39 Best Pizza Restaurants in Columbus

“My kids said 10 stars!!!! Best pizza in Columbus without a doubt!!!!! The pizza is amazing and the atmosphere is chill!!!!! Love it! Favorite place to come with the boys!“

“Thanks to the Manager for helping serve an out of town Hockey Team with Pizza after the game meal. Pizzas were great and delivered on his own time to the Hotel. We had called several competitors prior to Mellow Mushroom, only to be treated and talked to rudely and not helpful at all. We needed to purchase enough to feed 35 hungry guys He made it happen. See you again soon.“

“Our server is very friendly! She ensured we are enjoying our foods. At the end, we told her that we aren’t from here and would like for recommend to other places to eat. Without hesitation, she came back with a list of places from the owner of this restaurant. Who else did that ! Thank you!! Definitely highly recommended!!“

“Tried for the first time yesterday and was absolutely blown away by the pizza! Purchased for several people at a local business, everyone enjoyed their lunch. Fast, friendly service and awesome food — we will definitely be adding this to our regular lunch rotation!“

“We just finished our lunch at the Landings location and it was wonderful from beginning to the end. The very young staff was amazing! It was our pleasure to tip them, they were very informative, helpful and FUN to talk with. The pizzas were perfect and delicious. l can't wait to return and eat here again. Keep this staff and you have us for life! 5 stars all the way! Dan and Jennifer Dailey“

“In and out pizza!
This pizza is so yummy and delicious. I can never take a picture in time.

You cannot walk in.
You have to order at the window. A older gentleman will ask you what you want.
I’ve ordered all types of pizza and it has never let me down. (Cheese, 3 meats, pepperoni, pepperoni and peppers)
The pepperoni meat was sooo yummy!

The prices are so reasonable, you can’t complain.
You can tell that this establishment and owner is a pillar in the community!“

“I would come back for the pizzas and wings! However, the service was less to be desired. waited for 15 minutes for our check after we were done eating. not only that, we watched our bartender hit her vape twice behind the bar and proceed to ignore us....we didn't see her for almost 5 minutes at one time while waiting for our check. Thursday night at 7pm...3 other tables. we were the only ones at the bar.“

“Delicious food. Great atmosphere. Fast service. Very nice waitress and Very accurate with our meals. our waitress did an excellent job juggling the ten of us.“

“We just finished our lunch at the Landings location and it was wonderful from beginning to the end. The very young staff was amazing! It was our pleasure to tip them, they were very informative, helpful and FUN to talk with. The pizzas were perfect and delicious. l can't wait to return and eat here again. Keep this staff and you have us for life! 5 stars all the way! Dan and Jennifer Dailey“

“I fell in love with Newks years ago when I moved to Birmingham from NY and they had my favorite salad, the Triple Take. When we moved to south Florida I didn’t have a Newks near me (so sad). We came for my sons graduation and we found Newks (cue the angels singing). Anyway, I asked for my favorite salad and they no longer have it on the menu (gasp!). Well the staff was so accommodating and I got my salad. It was amazing and the staff was so kind. I will 💯 be back. Thanks Newks staff! Also, Newks, bring back the Triple Take!“

“Excellent Pizza! The atmosphere was great. The restaurant was very clean. The staff was so friendly and on the spot. Most important was the excellent food at very good prices. This is a great place to bring the family or if you are on your own eat at the bar and have a draft beer. Definitely my go to for pizza in Columbus!“

“Lasagna is 🔥🔥 the bread is soooo good too. Great customer service.“

“My 31/2 Yr old grandson’s first trip! He had a fantastic 3 hours!“

“The pizza was good, but we had asked for some items to be changed on the toppings, which didn't happen. It wasn't very busy, so I don't know what happened. But even though we didn't get exactly what we asked for, the quality was good.“

“We drove 3hrs just to have “real” pizza! Relocating from Bflo, NY to Alabama we haven’t had real pizza! Although i love my NY style, this Chicago stuffed was amazing! The Buffalo wings were just as good! A new travel destination for the summer!!“

“We held a private luncheon upstairs at The Cannon Brew Pub and it went great. The service was top notch. They staffed 2 people to take care of us and it was the best service a lot of us have experienced. Very thankful to the staff for making this farewell lunch a wonderful success.“

“They are really helpful when coming to ordering, fast/fresh xl pizzas for a price you cannot possibly complain about!

