48 Best Pizza Restaurants in Columbus

“Best pizza, delicious salads, and fresh ingredients making Cerrone’s one of my favorites!“

“Tried for the first time yesterday and was absolutely blown away by the pizza! Purchased for several people at a local business, everyone enjoyed their lunch. Fast, friendly service and awesome food — we will definitely be adding this to our regular lunch rotation!“

“Thanks to the Manager for helping serve an out of town Hockey Team with Pizza after the game meal. Pizzas were great and delivered on his own time to the Hotel. We had called several competitors prior to Mellow Mushroom, only to be treated and talked to rudely and not helpful at all. We needed to purchase enough to feed 35 hungry guys He made it happen. See you again soon.“

“everyone is polite. food is always pretty good. doesn't take forever“

“We just finished our lunch at the Landings location and it was wonderful from beginning to the end. The very young staff was amazing! It was our pleasure to tip them, they were very informative, helpful and FUN to talk with. The pizzas were perfect and delicious. l can't wait to return and eat here again. Keep this staff and you have us for life! 5 stars all the way! Dan and Jennifer Dailey“

“I would come back for the pizzas and wings! However, the service was less to be desired. waited for 15 minutes for our check after we were done eating. not only that, we watched our bartender hit her vape twice behind the bar and proceed to ignore us....we didn't see her for almost 5 minutes at one time while waiting for our check. Thursday night at 7pm...3 other tables. we were the only ones at the bar.“

“I seen that Pizza Pronto had some great reviews so I tried them out. I bought 5 pizzas; 2 supreme, 2 meat, and a pepperoni. The place is a hole in the wall but it’s very good. I do recommend calling it in or you’re going to have to wait outside. The pizzas had plenty of topping and it is thin crust so be ready for that. Put one piece on top of another and chow down.“

“Delicious food. Great atmosphere. Fast service. Very nice waitress and Very accurate with our meals. our waitress did an excellent job juggling the ten of us.“

“We just finished our lunch at the Landings location and it was wonderful from beginning to the end. The very young staff was amazing! It was our pleasure to tip them, they were very informative, helpful and FUN to talk with. The pizzas were perfect and delicious. l can't wait to return and eat here again. Keep this staff and you have us for life! 5 stars all the way! Dan and Jennifer Dailey“

“Great service, food, and Friendly staff“

“Tried for first time and very pleasantly surprised at how good the pizza was as I am usually not a big pizza fan. Will definitely be back!!!“

“My wife and I have eaten here for years, and love it. Today we went and noticed that the service was even more exemplary than usual. The food was phenomenal (i got the Pesto chicken sandwich and a half ceasar salad), and the employees went above and beyond to make us feel welcomed. If you havent tried this place, come check it out!“

“We held a private luncheon upstairs at The Cannon Brew Pub and it went great. The service was top notch. They staffed 2 people to take care of us and it was the best service a lot of us have experienced. Very thankful to the staff for making this farewell lunch a wonderful success.“

“Lasagna is 🔥🔥 the bread is soooo good too. Great customer service.“

“Love love loveeeee this place there’s so many options for everybody which makes it great so you’re not limited with friends. The tap wall with wristband is a super cool concept because you can try drinks without needing a full one. Would easily go again“

“My 31/2 Yr old grandson’s first trip! He had a fantastic 3 hours!“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“I had a great experience ordering last minute when leaving the mall. I was able to take home a couple pizzas as well as a some stromboli and they were all fresh, flavorful, and the staff and owner were very friendly and professional. Will absolutely eat here again!“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“I have always loved papa johns. Wings are great...“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“I tried the Peluso Pasta Platter. It was not a disappointment. The food taste amazing!“

“I tried the Peluso Pasta Platter. It was not a disappointment. The food taste amazing!“

“The food was amazing and the service even better. Alvin was wonderful and truly made our visit perfect. First time eating there and definitely won’t be the last.“

“I can only speak of my experience from a DoorDash point of view because I'm a DoorDash driver and pick up from here all the time but that being said they have a 100% clean rating from the health department Pizza smells fresh people order it all the time they even have a drive-thru it's a great little store and a great location I would say keep ordering from here and I'll keep picking them up.“

“Reasonable price, delivered faster than projected! Delicious!“

“The atmosphere is excellent. They have the best happy hour from 5pm to 8pm. Where are you going to get $7 hookah? Where are you going to get 5 beers for $10? Where you going to get 50 cents wings up to 10? If you guessed Suites you are right. The service is second to none let's just say it's top notch. They are opened Tuesday through Sunday.“

