39 Best Italian Restaurants near Saint Johns

“Vito's Italian Restaurant offers delicious and reasonably priced food in a lively atmosphere with outdoor seating. The chef, Mr. Giulio, provides excellent hospitality, personally attending to customers. Reservations are recommended, especially for larger parties. The menu includes specials like garlic bread, salad, and soup served with main courses. The restaurant is very popular, so booking in advance is advised. The staff, such as Evelyn, provides friendly and attentive service, ensuring a perfect dining experience, even during busy times like Mother's Day.“

“Trattoria di Bernardone is an Italian restaurant located in Jacksonville that offers a warm and relaxed atmosphere, with friendly staff. The menu features a variety of delicious dishes, including the Baked Mushroom Appetizer, Butternut Squash Ravioli, Taglietelle Carbonara, Rigatoni Bolognese, Caesar salad, garlic bread, pizza, lasagna, and cannoli for dessert. However, some customers may find the piano player on weekends too loud, making it difficult to have conversations. Nonetheless, it remains a favorite place for many, especially for those who appreciate great food and a cozy ambiance.“

“Jenk's Pizza, a well-known pizzeria in St Johns since 2002, offers delicious pizzas and a variety of Italian dishes. The restaurant, now under new ownership, is praised for its tasty lunch specials, housemade marinara sauce, and crispy salads. While the blackened chicken may not always be as expected, it still receives positive reviews for its flavor. Overall, Jenk's Pizza promises a satisfying dining experience.“

“Serafina's Pizzeria in Jacksonville offers the best NY-style pizza in Northeast Florida, according to reviewers. The restaurant provides a warm and welcoming atmosphere, with huge and delicious garlic knots that are a must-try. Customers appreciate the crispy crust and generous toppings on their pies, with one reviewer even stating it tastes like a true NY slice. The owners, originally from Brooklyn, are friendly and make diners feel appreciated. Additionally, Serafina's offers an excellent gluten-free pizza option that left a lasting impression on a family, who claimed it was the best they've had in Florida. With authentic flavors reminiscent of Italy, this pizzeria has quickly become a favorite spot for those seeking high-quality pizza and exceptional service.“

“Al Dente's is a local Italian restaurant that offers a pleasant dining experience. The food is highly regarded, with standout dishes including flounder and lasagna. The chicken florentine special is also a must-try, featuring moist chicken and delicious garlic sauce. The restaurant offers daily specials and provides great service. It is a good choice for various occasions, from a casual visit to a family celebration. The prices are reasonable, making it an excellent value for the quality of food and service.“

“Amore Mio Pizzeria is a family-owned gem where doughs and sauces are made fresh daily. The pizza and pasta dishes are praised for their exceptional taste, with the crust being a standout. The cozy restaurant offers generous portions, a BYO liquor license, and a comfortable atmosphere, making it a great spot for a meal.“

“Bella Vista Italian Restaurant offers a beautiful outdoor dining experience with twinkling lights. The waiters are engaging and attentive. The food is described as the best Italian food in town, with dishes like bruschetta and perfectly prepared shrimp receiving high praise. The restaurant is clean, with quick service and tasty, generous portions. Customers recommend trying the fried calamari, baked clams, chicken parmigiana, bolognese, and toasted almond cake. The staff is friendly and attentive, ensuring a great dining experience. Bella Vista Italian Restaurant is a must-visit for those seeking authentic Italian cuisine, excellent service, and a pleasant atmosphere.“

“Leona's Cucina is a highly-recommended restaurant serving delicious Italian dishes. Their pizza and calzones are wonderful, and their Jumpo Shrimp Linguine Scampi and spaghetti with marinara sauce and meatballs are popular choices. The restaurant's marinara sauce is a standout, described as "absolutely the best" and "addicting." With great service and a variety of tasty options, Leona's Cucina is a must-visit spot.“

“Poppys Italiano is a charming restaurant with a welcoming atmosphere. The menu offers a range of dishes, including the Shrimp and Scallop a la Rosa, Chicken Cacciatore, and Pasta Fagiole. Early bird specials are available between noon and 5:30, featuring better prices and a glass of house wine. House wines are a point of improvement, with some being watery and sweet tasting. Service is great, even during busy times. The value is excellent, with a 10/10 rating.“

