50 Best American Restaurants in St. Augustine

“One of the best in area.“

“Food was all very fast, and freshly made! Such a unique concept on serving too - all on a board which was definitely more enjoyable for our family!! Food was delicious and fresh (went for brunch). Family friendly as well. Definitely a hidden gem!“

“We went for lunch - everything and everyone was wonderful. The Fish Dip was the best we have had in St A.“

“my husband and I went there for the first time and it was such a great experience! Live music and the ambiance just fit the theme. The food was delicious! service was also on point. We didn't feel rushed. Definitely going back.“

“Last evening we had a delightful and delicious dinner. Rum pour was generous. JJ was our outstanding and friendly waitress. She made our dinner special with her attentiveness. We will continue to return to this gem and hope JJ is our waitress again.“

“We’ve been coming to Ruby Tuesday every Thursday for a long time now, and one of the biggest reasons we keep coming back is *Kat*. She is hands down the best server we’ve ever had — not just here, but anywhere.

Kat always greets us with a smile, remembers our usual orders, and goes above and beyond to make sure everything is perfect. Her attention to detail, professionalism, and genuine kindness make every visit feel like we’re dining with a friend. Even when the restaurant is busy, she never misses a beat and still gives us amazing service.

Kat truly makes Ruby Tuesday feel like a second home for us on Thursdays. We can’t say enough good things about her — she’s exceptional!

Thank you, Kat, for being the absolute best!

— Your Thursday regulars 💕“

“Spectacular experience! Great food, awesome service and wonderful atmosphere! Perfect date night!! (P.S. try the duck!)“

“I was on vacation when I saw this restaurant in St. Augustine FL. I saw the menu and said I have to go in and get something! I am a grilled cheese connoisseur and I make some good ones myself but oh my gosh, the grilled Mac and Cheese I had with I can't remember what kind of meat was AMAZING! So was the tomato soup! This amazing 70's music was playing inside and I was dancing waiting for my take out. It was so cool inside! They asked for my name and I told them. Little did I know when I came back in a few days later where we ate inside that time, that the man who waited on me 2 days before would remember me and call me by name! Holy cow! That was so cool! He said it was because I was dancing. I'm a dancer with 5 trophies so yeah, I was dancing to that good music but to remember me like that! If you love grilled Mac and Cheese or just grilled cheese in general and you love tomato soup, you have to eat here! I promise you will not be disappointed at all! Next time I want some Poutine and another sandwich! YUM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!“

“My love and I enjoyed breakfast at The West Egg. We primarily chose to go there based on the great reviews and the fact that they had keto options.

The service was wonderful. The woman who took our order and brought our food out was very friendly and knowledgeable. The food was perfectly cooked and delicious.

Seating is limited so we knew there was a possibility that we would get it to go if necessary. We were happy to sit right outside.

The reviews were correct!“

“A True Hidden Gem in St. Augustine The Collage exceeded all our expectations. We’ve visited St. Augustine many times, but this was our first time discovering this incredible restaurant, and what a find! We were celebrating our 21st anniversary and stumbled upon The Collage online. Thinking it would be quiet on a Wednesday night, we didn’t make a reservation. Despite being fully booked, Megan, the restaurant manager, went out of her way to accommodate us, which we truly appreciated. Our server, Franco, was warm, attentive, and very knowledgeable. The food was absolutely phenomenal from start to finish. We began with the beef carpaccio and watermelon salad; both beautifully prepared. For our main course, we each had the 8oz filet topped with gorgonzola sauce, and every bite was mouthwatering. Between courses, we were treated to a refreshing raspberry sorbet to cleanse our palates—a lovely touch. For dessert, we shared a warm pound cake with raspberry coulis and fresh whipped cream, paired with perfectly made espressos. The ambiance was quaint, cozy, and romantic,ideal for a special occasion like ours. We especially loved that the menu changes regularly, offering something new to look forward to each time. We’re so happy to have found this gem and will absolutely be returning. Highly recommended! Thanks Again, The Gennaro’s“

“Amazing food and great service! I have never had a bad meal from here. The portions are absolutely HUGE.“

“Fantastic dinner, loved the place and Shane our server was AWESOME!!!“

“Had an amazing evening at the Forgotten Tonic. The drinks were creative and well made. The food was to die for, we are considering replacing pumpkin pie with pumpkin bread pudding at Thanksgiving this year thanks to our experience. The whole night was enhanced by our lovely server Tamara. She was professional, knowledgeable, and an absolute angel. We will be returning in the future and recommending The Forgotten Tonic to anybody who cares to listen.“

“Delicious food!! so glad we saw this place while turning around in the parking lot. the food was fresh and absolutely yummy. definitely will be going there again! had the turkey bacon sandwich on a bed of lettuce instead and added avocado. wow! and the sweet potato fries were cooked to perfection.“

“Delicious & perfect!! Great service too“

“We have been visiting our local Culver's a little more frequently, and each time we go in, the staff is extremely friendly to us and accurate with our orders. We even forgot to mention specifics for a concrete mixer custard, and instead of giving us attitude, they just made it happen. Great staff and great food (quality and quantity). We will definitely be going here from now on for our fast food needs.“

“Best food around and great service! Can’t wait to come back!“

“I went to visit the area first time, the service received from (Andrew) our server was amazing, friendly and attentive. Food and atmosphere was great, prices reasonable. Will definitely come back!“

“We had a wonderful experience here and the dining area so pristine. Delicious eats and we also loved our waitress. Went with my sister and her boyfriend. Parking was great . Overall just a good time!“

