50 Best Pizza Restaurants in Tampa

“Went there yesterday with my husband and daughters. That was by far the best pizza I've had!!!! The owner was soo nice & we promised we'd leave a review about the pizza & not the bathroom that's getting remodeled!!! Lol“

“That’s what I’m talking about!!! Great food! What a great menu!!! Looking forward to many great meals to come. Town and Country needed a legit Pizza spot and Tomato Joe’s delivers!!! 🙌🏼“

“Blaze pizza is the best customized pizza chain in the country. The ingredients are fresh and reliable every time. This location is so far the closest to me, and I am happy to drive an hour to get there.
Even with the influx of college students, they always make sure we're taken care of, I really appreciate that.“

“Great experience! Wow, pizza and breadsticks were amazing! Ashley was wonderful too at the Kissimmee location. Highly recommend this pizza company!!!“

“Nicest people i’ve met, they always do right by me when I come in and the food is always good!

Vegetarian options: There’s all types of toppings from meat to veggies

Parking: In a plaza

Kid-friendliness: small pizzas that are filling even for me!

Wheelchair accessibility: Straight forward from door to counter“

“I'm delighted with this place. The food is delicious, pure, and authentic Italian flavor. A clean place with first-class service. The freshness of the ingredients is palpable. This place is my favorite for Italian food. And most importantly, prepared to your liking!!🥰💯“

“By far best pizza we have ever had! Also great service and cool environment.“

“Flash back to 1988. This is your nostalgic pizza joint, just by a different name. This place is exactly the chain pizza place that used to be awesome in 1988. A place to gather with family and friends around a fresh salad followed by a trademark pan pizza.

Go for the Supreme Pizza (House Special on this menu) or Meat Lovers for that perfect piece of nostalgia. Start with a Greek Salad. The 80s music playing in the background, the stained glass lamps, and the overall vibe is perfect for memory lane. Only missing the Ms Packman or Donkey Kong arcade game near the entrance and a slight change to the interior colors to cause a memory lane melt down.

As for the salad, spot on... go with the Greek Salad. Potato salad optional. I prefer to skip the potato salad. The Mini Greek is perfect sized for one or two.

As for the pizza. Pizza is in the name of this place for a reason. If you loved the chain I am referencing in the late 70s and 80s and early 90s... you are in for a treat! And if you never had it back then, you can have it here now. And if you miss it (as it is not the same as it used to be), this place will win your heart.

Nice family place with great servers as well. Eeyroe gives this a 5 out of 5 for the memories. I'm going for a 4 out of 5 for the Greek Salad and Pizza complimented by the 80s vibes.

This place and the pizza is a timeless classic.“

“Great taste,tostadita en los bordes y suave en el cuerpo.La recomiendo.“

“We LOVE everything on the Lebanese menu! Staff is so sweet. We can’t stay away!“

“HOT Rock Pizza. Love it i’m from Jersey I’m a Jersey guy, so I know good pizza when I see it. At the barbecue chicken pizza on the money. I will definitely be back. 🙌🏽“

“They are open until 2 AM which is great! The crust is not pre-made or prefrontal, he spins it right in front of you. We had the Orr, pepperoni with pesto and honey Sriracha drizzle. The pesto was not overwhelming and the drizzle was the perfect amount of spicy and sweet. The Italian working there never stopped and worked quickly to fill orders. I noticed they had a Cauliflower crust option! Prices are great! Make sure you give them a try!“

“Great Service! Everyone is great! I always feel like family! I from NY and the Pizza is as close to home as I can find. Always keep coming back. I strongly recommend. Thanks Taste of NY.“

“Best place for just pizza wings and beer!“

“Was in the area i live in Sarasota but i always went to different cuban pizza places this place happened to be close to me and the reviews were beautiful so i came to El Recreo , i was pleased when I pulled up to be surrounded by beautiful green trees in this concrete jungle. My husband and i ordered, one chorizo pizza, a pepperoni pizza, a spaghetti a mango smoothie. I am always unimpressed by Cuban food in this area but…. Everything was perfect wow I will definitely be back“

“Great place to eat, the best vegan food in Florida. Absolutely best pizza I’ve ever eaten. The owner was so helpful to my wife Rose, explaining everything and taking care of us. We are from middle Tennessee but we will be back. All looking for a better place to eat healthy and great tasting food don’t miss this place.“

“Great all around thin crust pizza. Very consistent. Simple. No issues. Service is great when the kids (under 22) aren't working. Otherwise it's very monotone and feels like a machine. Don't let that steer you away. Simple really good pizza. End of story. Thats it.“

“This place deserves 100 ⭐️ ! We are visiting from Tennessee and this restaurant was close to where we were spending our day so we decided to give it a whirl. From the time we walked in the door to the time our bellies were full we had an amazing experience. Not knowing the menu or area our server Tara went over everything on the menu with us and was very patient with us while we decided on what to order. The pizza was amazing and the crust was just right. Service was top tier and we will be coming back again very soon ! Thank you again NYNY Pizza for going above and beyond to make our trip to Tampa even better!“

