26 Best Bakeries in Tallahassee

“I have been rocking with my girl since day 1..she walking through our parking lot selling cookies and my came n told said since u like sweets so much it's a young lady out her selling cookies..WELL I BROUGHT A JUMBO RED VELVET WHITE MACADAMIA COOKIE AND OMG ‼️‼️‼️this young lady definitely does her thing wen it comes to dessert n her BROOKIE BROWNIES...#1MY GIRL SUGAR RUSH....“

“I have never had Crumble before, my family all sat around together and tried for the 1st time. I can say, they were a Go for us. Thank You to the staff for being so nice too.“

“the cookies here are absolutely incredible, sometimes they are all I think about“

“If your looking for high quality, delectable taste, visually appealing, out of this world PERFECTION.... look no further! This beautiful soul of a women has you covered. From her professionalism, talent, communication, kind heart, and so much more. We personally know the Andrew's, and can say without a doubt, these folks deserve the highest recommendations, and recognition possible. we can't thank you enough for the joy you brought to our families on there special days! ❤️“

“Wonderful, caring staff and owner is so personable and always recognizes me. Cakes are so tasty! A must try!“

“I order a Sonic theme birthday cake for my son’s 5th birthday and showed the owner of Capital City Caked, LLC a picture of what I was looking for. Not only did they design the cake like the picture I sent, the cake was also amazingly good. The cake was very moist and easy to cut. The owner was very responsive in communicating in a timely manner. I will definitely be ordering from them again.“

“Every time I come into this store, I am always pleased with how clean the store is, and how amazing the cookies taste! The Employees are always super kind, and helpful! Emma is always there when I go in, and she is so fun to chat with while she gets my cookies ready!“

“Great food, great service and great place for a get together 💛“

“Thank you so much for the gorgeous back to school cookies! Not only were beautiful but they tasted great. Thanks again!“

“We took our little girl Sofia (she is a Puppy) for her very first Grooming per recommendation of a friend 😊. We had an amazing experience with their friendly staff ,the lady at the front desk listened to all our request and took notes of it ; she was very loving and attentive to our Sofie. At pick up time, we also meet her groomer Chantal. Sofie was happy on her arms and she gave us a feed back on how good she did 💜. Sofie looks amazing with the poodle puppy cut that we requested , and also smell great after the bath. I love the place and I will recommend it 💯 Thank youuu Lakeside Grooming“

“Omg!!!! This place is stupid good!!! The cream cheese brownie was delicious. Hubby loved their pistachio muffins & we equally loved the cinnamon rolls so much that we will be back tomorrow when they open! Those cinnamon rolls will make your eyes cross!“

“amazing pretzles and a wonderful crew“

“I come here every Monday or every other Monday to get my favorite version of Dave's Killer Bread for $3.50/loaf. This time it hadn't been delivered yet by noon; that happens occasionally. At least I was able to get Raisin the Roof and other versions remaining from Friday's delivery.“

“Zaks Mac is definitely a pioneer in the future of business, the very definition of a locally owned, Upon receiving confirmation of my order I was given the response, that we’re all in this together ❤️, during the time of this pandemic it is small things like this that remind us that we’re all human outside of it all..... HIGHLY RECOMMENDED“

“Been going for years, it's always a fantastic pick me up. Divine food and sweet staff.“

“Artistic Creations made the cake for my daughter’s baby shower this past weekend. It was just amazing. The fondant work was incredibly smooth, with NO bumps or divots. The cake itself was moist, and the buttercream was delicious. Every cake we have bought in the past, has ended up mostly in the garbage due to the icing being cloyingly sweet. This cake was so good, my son in law insisted on bringing the leftovers home. I highly recommend Artistic Confections for all your cake needs. They definitely have us as customers for life!“

“They’re delicious . The cakes were soft and very tasty. Nice clean atmosphere with friendly staff.“

“amazing dessert and coffee drinks“

“So today on January 17th my husband went to Governor Square mall in Tallahassee...we live in ft Walton beach Florida...but he got us a 6 pack of Cinnabons...brought them all the way back here for me to have a taste...dude!!!!..these are the most delicious ones I've ever tasted....hot or cold...and they gave us Xtra icing....omg....love this place..we will forever come back....thank you!!!!!“

“Outstanding service, roasted-on-the-premises (you can watch) coffee, and made-from-scratch baked goodies. What’s not to like? 5/5.“

“Some of the cookies are very good in flavor. But the texture is monotone. It lacks that crunchy edge that a cookie needs.
The atmosphere is charming but needs to have chairs accessible for waiting.
Strawberry milk and pistachio are my favorite flavors.“

“Absolutely amazing food!! Excellent service!! I will definitely be back!! Wonderful family owned business!!“

“My last two birthday cakes have come from Q-Ti Cakes and they were both to die for. Q-Ti Cakes makes custom cakes in just about any flavor you can think of and they are absolutely incredible. This is a raspberry cake with buttercream and lemon curd and it blew my mind. Do yourself a favor and get a cake from here for your next birthday or event.“

“I walked into TC Bakery on a day when I was running on fumes—physically and emotionally. What I found there wasn’t just good food, but two absolute angels behind the counter. And here’s the part that still blows my mind: they weren’t even open to the public at the time. It wasn’t regular business hours, yet they unlocked the door and let me in anyway.
They didn’t have to do that. They could’ve easily said “sorry, we’re closed.” Instead, they chose kindness.
Inside, I was met with nothing but genuine compassion, patience, and warmth. No rush, no judgment—just real human care. They talked to me, listened, smiled, and helped keep my spirit upright when it very easily could’ve collapsed. That kind of love sticks with you.
TC Bakery isn’t just a place to grab something to eat. It’s a place where people still see people. I’ll never forget how I was treated there, and I’m deeply grateful for those two souls who showed me love when I needed it most.
If you believe kindness matters, support this place. They’re doing it right.“

“The Cake Shop Bakery is an amazing local bakery that has a talented team who make delicious baked goods. They also donate countless amount of their wonderful baked goods to cancer patients every week. They are a truly compassionate partner in the Tallahassee community, and I am very thankful for all they do! I highly recommend The Cake Shop Bakery.“

“Lucky Goat Coffee is absolutely worth the stop off I-10!
We popped in and ordered an Oat Milk Latte and the Snowflake Crunch Latte—both were fantastic. The espresso is rich and smooth, and the oat milk latte had that perfect creamy balance without being overly sweet. The Snowflake Crunch was a fun surprise: velvety, lightly sweet, with a hint of hazelnut. If you’re a seasonal latte fan, this one is a must-try.

The café itself is clean, welcoming, and clearly loved by locals. There’s tons of merch, plus whole bean and ground coffee ready to take home—perfect if you want a taste of Lucky Goat in your own kitchen. Whether you’re fueling a road trip or looking for a great everyday coffee spot in Tallahassee, Lucky Goat Coffee delivers quality and personality.

If you’re driving along I-10 and need a great cup, this place is absolutely worth the diversion. Highly recommended for coffee lovers, travelers, and anyone who enjoys supporting a local favorite.“