Vegetarian options: They offer a veg selection for each food item

Kid-friendliness: They have small items for kids“

“The two ladies there seemed to be overworked, but got my order taken care of quickly. The topping ingredients seemed super fresh, which really stood out to me. However, neither the sauce nor the base was memorable. The pizza was a decent size, but with just 4 toppings the price ballooned to over $20. While I'd still recommend the pizza, I do believe there are tastier options in the area for less.

The area seemed a bit run down and there was a digital menu only, so it was hard to read with the light glare reflecting off the screen. The older lady was very nice and overall I had a mostly positive experience. There was a nice sitting area outside to enjoy the pizza and the box had a pretty nice design.“

“I've enjoyed Hunt Bros. for over 20 years. The slices are a great after work snack and on a "we just want the whole thing" night, one phone call is all. Our local Marathon ladies make them less than a mile from our house !“

“I've enjoyed Hunt Bros. for over 20 years. The slices are a great after work snack and on a "we just want the whole thing" night, one phone call is all. Our local Marathon ladies make them less than a mile from our house !“

“I would not go as far as not recommending them but this does need to be addressed. Marco’s had an advertised special for 2 large 1 topping pizzas, cheesy bread and a 2 liter for 24.99 on their website. We paid for it and went to pick it up but all they had for us were the pizzas which cost us a total of 42.00 because we got extra toppings. The guy at the store told me there is a problem with the app not sending the whole order through and they are just seeing the pizzas and “per the owner” they don’t have to honor the price advertised if the extras items are desired. The guy said he would “give us the cheesy bread” but I would have to pay for the 2 liter. I decided not to get the 2 liter and I told him I paid the advertised price for all the items so I didn’t understand how just because they didn’t get the other items from the app/website meant they couldn’t still just give us what we actually ordered and paid for. Even if we had to wait for the items to cook, that would be fine but he didn’t seem to understand the problem isn’t that they didn’t see the extra items and didn’t prepare them in time. It’s really a simple fix to give the customers what was advertised and paid for. I don’t fault the guy I spoke with as he seemed to be repeating what the owner told him but this made no sense to me. I’m very disappointed in this. False advertising.“

“my friend and i accidentally placed an order for the wrong location, and the guy helped us and was super kind about it! even called the place to have the order cancelled for us. only took 10/15 minutes and we got fresh pizza and brownies. thanks guys!“

“I have always loved papa johns. Wings are great...“

“"Deorio's," overall, is an exceptional dining experience. The food is "okay," the decor is homey and Italian, but the service is marvelous. Of the many restaurants in Columbus in which I have dined, Deorio's has some of the best service. The staff is very considerate, nice, and I love the restaurant's atmosphere. It is a wonderful restaurant for the family.“

“I can only speak of my experience from a DoorDash point of view because I'm a DoorDash driver and pick up from here all the time but that being said they have a 100% clean rating from the health department Pizza smells fresh people order it all the time they even have a drive-thru it's a great little store and a great location I would say keep ordering from here and I'll keep picking them up.“

“Ashley Hoskins at Marcos on double churches, is THE MAN, Not just at slinging pizza, but got pizzazzz! Friendly and funny, and ya get alot for ya money, so don't be a dummy, order now, go and get it you and won't regret it!. And Maddie to, the customer service guru, the best place in the city thru and thru!“

“I don't like to speak about restaurants that have good food and service, but I just ordered a three meat treat and a pepperoni pizza, to my surprise, a piece of white personal hair was on my pizza. I was so disappointed, but normally service is very good. I hope that this issue will be resolved in the future.“

“This is a Gem for downtown Columbus! We stopped in to pre-game here and stayed until closing! The staff was super helpful, I’m not a beer drinker but the beer wall is super cool. The mixed drinks were Delish and all the juice was fresh so you didn’t have that sluggish too much sugar feeling after. The bartender was super helpful as well and took pride in her craft!
Food is 10/10 as well
If you’re in the area stop in and try them out!“

“I ordered a pizza tonight Greg was my driver! The pizza was great first and foremost, but Greg gave me my pizza, and a dipping cup and realized the ranch was still in his bag. He went all the way upstairs and knocked on my door twice, just to give it me! This is someone who really cares about the guest expeiricnce.“

“Thank you Ray and Kim for a awesome Papa Johns Experience!!! Can’t wait to come back!! Much love and ALOHA from your Hawaii Family!!!“

“I am the “Malik” that the customer, Olivia Page, called a “terrible delivery driver” in her review of this Dominos location at Bradley Park Dr.

