15 Best Italian Restaurants in Columbus

Browse menus, reviews and photos of Italian Restaurants in Columbus.

Showing 15 of 16 restaurants

  • Mabella's | Italian Steakhouse 14 11th Street, Columbus Italian · $$$

    1 Mabella's | Italian Steakhouse

    4.6 Superb 479 Reviews

    14 11th Street, Columbus

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Fillet Mignon with Shaved Brussel Sprouts and Baked Potato
    • Pistachio Crusted Florida Grouper
    • Chef's Board Red Sangria Moscato
    • Grilled New Zealand Lamb Chops

    “From the moment we walked in, the service was warm and attentive without being overbearing. The ambiance was cozy yet elegant, perfect for a special night out. My food was bursting with flavor, beautifully presented, and made with high-quality ingredients. The chef clearly takes pride in their work. Highly recommend this gem—definitely coming back!”

  • Caffe Amici 2301 Airport Thruway e2, Columbus Italian · $$

    2 Caffe Amici

    4.5 Superb 257 Reviews

    2301 Airport Thruway e2, Columbus

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Garlic Bread or Ciabatta
    • Homemade Creme Brulee
    • Florentine Cheese Dip
    • Mozzarella Triangles

    “The food is outstanding and so is the service!! Will be back again soon!”

  • Gabagool 1232 Broadway, Columbus Italian · $$

    3 Gabagool

    4.6 Superb 163 Reviews

    1232 Broadway, Columbus

    • Delivery

    “Stayed in Columbus, Ga. to attend a military graduation. Stumbled upon this restaurant by sheer accident. The staff was amazing, the food was exceptional and the price was well worth the experience!”

  • Mabella Italian Steakhouse Midland 6835 Midland Cmns Boulevard Ste East, Columbus Italian · $$

    4 Mabella Italian Steakhouse Midland

    4.5 Superb 187 Reviews

    6835 Midland Cmns Boulevard Ste East, Columbus

    Customers’ favorites

    • Mezzi Pacherri w Volka Sauce and Gulf Shrimps
    • NY Sirloin Steak Fries and Mashed Potatoes
    • Whole Cheesecake with Strawberries
    • Porcini Crusted New York Strip

    “We frequent the Midland location and love it! The food is amazing, the service is great, and the cheesecake is to die for! Katie is the best bartender who instantly makes you feel welcomed, and makes sure you have a great experience every time!”

  • Carrabba's Italian Grill 5555 Whittlesey Boulevard Ste H, Columbus Italian · $$

    5 Carrabba's Italian Grill

    4.3 Superb 541 Reviews

    5555 Whittlesey Boulevard Ste H, Columbus

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Chicken Parmesan with Fettuccine Alfredo
    • Mama Mandola's Sicilian Chicken Soup
    • Tuscan-Grilled Sirloin
    • Cannoli Cake for Two

    “Food was great, server was attentive and friendly atmosphere.”

  • Olive Garden Italian Restaurant 5555 G Whittlesey Boulevard, Columbus Italian · $$

    6 Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

    4.0 Good 527 Reviews

    5555 G Whittlesey Boulevard, Columbus

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Shrimp Alfredo Fettuccine Alfredo Tossed with Saut
    • Asiago Tortelloni Alfredo with Grilled Chicken
    • Never Ending Dipping Sauces for Breadsticks
    • Chicken & Shrimp Carbonara

    “The food was excellent, and our server was amazing (I wanna say her name was Jaina). Despite how new she was, she was very on top of her game, and my wife and I were happy to get her section, because that has been the best service we've gotten!”

  • Peluso's Italian Restaurant 4519 Woodruff Rd # 9, Columbus Italian · $

    7 Peluso's Italian Restaurant

    4.1 Good 111 Reviews

    4519 Woodruff Rd # 9, Columbus

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Thin Crust Pizza with Two Items
    • Spaghetti and Cheese
    • House Special Pizza
    • Two Items Calzone

    “I tried the Peluso Pasta Platter. It was not a disappointment. The food taste amazing!”

  • Peluso's Italian Restaurant 5600 Milgen Road, Columbus Italian · $

    8 Peluso's Italian Restaurant

    4.0 Good 194 Reviews

    5600 Milgen Road, Columbus

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Lasagna with Garlic Bread and Salad and Minestrone Soup
    • House Special Spaghetti with Sausage
    • Sliced Meatballs with Meat Sauce
    • Ham Salami and Cheese Hoagie

    “I tried the Peluso Pasta Platter. It was not a disappointment. The food taste amazing!”

