“This is THE best cheesecake I have ever eaten. Better than Juniors, or any other NY cheesecake, baked or otherwise; even better than my grandma's Italian ricotta cheesecake. So having said that -- obviously there are different types! We all have our favorites. I much prefer my own homemade over my bff's - whose cheesecake tastes like a refrigerator cheesecake, but she claims she makes the best. Don't tell her I said hers is so-so. And when it comes to turn-off-the-oven-and-leave-it for two more hours Italian ricotta six eggs grandma Dearie's, well mine is now the best - my Dad agreed. Grated lemon, ricotta, cream cheese and mascarpone, and dash of almond extract- Zwieback for the hint of a crust- a 4 generation recipe from Naples, adapted by my dad, perfected by moi. But for a creamy, dreamy taste of - well, heaven on earth, nobody does cheesecake like Heavenly!!! I will never bake another! My friend Flossy and I could easily sit down with 2 forks and polish one off in a single sitting. The cakes are pricey, but those who bake using prime ingredients will understand. We tried the raspberry but both of us prefer plain- nothing but cheesecake. They do sell other flavors if you prefer. So good, so dreamy, so creamy, so Heavenly!!! PS they also sell cookies, scones, breads, frozen cheesecakes on a stick coated in chocolate & now individual sizes! It's a tiny shop tucked into a corner of the produce shop on US1 near Fort Mose in the same lot as Kyle's Seafood, so a great shopping stop! Great guys with a great sense of humor.“
“I can not recommend this bakery highly enough! We purchased a birthday cake. The cakes decoration was breathtaking! The first question of us who enjoyed it and everyone to whom we showed pictures of it was “does it taste as good as it looks?” The answer: even better!!! Thanks for making an important birthday celebration extra special!“
“Cute upscale bakery in uptown St. Augustine. Gluten free Whoopie pie was to die for. You would never know it was gluten free. My sister had the Carrot Cupcake. So moist and delicious! I'll go back tomorrow to try a breakfast sandwich along with a cupcake! A definite stop when in St. Augustine!“
“While walking around, my sister and I saw Ben & Jerrys and decided that ice cream sounded good. I have Celiac so I went in not expecting to find much to choose from. I asked the girl behind the counter if she knew what was gluten free (I was expecting her to say no). She pulled a list out of everything gluten free and it was a long list. She assured me that they would open a new ice cream container, use a new scoop and new gloves to make sure there was no cross contamination. I highly recommend this place as they obviously train their employees extremely well. I will certainly be making another stop to this Ben & Jerrys when I return to St. Augustine. Thank you for such an amazing experience. You have a new customer for life.“
“We ordered a birthday cake for my twin granddaughters second birthday and had a lot of requests from snowflakes to egg free but Dana exceeded all of our expectations and then some. The cake (coconut with coconut cream) looked absolutely amazing and was one of the most delicious cakes we've ever had. Even the non believers in an egg free cake were converted. Dana I can't thank you enough you are a true artist.Dietary restrictions: Egg free“