“quick service. friendly staff. authentic. delicious!“

“Thank you so much Eddie & Sam’s for correcting (re sending it out for us) our order being delivered to the children’s hospital when it wasn’t your fault the delivery driver did not drop it off. Once it was delivered the second time it did not disappoint it was honestly the best pizza I’ve ever had! I will be craving this pizza for days unfortunately I like to fair but will always get this anytime I’m in town! Thank you! ❤️“

“Very good we have been trying all the pizza around here and this is one of the best so far“

“Best services ever and very polite“

“Delicious authentic NY pizza! We’ve come multiple times and their food is always consistently delicious regardless of time of day. Fast service and friendly employees“

“This pizza place is a true hidden gem. The portions are generous, loaded with fresh toppings, and every slice is bursting with flavor. The crust is that ideal balance of crispiness on the outside and lightness on the inside — exactly what great pizza should be. On top of that, the prices are incredibly convenient, which makes the whole experience even better. It’s honestly one of the most underrated spots I’ve been to, and it absolutely deserves more recognition. If you love pizza, don’t sleep on this place!“

“the food was amazing along with the selection of choices. the price is on point.“

“Being a Connecticut Resident for 50 years, I was so happy to know they opened a Colony grill in Tampa. It was just as good as back home. The staff was very friendly. I highly recommend.“

“Not sure how to feel, because the pizza itself was really good. When I arrived, I waited about five minutes at the counter before realizing the person working was off to the side.

I ordered the “special”, which includes a pizza, one topping, and a drink for $14. I clearly requested that, but was charged 17$ as charged separately for the pizza and drink. Then they forgot to give me the drink… and even questioned me about whether they’ve already given me the drink.

To top it off, after finishing my meal, they refused to let me throw away my pizza box and told me to take it with me and use a city trash can. Like… seriously? I tipped, ate at your place, used your table, and now I’m also responsible for waste management?

Great pizza… maybe the homie was having a bad day. 5 star pizza… 1 star experience. 4 star overall.“

“Almost 2 years in business and their pizza is my personal favorite! Very high quality and delicious! Awesome job“

“I moved to Tampa from NYC in 1982 and this is the first place in the Bay area where I have eaten a really good slice of Sicilian style pizza!“

“Delicious food, flawless service! We used Johnny C’s for a corporate luncheon, and they absolutely knocked it out of the park! The trays of pasta were hot and fresh, the meatballs were a crowd favorite, and the garlic knots disappeared within minutes. Picked up was on time and the setup was effortless due to the trays being ready to go! Highly recommend for any event—you won’t be disappointed!“

“Thanks Angel for the amazing time. You made our anniversary eve dinner a wonderful one, thumbs up!!!“

“Ordered a pizza online at 9 am for pickup at 5:15 pm. When I got there they told me it would be a 20 minute wait as ours was 3 tickets back. I asked why it wasn't ready and the guy called me a "Karen" and laughed. Will not be back again.“

“Best pizza in Westchase area!“

“good pizza 🍕 good prices 😋good service 👍“

“The best pizza in town. The atmosphere is amazing in additional to Pizza. They have Latin Food with great entertainment and extremely reasonable pricing.“

“Stop what you're doing right now and order from Alfonso's! the garlic knots are HUGE and are absolutely delicious. I will dream about these when I go back home. The pizza is to die for, and everything was so fresh and amazing. You can feel the family's love for this business even before you order, just by watching everyone interact with each other. There is a reason they've been open as long as they have been, and it shows all over their food. And don't leave without dessert!“

“Best pizza I've had in awhile. Pinellas has 1 that is authentic; this place was fantastic. Staff were so nice. If going to concert eat here first!!“

“I hired Tampa Bay Food Truck to cater my neighborhood Halloween Party. This was my first time using a Food truck for a party I was hosting. Tisha Penzato the Sales and Account Manager set me all up through phone calls, emails and texts. She made it so easy to book the event and she was very thorough throughout the process.
The guys in the Food truck showed up on time and served my halloween party with no issues. I picked mexican themed food and it was a hit at the party! The food was delicious, hot, and served quickly! I would highly recommend this company if you’re looking for a food truck company to cater an event you’re hosting. I know I will definitely hire them again for upcoming events!“

“We have been going there for years and is always great food, great people, and always a family favorite.“

“I always favor simple pizza sauce over heavily seasoned sauce. Westchase scores big for me there. I think they come closer to NY pizza than any other in the Westchase/Waterchase area. For close to home great pizza using fresh ingredients, this is my go-to.“

“Turning 21 and celebrating at Cali was the best combination! I got a free cookie to celebrate! Tay as always was incredible and just brought a smile to my day! Cam was also stellar in making my day so special! Cam was training but frankly I could’ve sworn she was already an active staff member, she was amazing! Joe even came by to stop by and was so sweet! We also spoke with Adam as he dropped off our Hummus and he came with smiles and compliments. What an amazing staff!! Not to mention the food was heavenly! I had an excellent time!🫶🥹“