  • Johnny's New York Style Pizza 6770 Veterans Parkway Ste D, Columbus Pizza · $

    9 Johnny's New York Style Pizza

    4.4 Superb 331 Reviews

    6770 Veterans Parkway Ste D, Columbus

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Calzone or Stromboli with 1 Regular Topping
    • Johnny's New York Style Pizza
    • Cheese Calzone or Stromboli
    • Traditional Cheese Pizza

    “everyone is polite. food is always pretty good. doesn't take forever”

  • Your Pie Pizza 1019 Broadway, Columbus Pizza · $

    10 Your Pie Pizza

    4.4 Superb 306 Reviews

    1019 Broadway, Columbus

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Build Your Own Pizza
    • Make Your Own Pizza
    • Pepperoni Pizza
    • Personal Pizza

    “We just finished our lunch at the Landings location and it was wonderful from beginning to the end. The very young staff was amazing! It was our pleasure to tip them, they were very informative, helpful and FUN to talk with. The pizzas were perfect and delicious. l can't wait to return and eat here again. Keep this staff and you have us for life! 5 stars all the way! Dan and Jennifer Dailey”

  • Deorio’s Pizza 1931 Auburn Avenue, Columbus Pizza · $

    11 Deorio’s Pizza

    4.3 Superb 125 Reviews

    1931 Auburn Avenue, Columbus

    Customers’ favorites

    • Side Salad with House Italian Dressing
    • Mushroom Onion and Pepperoni Pizza
    • Meatball Appetizer
    • Meat Lovers Pizza

    “Great service, food, and Friendly staff”

  • Your Pie Pizza 5592-L Whitesville Road, Columbus Pizza · $

    12 Your Pie Pizza

    4.2 Good 242 Reviews

    5592-L Whitesville Road, Columbus

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Wheat Crush with Broccoli and Chicken
    • Build Your Own Pizza
    • Broccoli and Cheese
    • Cheesy Alfredo Pasta

    “We just finished our lunch at the Landings location and it was wonderful from beginning to the end. The very young staff was amazing! It was our pleasure to tip them, they were very informative, helpful and FUN to talk with. The pizzas were perfect and delicious. l can't wait to return and eat here again. Keep this staff and you have us for life! 5 stars all the way! Dan and Jennifer Dailey”

  • Ramos italian restaurant and social event center 1607 South Lumpkin Road, Columbus Pizza · $

    13 Ramos italian restaurant and social event center

    4.2 Good 82 Reviews

    1607 South Lumpkin Road, Columbus

    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Ramo's Homemade Lasagna
    • Meat Lovers Pizza
    • Pepperoni Pizza
    • Chicken Alfredo

    “Lasagna is 🔥🔥 the bread is soooo good too. Great customer service.”

  • Sbarro Peachtree Mall 3131 Manchester Expressway, Columbus Pizza · $

    14 Sbarro Peachtree Mall

    4.1 Good 18 Reviews

    3131 Manchester Expressway, Columbus

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • 2 New York Slices and Drink Combo
    • Spaghetti with Meatballs

    “I had a great experience ordering last minute when leaving the mall. I was able to take home a couple pizzas as well as a some stromboli and they were all fresh, flavorful, and the staff and owner were very friendly and professional. Will absolutely eat here again!”

  • Marco's Pizza 1290 Double Churches Road, Columbus Pizza · $

    15 Marco's Pizza

    3.2 Average 162 Reviews

    1290 Double Churches Road, Columbus

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Philly Cheese Steak Pizza
    • Philly Cheese Steak Bowl
    • Pepperoni Magnifico
    • Fiery Cheezybread

    “Marcos on Double Churches Rd is consistently good. We order take out there 2-3 times/month. The pizza is airways hot and ready right on time and made exactly the way we order it. The staff is airways so friendly when we go in for pick up. They also have great coupon deals in the mailer and on there website so we can feed our family of 4 for $30 with full leftovers.”

Italian Restaurants Nearby

You May Also Like

  • Una Pizza Napoletana Pizzeria Named Best in the World for 2024

    Una Pizza Napoletana Pizzeria Named Best in the World for 2024

    Una Pizza Napoletana, a popular spot in New York, has just been named the best pizza in the world by the 2024 Italian 50 Top Pizza ranking. This is a major victory for owner Anthony Mangieri, who has already earned the title of best pizza in the U.S. for three years in a row.

  • Italian Pizza Chain Rosso Pomodoro Makes Its American Debut in Denver

    Italian Pizza Chain Rosso Pomodoro Makes Its American Debut in Denver

    Naples-born Rosso Pomodoro has landed in Denver. The Italian pizza franchise just opened its first U.S. location in the city's Central Park neighborhood at 29th Ave Town Center. "It has long been a dream to introduce our brand of authentic Neapolitan-style pizza to every corner of America,” CEO Nicola Saraceno shared his excitement.

  • 100-Year-Old Pizzeria Seeks New Owner, Bans Pineapple

    100-Year-Old Pizzeria Seeks New Owner, Bans Pineapple

    Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana, a 100-year-old Coney Island eatery, is looking for a buyer or partner to keep its legacy alive, but it has one important condition. Totonno's has made it through fires, floods, and even COVID, but there's one thing they'll never tolerate: pineapple on their pizza.