50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Milton

“One of my favorite restaurants. Sabrina was our waitress most recently. She was fabulous. We don’t often have someone confirm each persons order and she did every time. Great food, great drinks, and great service. Best way to celebrate my birthday this week. Thank you“

“Fridays are the best Vienna Beef 🥩 hotdogs the absolute best and there’s no one around that has them except this place“

“Food is amazing! My husband got the small 5 meat stromboli (which really isn't small) and I had the pesto panini (because he hates pesto and I love it). We live 20-25 minutes away and he said he wished we had one of these closer to home. We will definitely be back!“

“good service..........“

“Holy cow!! This place was good!! In the area for a few weeks and this spot was within walking distance. Stopped on a rainy Sunday evening. It was nearly empty but had a few to go and DoorDashers while I was there. I had the Grateful Cowboy (see pic with register menu board). Very yummy and reasonably priced for the area.“

“We ate so quickly that I forgot to take pictures of the pizza! The only photo I managed to get was of the cheese bread we took to go.

This is, hands down, the closest thing to authentic New York-style pizza that I’ve had since moving here 30 years ago. I’ve found some good pizza over the years, but this was the best. It was absolutely delicious, and I’m definitely adding it to my favorites list.

The owners were very friendly and helpful, and the restaurant was clean, including the dining area and tables.

The garlic knots were amazing—packed with so much garlic that it was a delicious kick right in the face! We ordered the Triboro pizza and a cheese pizza, and both were outstanding.

If you’re looking for great New York-style pizza, Flippin’ Pizza is well worth a visit!“

“Dinner was excellent! Very nice owner and staff. Great food and dessert recommendations & we’re happy we made those choices. Service was also great. Don’t think about it. Just go. (I’m not a friend or family. Just a very happy Italian 😋).“

“Really good food, quick service, the pizza is amazing, very reasonable prices. Outstanding in every way, highly recommended.“

“The best place to buy egg less cakes in Atlanta area. Very tasty and healthy cakes :-)“

“Very happy to have discovered this place. The food is really tasty. I was having a large gathering and reached out to them for options. The owner himself communicated with me via email to make sure I got a special discount on my order, which I really appreciated since it was over $300. Thank you.“

“this is the best authentic neapolitan pizza anywhere around! The staff is amazing and very welcoming and always available to answer questions! Love it!“

“Cool vibes for pizza place. Great music too.“

“Best Pizza in Alpharetta!“

“I dined here on Saturday, the Cheese Steak Stromboli was so good I returned on Sunday to enjoy another one.“

“Absolutely delicious and very generous portions Highly recommend!“

“We love Sid’s! Great service, delicious pizza and a great space for kids. :)“

“Tasty food and fresh ingredients.“

“Great food and cozy atmosphere! The service was friendly and quick. absolutely delicious. Will definitely be coming back“

“Big “Thank you” to Dave (Manager) for his generosity in donating gift cards to Girl Scout Troop # 19799 at Dolvin Elementary in John’s Creek GA. This group is working to achieve their Bronze Service Award by collecting toiletries and birthday supplies for charity. This is one of the many reasons why we love our local Mellow Mushroom and appreciate their support in the community.“

“Amazing as always! I don’t understand the people who are saying the pizza was “burnt” it’s brick oven, it will come out a little charred…The pizza is always fresh and tasty, the staff is awesome! It’s packed for a reason! The people complaining on here are used to pizza hut or something“

“Delicious food, excellent menu and great service“

“Really nice Pizzas and even nicer people. We have been coming here for many years and the pizzas have always been consistently nice just like their service. No matter who is at the front desk they have always been wonderful. Very happy that such a place with such amazing people are close to our residence. Thank you to whoever is running this place. You are doing a great job!!“

“This is the best pizza I’ve had in a very long time. Exceptional customer service as well.“

“Wings and more Wings!😎“

“This is my second time eating this pizza. The first time I was put off by the price and the value for dollar. The pizza was good the first time but it was too darn expensive. This time I opted to get a larger pizza that I can share with my family and I got the hot honey pepperoni. It’s my first time trying hot honey with the ricotta cheese and thank the gods I got the hot honey on the side. Maybe it’s just my taste but I believe the hot honey all over the pizza would have ruined it. This is a margarita style pizza with a crispy crust and a floppy center. The crust is very delightful and the sauce is absolutely delicious. Oh this was an excellent pizza but even still at the larger size I don’t think it’s worth the money. This is a 10 inch pie for $20. All of my local pizzerias will sell me a 16 inch pie for $17. I admit that the quality of the ingredients is higher and it is a very tasty pizza but still overpriced.“

“Visiting Roswell, GA for a baseball tournament and this was across from our hotel. I was skeptical if it would be true NY style pizza, but boy was I wrong! You can get 2 NY style size slices and a drink for under $9 and the service was great! Garlic shaker on the table = dead giveaway this is a legit NY style pizzeria. Wish it was a chain so I could have this in my hometown!“

“Excellent service great Italian food!“

“Christian was my server he was amazing. Hi recommendations were perfect.“

“The original, authentic Chicago stuffed pizza! Best service - the staff is great and the prices are reasonable. I give Nancy's my highest endorsement!