“Tucked in the heart of the town, Catullo's Italian Nocatee offers an Italian haven where flavors come alive in a symphony of tastes. Each dish, a canvas of passion, tells stories of sun-kissed fields and ancient olive groves. The ambiance is warm and tranquil, with laughter intertwining with fragrant aromas of simmering sauces and freshly baked bread. The food is fantastic, from the appetizers to the main courses, and the service is impeccable. The staff is kind, attentive, and genuinely hospitable, creating an atmosphere that is both comfortable and special. They go above and beyond, as seen when they provided a bottle of Prosecco for a wedding celebration. The hostess, Whitney, stands out for her welcoming personality, contributing to the overall positive atmosphere. The people working at Catullo's seem to enjoy being there, which further enhances the dining experience. In the shadows, there's an unsung hero named Isaiah Sibilia, also known as Sir Zay, who ensures every table is pristine and each guest feels cherished. His dedication and work ethic are unmatched, deserving of recognition. In summary, Catullo's Italian Nocatee is a gem in the area, offering a sanctuary of gastronomic delights and warm human connection. The combination of culinary mastery, unparalleled hospitality, and a welcoming atmosphere makes it a dining experience that transcends the ordinary.“

“Carraba's Italian Grill offers a delightful dining experience with excellent food and exceptional service. The restaurant has a $10 take-home offer, making it even more appealing. The staff, including servers like Jeff, Raychel, and managers like Will, are dedicated and hardworking, ensuring tables are well-tended. They check on customers' needs, create a comfortable atmosphere, and contribute to a memorable dining experience, as noted during a birthday celebration for a party of eleven.“

“Picasso's is a hidden gem with great food and service. The space is small but quaint, and there are plenty of staff to ensure a satisfying dining experience. The menu offers a variety of options, including delicious pizza, sandwiches, salads, and appetizers. The homemade pasta and sauces are a highlight, with the gumbo and pan-seared chicken receiving high praise. Don't miss out on the butter cake for dessert! The restaurant is family-friendly, with a kids menu available. While the parking lot can be full, there is wheelchair accessibility with a ramp at the entrance. Whether you're a vegetarian or looking for a new favorite spot, Picasso's is a must-try for a great meal.“

“Carrabba's Italian Grill is a favorite spot for many, offering great food and excellent service. One reviewer praised the staff for their kindness and quick cleanup after a messy accident, making a stressful situation much easier to handle. Another diner highlighted the warm and welcoming service from their server, creating a pleasant dining experience. Additionally, a customer who opted for delivery was impressed by Jonas' outstanding professionalism and friendly customer service, noting his dedication to ensuring a positive experience. The restaurant seems to excel in providing exceptional customer service, with staff members like Emily, Justin, Alexis, and Jonas going above and beyond to make guests feel valued and appreciated. Whether dining in or getting delivery, Carrabba's is a go-to spot for delicious food and top-notch service.“

“Leci's Italian offers delicious food at excellent prices. The Scarparella, veal parm, tortellini, ravioli, and chicken scampi are popular dishes, all served in generous portions. The kind and attentive staff provide excellent service. With a loaded menu and reasonable prices, this Italian restaurant is a must-visit, even if it requires a bit of a drive.“

“Enza's Italian Restaurant is a highly regarded dining establishment known for its delicious food and enjoyable atmosphere. The meatball appetizer is a popular choice, and the osso bucco is a standout entree, known for its perfectly crispy exterior and tender interior. The pastas, soups, salads, and desserts also receive high praise. The restaurant features live piano music, and the staff, including Brooke and Katie, are commended for their excellent service and attentiveness to customers. The wine selection and mixed drinks are also highly rated. Located in NE Florida, Enza's is a favorite among locals and visitors alike.“

“Mandola's Italian Kitchen offers delicious and flavorful food at a great price. The lunch specials provide a generous portion of food, and the gelato is a sweet treat. The restaurant is clean and welcoming, with friendly staff. With a variety of options, including meatballs, Mandola's is a great choice for families and those with dietary restrictions.“

“Dolce's Pizza Italian Restaurant offers great service, delicious food, and a cozy atmosphere. This hidden gem in Mandarin provides a quiet dining experience and a wide selection of specialty pies and ingredients. Whether you're a local or visiting from afar, Dolce's is a favorite spot for a tasty and satisfying meal.“

“Bronx House Pizza offers a tasty and fresh dining experience. The restaurant serves a variety of dishes, including the popular Haymaker Detroit-style pizza, which features a crunchy crust and full of flavor. The service is fast and friendly, making it a great spot for families, as evident by the kid-friendly cheese canzone. While prices may be on the higher side, the quality of the food makes it a worthwhile investment.“

