Custom Cakes in St. Augustine, FL

“The cheesecakes are simply the best. The pound cakes are delightful, I can’t wait to order more treats.“

“Dropped in last week for a sweet treat and was delighted to find such creative flavors presented so beautifully. The pistachio was delicious and the filling a tasty surprise. Looking forward to my next visit!“

“Above and Beyond Doesn't Even Begin to Cover It.
Finding a baker who genuinely cares about what goes into their ingredients is rare, but finding someone like Nicole is an absolute blessing.
As a parent, you always want the absolute best for your children’s birthdays, and Nicole gone above and beyond every single time. Simple sugars organic bakery has now made three separate cakes for us. Every single time, she has completely blown us away. Her custom creations are nothing short of works of art, but what makes Simple Sugars Organic Bakery truly miraculous is that everything is completely organic and 100% dye-free.
To find cakes and cupcakes that are completely safe and free of artificial dyes is hard enough, but for them to taste amazing too is unbelievable! It’s almost impossible to describe. They are, hands down, the most delicious, moist, and flavorful cakes we have ever tasted. Nicole proves that you don't have to compromise on health or quality to have an absolutely stunning, mouth-watering dessert.
Beyond her incredible baking talent, Nicole herself is just an amazing, kind-hearted person who pours her soul into her craft. She doesn't just bake cakes; she helps create core childhood memories for our family. Three cakes later, and she has a customer for life.
If you are looking for a baker in St. Augustine, who offers unmatched quality, incredible flavor, and a genuine care for her clients, look no further than simple sugars organic bakery. Thank you Nicole for making our celebrations so sweet, memorable, and worry-free!“

“These cupcakes are probably the best I have had in a very long time. Thank the Good Lord I do not live nearby. I would be 50 pounds heavier. They are excellent. The first bite truly was not my last. The flavor and the batter so rich and delightful. Thank you. Your shop is as cute as a button.“

“Free ice cream my name was Eric need I say more. I will it was delicious thanks!“