UPDATE: It has been a while since we were last here. We came to celebrate my birthday and it was excellent as usual! Our server was friendly and personable - it was a great birthday dinner!“

“Pizza was outstanding!! 10/10“

“Tried the Achari Wings, Angry Thai Wings, and pizza — everything was really good. The Achari Wings had a great desi spiced flavor, and the Angry Thai Wings were perfectly balanced with heat and sweetness. The pizza was fresh, flavorful, and complemented the wings really well. Definitely worth trying!“

“Great Service!“

“Incredibly caring and welcoming staff, very comfortable and open space, and absolutely delicious pizza and salad.

Bree was such an incredibly kind, thoughtful, and caring server, and truly went above and beyond in her hospitality.

I asked her to give me her recommendations on their pizza, and she totally knocked it out of the park.

The white slice is incredible, and the meat lover’s slice was fantastic as well. Their crust is some of the best New York I have had in metro Atlanta, with a perfect balance of thin and crispy, and the amount of toppings was generous, but not too much for the crust to support. They also have an absolutely wonderful red sauce.

Everything was clean in the dining area, as well as the restroom, and the bar and televisions I think make this a great place to watch a game with some delicious food.

The restaurant and crew at Vendetti’s have certainly won my complete support as an amazing local Italian restaurant, and I will without a doubt be coming here much more.“

“Absolutely the best pizza in Atlanta. Prices are a great value and the toppings are so generous. Quality is excellent. Our family loves picking up dinner here (it’s to go only). Owner is so friendly and so kind. Always carries my pizza out for me if my hands are full. 15 min usually from time you call it in to ready!“

“The owner is the best! Very friendly employees. :)“

“Highly recommend Vincenza's Pizzeria! You can't go wrong. This is a must-visit. This is my first time enjoying this wonderful spot!!! You won't regret stopping and enjoying a great pizza! YUM!!!“

“Hunter and staff were awesome! Excellent food fresh & hot pizza and chicken parmigiana)and service this past week. Highly recommend stopping by and enjoy!“

“THE BEST MOST MAGIKALLY DELICIOUS CHICKEN PARMASIGIANA I HAVE EVER HAD IN MY LIFE!✨️🤌🏾👌🏾🙌🏾😋🥰😍👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾“

“The food was amazing.Chessa and Kim the bartender are amazing .it’s my new place to go.The staff is very friendly“

“We love ordering from this location! Excellent customer service and the pizza is made just how we like it.“

“I loved this place when I lived in Woodstock and now that I live in Cumming I can finally get my PLP again. The first time was a 4/5. Great but not spectacular. Tonight was the second time I went and holy crap, everything was amazing and literally perfect. I customized a cheesesteak pizza (get one on the menu!) with steak, cheese, onions, and ricotta sauce. Damn, it was crazy good. I also got a cheese pizza and OG pepperoni/sausage pizza. That old school cup pepperoni was spectacular. Brought back so many memories from my youth. The sausage was perfect too. Sliced and spicy is the way to go. Y’all aren’t the cheapest but keep making pizza like you did tonight and I’ll be going all the time. You’re right up there with Atlas in Gainesville now, and that’s the highest compliment I can give. I’m from Philly and PLP holds its own✌. Whoever made my pizza tonight isn’t getting paid enough. 🥰“

“If you want to treat your guests to the perfect pizza, this is the place! We ordered it for a children's party, and it was a total hit. The pizza is incredibly delicious, fresh, and made with love. Huge kudos to the team for their great work and for helping us make this day so special for the kids. Everyone was thrilled! 🍕🌟 Thank you so much 🙏“

“This was the first time going to this hidden gem!! If you want a true New York style pizza in Roswell GA, this is the place. Christine our server was so amazing and attentive. And the owner Mike rocked it!! Even though there has been so much rain they made sure that our table was dry and comfortable for us! This is a true gem of a restaurant!! This may have been my first time but it definitely won’t be my laat!“

“Amazing! Its been a while since weve been and we were pleasantly surprised. The atmosphere was nice. We were there in time for Monday night trivia. We didnt stay. The staff was really friendly attentive but not so much that they made us feel interrupted. The half salad was a great starter. I got a small Kosmic Karma and swapped out the feta for mozzarella. Divine.

Their ADA parking was also much appreciated, as was the space between tables so nobody felt scrunched.“

“Everything was good - sauce, cheese, crust. The sauce was something special in that it really seemed to bring out the flavor of the pizza overall. The cheese was delicious. The crust seemed just about perfect, crisp outside and still soft and chewy. What really impressed me was that nothing was overdone or greasy or overcooked, and the elements just served the delicious pizza taste overall. My son and I ate all but two pieces of the large within about 15 minutes before we got home. Highly recommend. Best pizza I've had in Johns Creek, and that's actually saying something (lots of great places north of Atlanta).“

“The food is really good but the customer service sucks!“

“Hunter and staff were awesome! Excellent food fresh & hot pizza and chicken parmigiana)and service this past week. Highly recommend stopping by and enjoy!“

“2nd time coming in to this location.
Great customer service, orders were made on time, clean and they have a restroom for you to use if needed while waiting. I came here bc of the reviews I've read from the location nearest to me. Happy to drive half a mile out of the way to get a guarantee on service and my food. Thanks guys!“

“Great slices of pizza! Great staff.“

“Neil and Cesar at this location are absolutely amazing! Their service, professionalism, and genuine kindness made our entire experience exceptional. They went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect, and you can tell they truly care about their customers.

The drinks were delicious, the atmosphere was welcoming, and thanks to Neil and Cesar, we left with a smile. Outstanding customer service like this is hard to find these days. Highly recommend this Mellow Mushroom, and we’ll definitely be back!“