“Excellent service and amazing pizza. We stumbled upon this place today at lunch and so happy we stopped. Seriously the BEST pizza I’ve had in a really long time and the customer service is out of this world. I highly recommend this place. I know we will definitely be back for years to come.“

“Best pizza“

“Good afternoon it was a mix up with an online item . I went inside the store and the Gentleman was very nice and pleasant and polite and listen to the problem I had with my purchase . He read over the receipt I showed him what I purchased on the app . It was totally wrong . But he made sure I was pleased when I left . He remade my pizza . I’m very pleased . It was hot a fresh a tasted amazing . Thank you i am assuming that’s the manager didn’t catch a name . Best regards S.Knighton“

“Had an exquisitely nice afternoon with the fellas after a long day of intense yoga and palates. Pizza smelled amazing but because I am on the Paleo/Keto thing, I just stuck to the tasty meatballs. Next time I hope the sausage come with the meatballs.“

“my husband and I came across this place and I'm so.glad...we were greeted very nicely, the food was prepared in a timely manner. but mostly it was delicious. everything we ordered was yummy. we ordered hummus/ pita, falafel, grape leaves, gyros and baklava, we also got 2 smoothies they were absolutely delicious. it was recommended by the gentleman that took my order, he said it was his favorite. geez I didn't get his name. going to have to come back...“

“I have been in tampa for 12 years, moved from N.Y,,,. Pizza has been one of my biggest struggles... Cappys by far is the closest to N.Y pizza I've had yet.. Great food, Great service,and great price!!“

“Ok. I am not a reviewer. Pretty much ever. I’m barely even a commenter on social media. HOWEVER. Exceptions must be made. Tonight I ordered pizza from Westshore, not because I had no dinner plan, but mostly because by the time I got finished fighting all the harpies at Homegoods and Target to finish my Mother’s Day shopping, I no longer cared. Hence, when it took me OVER 30 MINUTES to complete my on-line order due to bugs in their website, I was pretty annoyed, and recalled why I haven’t ordered from them in over a year bc their online ordering is literally a dumpster fire of issues, and I only order pizza anyway when I’m over it and refuse to cook. Nevertheless, I persevered, completed my order, and emerged victorious with a few dollars saved using online coupons and a screen shot of my order confirmation that stated a pick up time of 7:25:16 pm. Pretty specific. So my husband arrived at 7:26 pm, only to receive lukewarm (albeit tasty) pizza, and to be greeted by a sign that read: 14 inch pizzas, BOGO. Obviously, upon learning this I immediately wanted to know why the three pizzas I bought were not subject to this deal, since it is not listed on their website (in fact a bogo coupon that is listed doesn’t work), and I ordered 2 14 inch pizzas and 1 18 inch pizza. Reluctantly, I called the store to ask about the promo, expecting to learn my husband had been mistaken. Nope. 14 inch pizzas, BOGO. Umm. But…. I began to stutter out my explanation of why this was unfair, blah blah blah… bad website blah blah blah… took me 30 minutes to order online blah blah blah… cold pizza blah blah—and do you know what? The manager (owner) didn’t even listen to my whole story. He COMPLETELY COMPED MY ENTIRE ORDER before I could even fully explain. I didn’t even want the whole order comped— I just wanted him to honor the bogo promo not listed online. He told me it was already done and Happy Mother’s Day, so at that point all I could really do was thank him and swallow my indignation along with a slice of tasty veggie pizza. I think he said his name is Mike. I think he said that he just purchased this franchise and is still trying to turn things around. He asked me to follow his store on social media, and said he understood why I gave up on them over a year ago, even though I do like their pizza and salads. Wings are good too actually. I was a bit surprised by this entire exchange to be honest, given the fact that I spent some of my day reporting the $400 that was stolen from my checking account by identity thieves, and the rest of my day weaving my way through over privileged ladies in tropical prints who consider shopping to be a competitive blood sport. I’m not jaded. I’m just tired. So, thank you very much Mike for comping my family’s dinner when you didn’t have to, and thank you for surprising someone who is almost never surprised with your excellent customer service. I have lived in New Tampa for a long time, and it still amazes me that I can patronize the same mom and pop small businesses for years (food, coffee, nails, car wash, dry cleaners— whatever) and the owners/ managers rarely acknowledge that they A) recognize you, and B) appreciate your business. You managed to accomplish both of these feats in a less than 2 minute phone call. I look forward to ordering your pizza more often, and I am actually impressed. I think your chances of success are strong if this is the way you treat your customers. I will be back, and will be recommending Westshore Pizza New Tampa to my friends.“

“Best place to come and relax after a long day. Food is made fast and fresh. Great people. Love to take care of their first responders“