New American Restaurants near Tavernier, FL

Capt Craig's Restaurant Seafood • $$
90154 Overseas Hwy, Tavernier

Customers` Favorites

Famous Fish Sandwich Blackened
World Famous Fish Sandwich
Craig's Grouper Sandwich
Chicken Tender with Fries
Blackened Mahi Tacos
Stone Crab Chowder
Smoked Fish Dip
Fried Calamari
Lobster Bisque
Stone Crab Soup

“Of course the seafood is downright delicious at Captain Craig’s Restaurant. What was unexpected is the sublime homemade key lime pie. It is the real deal, complete with a beautiful toasted meringue topping on this glorious rendition of this classic dessert. If you have no room for dessert, I recommend ordering a piece of the pie to go.“

4.6 Superb193 Reviews
Square Grouper Islamorada New American • $$
80460 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada - 10.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepita & Parmesan Encrusted Chicken Cutlet
Yellowfin Tuna & Avocado Eggrolls
Square Grouper Magical Brownie
House Square Grouper Sandwich
Seared Sesame Encrusted Tuna
Grilled Oysters Rockefeller
Square Grouper Seafood Stew
Kung Pao Brussel Sprouts
Classic Grouper Piccata
Chicken Wing Lollipops

“Excellent food and service. This is our favorite restaurant in Islamorada! I highly recommend!“

4.7 Superb351 Reviews
Sunset Lounge Tapas Bar • $$$
80460 Overseas Hwy 3rd Floor, Islamorada - 10.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Crispy Conch Steamed Buns
House Smoked Fish Dip
Oyster Platter
Lobster Roll
Disco Fries
Wedge Salad
Baked Brie

“Great Place! Great ambiance!“

4.8 Superb38 Reviews
Hobo's Cafe Seafood • $$
101691 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo - 9.4 miles

Customers` Favorites

Key Lime Chicken Sandwich
Key Lime Lobster Sandwich
Key Lime Fish Sandwich
Blackened Seafood Trio
Seasoned Waffle Fries
blk Mahi Quesadilla
Whole Key Lime Pie
Conch Fritters
Key Lime Style
Coconut Shrimp

“Expected a greasy diner experience - instead had a 2 star Michelin dinner. Service was prompt and courteous. Will definitely be coming back.“

4.7 Superb300 Reviews
C&C wood fire eats Pizza • $$
99201 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo - 6.99 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza with Basil and Truffle Oil
Prosciutto and Truffle
Truffle Pizza Micks
Pizza Cheese Pizza
Meatball & Ricotta
Charcuterie Board
Short Rib Lasagna
Neapolitan Pizza
Pizza Napolitana
Key Lime Parfait

“Best pizza I ever had. I’m 73 and I’ve had a lot to try . Best ever!“

4.6 Superb274 Reviews
Doc's Diner Diner • $
99696 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo - 7.52 miles

Customers` Favorites

Belgian Waffle Tropical Style with Bananas Pecans and Shredded Coconut
Italian Chocolate Chip Pancakes
The Champ with Corned Beef Hash
Daily Homemade Cinnamon Roll
Breakfast Burrito Grande
Great Breakfast Skillet
Bacon Eggs Hash Browns
Tropical French Toast
Hash Brown Casserole
Doc's Breakfast Wrap

“Doc’s Diner Key Largo 4-30-25 Stooped by for breakfast on Wednesday about 7:15 am. They were not that busy and we got a table right away. Our Waitress brought the coffee fast and we ordered our food right there. The waitress was very nice and so friendly and checked on us many times. I ordered the Country Fried Steak with Sausage Gravy, Hash Browns and 2 eggs over easy. My wife ordered 2 Eggs over easy with Toast. My dad ordered Sausage Gravy over biscuits. Our ordered came out fast and looked very good. All our food as hot and tasty. When we were done, we were full as they piled up our plates with plenty of food. I give this place a 4 out of 5 stars. When I’m in Key Largo I will not hesitate to go back here. Make sure you stop by as when we left it was full of locals. They know where the good food is and now you know. ⭐⭐⭐⭐ Follow Me On FB For More Reviews & Fun. Gulf Coast Terry“

4.6 Superb219 Reviews
Eco Eats Fast Food • $
99607 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo - 7.39 miles

Customers` Favorites

Waldorf Chicken Salad
Avocado Chicken Press
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Smoked Turkey Wrap
Organic Tofu Pita
The Harvest Pita
Chicken Wrap
Wraps
Gyros

“Every time I manage to make it here before work or on laundry day I'm always excited. the service is friendly you can tell the people here are actually kind and caring humans. The food is always amazing and the prices are so low the scale of quality to price is broken here you always get more than you pay for combine that with wanting to give these lovely humans more money and support and it's a win win, I just wish they were open more, but I understand and respect that they keep a healthy work life balance!“

4.7 Superb27 Reviews
Snappers Oceanfront Restaurant & Bar Seafood • $$
139 Seaside Ave, Key Largo - 2.45 miles

Customers` Favorites

Camarones Empanados
Sweet Potato Fries
Lobster Bisque
Conch Fritters
Coconut Shrimp
Fish and Chips
Fish Sandwich
Seafood Tacos
Mahi Sandwich
Conch Chowder

“Stopped there for lunch….the place has been renovated and looks GREAT!….Food was amazing, very friendly staff….highly recommended!!!👍👍“

4.3 Superb437 Reviews
Ziggie & Mad Dog's Seafood • $$$
83000 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada - 8.59 miles

Customers` Favorites

Coach Shula's Barbeque Bacon Wrapped Shrimp
Lobster Tail and White Truffle Mac & Cheese
Ziggie's Classic Lobster Bisque
Hot Molten Lava Birfday Cake
Garlic Salted Onion Rings
Phyllo Encrusted Escargot
Cowboy Cut Bone-In Ribeye
Crabmeat Stuffed Snapper
Phyllo Crusted Escargot
Garlic Salt Onion Rings

“The food and service are exceptional! They made our anniversary dinner so special for us! We love the food! We will be back!“

4.3 Superb193 Reviews
Tides Beachside Bar & Grill Seafood • $
82100 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada - 9.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mango Shrimp Tacos
Islander Burger
Conch Fritters
Key Lime Pie
Tuna Nicoise

“Einfach Wunderbar 🌴💚 I'm freien sitzen und auf das Meer schauen, essen lecker, leider alles in Plastik serviert“

4.1 Good26 Reviews
Hog Heaven Sports Bar and Grill Bar & Grill • $
85361 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada - 6.33 miles

Customers` Favorites

Panino Con Carne Di Maiale Nella Ciotola Insalata Con Salsa
Ultimate Hog Heaven BBQ Sampler
Windley Key Chicken Sandwich
Homestyle Mac N Cheese
Brisket Deviled Eggs
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Key West Street Corn
BBQ Pulled Pork
SD Pulled Pork
Bacon Wrapped

“We loved this restaurant! Super laid back atmosphere, delicious food, great music, fair pricing, great view of the ocean! Definitely recommend!!“

4.2 Good310 Reviews