“We accidentally discovered The Backyard at Meehan's during the Trolly Tour of St. Augustine. It's very casual, with both indoor and outdoor seating. We had lunch: clam chowder, bacon cheeseburger and conch salad - everything was really good. We were happily surprised because we didn't know anything about the place before seeing it on the tour. There is a bar available if you're interested, we didn't partake,so have no opinions. Our Server was friendly, gave recommendations, and took really good care of us. Food was yummy and moderately priced.“

“The food was absolutely delicious. We tried the escargot and definitely did not regret it. The atmosphere in the once past pool was a different experience. Quiet, romantic and simply beautiful. Our waitress was phenomenal and cared to our every need. We can’t wait to come back.“

“Always friendly service and delicious food at the Amelia Island location!“

“Best Italian restaurant in St Augustine by far. Food was delicious, staff was fantastic and the owners are from my home state of NJ. What more can you ask for ?? My wife and I will definitely be coming back !!“

“Yes, unless they change it like they said.“

“The staff all throughout this hotel was remarkable. From front desk, valet, restaurant to pool…everyone was so kind, courteous, helpful and just fun! Amazing hotel that we highly recommend and will definitely be back!“

“Stopped in here for an after dinner drink. Service was friendly and attentive. Atmosphere was warm and peaceful even though their were other groups around. If you're looking for a place to talk while having food or a beverage, I highly recommend.“

“The atmosphere was nice. Our waitress was fun. We tried the sliders, Bleu cheese burger and the golf ball appetizer. Everything was delicious! The food came quickly and the drinks kept coming. Lots of Bill Murray memorabilia.“

“Evening food and service are top notch. The present crew: Stephanie, Cecelia and Jordan are the absolute best with friendly service, not to mention a great chef, kitchen, staff and management. Could do a little better on architectural ambiance, mood lighting and seating...“

“Ordered food from there yesterday and it was amazing! The jerk chicken quesadilla was outstanding and the three taco combo was phenomenal! BBQ super tender. Shrimp - super fresh. Highly, highly recommend. Was enough for two meals!“

“Little Margie’s is the best place to visit in St. Augustine Beach. Very family oriented and friendly. Food is fantastic as is Margie herself and everyone I’ve met in the restaurant. Highly recommend for breakfast/brunch/lunch/dinner😊“

“A group of us went to Sonnys on the Fourth of July for lunch. The ribs were very good some said the best they’ve ever had. I had the big meal deal with the beef sandwich and the beef was very tender. Service was great. Only thing we miss is the salad bar🥲“

“A great locals spot that also caters to the tourists. Live music too!“

“Great place please bring back your pork fritter sandwiches those were amazing“

“Just great place to go and good food“

“Food was amazing!!!“

“For the price, you can't top this place. Sushi was roughly as good as that you'd find at 150% of the menu prices here. It's not going to blow your mind or be the best sushi you ever ate, but it's still good sushi for crazy low prices.“

“I love that they use tallow to deep fry their food, the craft cocktails are amazing, highly recommend the hibiscus margarita. Also the service is awesome here. ❤️“

“Tiktok Bullrider726. Started with Gator, it was absolutely phenomenal! Then had the calamari, crab burger and crab legs, everything was cooked perfectly 👌 The datil sauce was so incredible, bought a couple jars of it. The staff was friendly and answered all our questions. 1st trip in, will not be the last!“

“Had the chicken with biscuits and gravy! Delicious! The chicken tenders were delicious! Very friendly staff. Will stop here everytime we are in the area.“

“Hands down some of the best chicken and waffles I have ever had! The strawberry butter is amazing. No use for syrup on waffles. Our waitress was great too!“

“We had Sporks cater our wedding December 14, 2024, and they did a phenomenal job! Miles and Libby were so helpful. The food and service was phenomenal - plus we love their restaurant too! Highly recommend them if you have a function that needs catering!“

“Kara was an excellent waitress always friendly always gives good recommendations. Excellent even in suggestion of bar drinks and willing to go the extra mile to make the customer happy.🩷“

“Service was awesome! Vinny“

“Always a pleasure and treat at Mango Mango - we have been going frequently since it opened. The service is cheerful and accommodating, food is excellent - love the fish dinner- and moderately price. Can't get much better casual dining“

“We had an awesome server (older lady I wish I could remember her name!). Everyone was happy with their food, the atmosphere, and they sat 8 people at a nice large ROUND table :) Kid friendly as child was given kids menu with crayons which kept her happy the whole time :)

Kid-friendliness: Wonderful to children“

“This is a hidden gem, so I’ll type type quietly. The food here is fresh, tasty and good looking! I had the salmon salad. The salmon was fresh with a smoky flavor. Bottom was nicely done with-a brown crisp to it Home made salad dressing was tossed with the salad. Salad had greens,capons , mushrooms, red onion, cheese and a very good flavor. Hubby had the shrimp wrap with a spinach tortilla. Delightful flavor all around“

“Not usually a big fan of waffle house but this one was the best with the best waitress. I can't remember her name but she was so friendly and fun. I think he name may have been something different. It maybe it was lily. But she was awesome.“

“Dined there last evening July 13,2023. There were 4 of us and the meal was very good. We were very impressed with the service provided to us by Lindsey. She and one other lady were the only ones waiting tables. Lindsey went way above her duties to handle customers. I hope that the manager of this Applebee's appreciate this worker who went out of her way to provide excellent service and that the cooperate office acknowledges good employees.“

“Met a wonderful young lady Missy while strolling St Augustine who recommended Keke's for breakfast. Boy was she right! Great food! Service was prompt and friendly. Highly recommend this restaurant. Thanks for the tip to go there Missy!“