What she left out of her story is that the reason why her food was left on the driveway that evening is because she has 3 signs in front of her driveway that threatens the safety of delivery drivers.

One sign said, “Warning trespassers will be shot survivors will be shot again”. Second sign said, “ALL trespassers will be shot.”
Third sign said “Beware of the dog”.

I called her TWICE to make sure it was safe and okay for me to enter the driveway and deliver her food. SHE DID NOT ANSWER. So I left the food at the driveway and told my manager exactly what happened that same day.

This job is already dangerous enough as it is, and I refuse to risk my life over something so trivial. I don’t get paid enough to put up with this nonsense from Olivia Page or any other unreasonable customer for that matter.

Olivia Page, if you want people to be comfortable with delivering to your home then maybe you shouldn’t have signs threatening their safety.

I refuse to be another black person delivering goods and being gunned down by a paranoid white person. I have a son that depends on me.

If any leadership from corporate sees Olivia Page’s review and chooses to fire me or “quiet fire” me then you are just as wrong as she is. Shame on you Olivia Page and shame on anyone who is enabling her behavior.

There are MANY people with cameras on their front doors who have footage of me being a GREAT delivery driver in both good and bad weather, so how dare you come at me like that Olivia Page.

I was going to ignore her review but I had to set the record straight. I can’t risk my job and ability to provide for my 2 year old son because of Olivia Page’s review.

With all that being said, I forgive you Olivia Page. I don’t hate you. I choose to bless those who persecute me. That’s what God would want me to do and I am a humble servant of the Lord.

Romans 12:14 says to “Bless those who persecute you; bless, and do not curse.”

So God bless you Olivia Page. I love you and forgive you. Amen.“

“I tried the Peluso Pasta Platter. It was not a disappointment. The food taste amazing!“

“I'll be honest, I had an issue with the night staff at this location. The young lady was rude to me because she has taken my order inaccurately. However, I came in the next morning to speak with someone about it, and Ms. Zena was awesome! Not only was she professional, she continued to apologize about the issue with the item and staff, she corrected the error, and also offered to replace the item from the night before as well. Things happen and how you handle them determine a lot. I don't know her title at the store, but if you want to keep happy customers, keep Ms. Zena!! Thank you, Zena!! Hope I got your name right! lol“

“I tried the Peluso Pasta Platter. It was not a disappointment. The food taste amazing!“

“My friend and I visited The Pizza Place for lunch on a Monday. James was our server, he was kind, patient and attentive. The cook made the HECK out of the Mango Habanero wings and pizza we had. Jersey was the bartender/mixologist and he BROUGHT IT on a Monday! I RECOMMEND!! I can’t wait to come back on a Thursday“

“The older black ladiie with the gold tooth. I'm sorry 4 describing her in that nature but that's the only way I could pinpoint who I am speaking on. She had great customer service and held the drive thru line down. The food was Def hot and ready.. I'll say the best 1 thus far...“

“I ordered the personal pan cheese and breadsticks and they were so good! The breadsticks were tender and salted just right and the pizza was very good too!Aside from the food, the manager there, an older gentleman, was very nice and customer service oriented! I also saw evidence that he runs a tight ship and has great employees!Most everyone who’s eaten out knows being a manager and great customer service isn’t always a given so I’m always impressed (and thankful) when I run into it!Just as important was the fact that the order was correct and ready when stated.Highly recommend this establishment!“

“Food was excellent! Best Mediterranean salad added ( gyro meat ) we have had in a long time. Gyro wrap and pizza were very good. Pleasantly surprised since everything else in the area was closed. Drinks were great and priced well. Staff very friendly and on point! The inside could use a makeover, dated and very worn tables and chairs.

We returned the next evening for drinks and music had a great time! We recommend and we would return if in town again.“