“"Deorio's," overall, is an exceptional dining experience. The food is "okay," the decor is homey and Italian, but the service is marvelous. Of the many restaurants in Columbus in which I have dined, Deorio's has some of the best service. The staff is very considerate, nice, and I love the restaurant's atmosphere. It is a wonderful restaurant for the family.“

“my friend and i accidentally placed an order for the wrong location, and the guy helped us and was super kind about it! even called the place to have the order cancelled for us. only took 10/15 minutes and we got fresh pizza and brownies. thanks guys!“

“These sweet folks delivered 5 pizzas to the local nursing home to celebrate a Korean war veteran turning 95. He called crying saying he and his buddies had THE best day!! Thank you a million for putting a smile on my friends heart!! They all had great pizzas...something they dont get in the nursing home🥳 put a smile on someone's face and send a pizza from MARCOS!!“

“Called ahead and placed a pick up order. Got an AI bot who couldn’t understand me. Transferred to someone who sounded like they were from Minnesota or the Philippines (you know you know that accent). Couldn’t understand them properly. Couldn’t pay at the store location upon pickup of the order. Phone ordering forces you to use the key pad. I should have just used the app but since I’m busy driving I thought I may get someone local and speak to a human I could understand. If I could rate the phone ordering system I would rate a 2/10. 2 for trying. -8 for being a huge pain in the butt. AI is supposed to make operations easier. This did not do the trick.

Folks inside the store were awesome friendly. Gave me order updates and were chill.

Dominos needs to ditch the AI and go back to local phone ordering. I’d like to speak directly to those people I see when I pick up my order. You will see more of this from the customer base as an anti AI revolution starts to blossom.“

“I LOVE THIS PLACE....!!!!! THE WINGS AND PRICES R GREAT....!!!!!“

“Thank you Ray and Kim for a awesome Papa Johns Experience!!! Can’t wait to come back!! Much love and ALOHA from your Hawaii Family!!!“

“Pulled up to window 20:50 placed order, Said didn't have Hot & ready Pepperoni will be ten minutes. Asked for a Name, Breeze , came back minutes, said it will be another or I can be refunded, I had Young Grand Daughters, wanting Pizza. So went around again withvthe line it was 21:45 Next person didn't see my order slip, thank God I had recipe. He finally gave our Pizza. That crew, need more training.“

“I would not go as far as not recommending them but this does need to be addressed. Marco’s had an advertised special for 2 large 1 topping pizzas, cheesy bread and a 2 liter for 24.99 on their website. We paid for it and went to pick it up but all they had for us were the pizzas which cost us a total of 42.00 because we got extra toppings. The guy at the store told me there is a problem with the app not sending the whole order through and they are just seeing the pizzas and “per the owner” they don’t have to honor the price advertised if the extras items are desired. The guy said he would “give us the cheesy bread” but I would have to pay for the 2 liter. I decided not to get the 2 liter and I told him I paid the advertised price for all the items so I didn’t understand how just because they didn’t get the other items from the app/website meant they couldn’t still just give us what we actually ordered and paid for. Even if we had to wait for the items to cook, that would be fine but he didn’t seem to understand the problem isn’t that they didn’t see the extra items and didn’t prepare them in time. It’s really a simple fix to give the customers what was advertised and paid for. I don’t fault the guy I spoke with as he seemed to be repeating what the owner told him but this made no sense to me. I’m very disappointed in this. False advertising.“

“Food, service, and even the atmosphere were amazing. However I hated seeing one person running the store by themselves. Companies cannot be hurting that badly l. However despite that setback and myvlargw order the young lady up front was super nice and helpful. Got my food to me in less time than she said she would.“

“Talkative staff, spacious waiting area. The floor could have used a sweeping .“

“Marcos on Double Churches Rd is consistently good. We order take out there 2-3 times/month. The pizza is airways hot and ready right on time and made exactly the way we order it.
The staff is airways so friendly when we go in for pick up. They also have great coupon deals in the mailer and on there website so we can feed our family of 4 for $30 with full leftovers.“

“Lissen Linda, I don't know who the 5pm crew was on Saturday, May the 16th but one of them made the best looking pizza and oven roasted sandwich I've ever ordered from Dominoes. I had forgotten the guys name but Bravo sir, Bravo. I mean no bubbles in the dough, each slice was well covered in cheese, crust soft. Hey manager, I appreciate that whole crew that worked that afternoon!! This location was the Bradley Park.“

“Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I really love this Little Caesars location! Every single time I place an order through the app, it is always ready right on time when I get there. They completely pass the test when it comes to speed and convenience. If you want your pizza hot, fresh, and exactly when they promise it, this is the perfect spot for takeout!“