9 Best Italian Restaurants near St. Marys

“The best authentic pizza here in town! Everyone who works at the green room is very friendly. I recommend them to everyone!“

“I have been coming here for years. It's always good“

“Best Italian Restaurant in North Florida , what a delicious dinner , the lasagna was delicious and the seafood pasta fantastic.I highly recommend .“

“I absolutely LOVE Angelo’s!!!! Literally the closest thing to the northeast restaurants you can get. When we go I even bring home a 32oz cup of Italian dressing!! I’ll recommend Angelo’s over and over and over again!!“

“We dined for brunch on 3/9/24 and had an absolutely wonderful experience. It was a VERY rainy morning which meant there were no outdoor tables for anyone. There must have 10 people waiting for a table in their reception area at the time of our reservation. In spite of this, the staff remained smiling and cheerful while they delivered a great dining experience. Their hostess worked very hard to communicate the status of everyone’s place in line along with those customers who had made reservations as well, again with a very pleasant demeanor. Now to the food! They have quite possibly the best French Toast I have ever had. The brioche bread was thick and perfectly prepared. My wife had their Caprese omelette and cheese grits which was also just terrific. The wait staff were attentive without overdoing things. Coffee cups never got empty before a refill was offered. One of our group was a tea drinker and she had a teapot of hot water and tea bags seemingly within seconds of ordering. The highlight of the meal came when we mentioned that one of our diners (the lady with the tea) was celebrating her birthday. The owner of the restaurant, a lovely woman, came out and actually gave gifted her the tea service that was on our table! She would not hear of us paying for the set and said she wanted to make a gift of the set. Completely unexpected!! I cannot recommend this restaurant any higher. In spite of a very difficult morning, none of which was their doing, the staff and management made everyone’s morning better!“

“what in the floppy disk pizza is this? we put it in the oven when we got home and it was still Flopsy Mopsy Cottontail. severely undercooked and raw dough. Not great“

“So I normally don’t eat salad, but the salad bar looks so fresh and it was! I actually had seconds And the pizza came out. It was so fresh and the marinara is so yummy and chunky crust is New York style thin crunchy dis a great experience for authentic pizza this is your place.“

“Amazing food. Had the Hawaiian pizza and bruschetta - both prepared perfectly Friendly, attentive waitress - Lisa“

“EDIT 1/18/24: Tried again.... Pizza was great, but the Chicken Marsala left a LOT to be desired... there was almost NO sauce, and 2 quarter pieces of mushroom. That's it. It was basically dry fried chicken breast on top of naked penne. Ugh. Why? The food is usually good but my last visit was a miss, for sure. They forgot the marinara dipping sauce for one of the pizzas, they forgot the buffalo sauce on my wings, and they forgot the raspberry sauce for the cheesecake. Without that sauce, the cheesecake tasted like a block of cream cheese. Plus I ended up chewing on a piece of paper that somehow got mixed in. Do better, guys.“