“5 ⭐️!!! We’re from Michigan so we love Detroit styled deep dish pizzas. Sal’s felt like we were back home eating. And they carry Faygo pop.. another Michigan favorite! Definitely our new favorite food truck here. Super friendly family owned business too!“

“Simone's Wood Fired Craft Kitchen offers fantastic food with exceptional service, making every visit delightful. The caprese salads and pizza specials are a must-try, with fresh homemade flavors. The bread pudding is a favorite dessert, along with other tempting options. The staff is attentive and knowledgeable, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. While waits may happen, they are worth it for the unique and delicious dishes. The restaurant's daily specials offer incredible flavors that never disappoint. With a great wine and beer selection, Simone's is a perfect spot for a date night or a casual meal. Whether you sit inside or outside, the experience is always enjoyable. While reservations are not accepted, the wait is never as long as predicted. Simone's is a little slice of heaven that is worth the visit, with quality food and a welcoming environment. Don't miss out on this gem of a restaurant that will leave you wanting to come back for more.“

“Rosalia's Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria offers exceptional dining experiences with delicious dishes like mushroom ravioli and flounder stuffed with crab meat. The owners, Rosalie and Donte, provide friendly service in a relaxing atmosphere. Known for the best Italian food in the Jacksonville area, this spot is perfect for pasta lovers and special occasions alike. Prices are reasonable, and the food is fresh and delicious.“

“Olive Garden Italian Restaurant is a reliable choice for consistent and dependable food, whether it's for take-out or dine-in. The prices are affordable, especially for groups, and the restaurant is kept clean. The waitstaff are typically kind and attentive, although there have been instances where language barriers may cause some miscommunication. The menu offers options such as Eggplant Parmesan and Chicken Parmesan. However, there have been rare cases where orders may not be fulfilled correctly. Despite the occasional mishap, the food quality is generally good. The restaurant could benefit from accessibility improvements, such as a handicap entrance.“

“Vino's Pizza & Italian Cuisine (Fruit Cove) is a popular local spot known for its delicious food and excellent customer service. The restaurant offers a casual environment and serves a variety of Italian dishes, including pizza, pasta, and sandwiches. Customers praise the quality of the food, particularly the marinara sauce and the Greek Pizza. While the overall experience is positive, one reviewer noted a slight disappointment with the quality of the meat in a hot sandwich on a recent visit. Despite this, Vino's remains a favorite among the local community.“

“Villagio Grille offers a pleasant dining experience with attentive service. Their menu features delicious burgers, served on Texas toast when brioche buns are unavailable, paired with tasty fries. The drink menu includes a strawberry lemon drop, with varying strengths. For dessert, try the tart key lime pie, balanced by whipped cream. While the menu options may be limited, the staff, including the friendly bar team, provide great service, making it a great spot to return to.“

“Jonis Pizza Italian Restaurant offers great pizza and other Italian entrees in a cozy setting, perfect for a group outing or a date night. While some guests found the service lacking in friendliness and attention, the delicious dishes like Chicken Marsala, Lasagna, and Chicken Parmigiana made up for it. Located in the Hilden Shopping Center, the restaurant serves excellent options like sausage, onion, and pepper parmigiana and Italian wraps. Despite being a bit off the beaten path, the food quality and good service make it a worthwhile dining spot.“

“Moon Dog Pie House offers amazing Chicago-style deep dish pizza. The restaurant is clean with outdoor seating and attentive staff. They serve huge, loaded house salads and delicious, perfectly-temperature pizza slices. Even for delivery orders, they ensure hot and fresh pizzas. With friendly service and tasty food, it's a must-visit spot, especially if you're a pizza snob looking for the best slice in town.“

“Tony D's New York Pizza & Restaurant offers delicious Margherita and Grandma pizzas, reminiscent of Brooklyn's L and B pizzeria. The restaurant also serves tasty chicken Parmesan sandwiches and Caesar salads. The service is consistently good, with a friendly and familiar staff member, often a white man with tattoos. The clean and spacious establishment is a great spot for groups and offers quick, efficient service.“

“Cataluna is a Jacksonville gem that offers an exceptional dining experience. The service is attentive and knowledgeable, with staff willing to go the extra mile to ensure a seamless visit. The ambience is upscale and inviting, with a warm atmosphere that sets the tone for a delightful evening. The food is impressive, with a focus on flavorful dishes and creative cocktails. Standout dishes include the salmon and branzino, with desserts being a particular highlight. The restaurant boasts an impressive selection of wines and craft cocktails, making it the perfect destination for a night out. With convenient valet parking and a commitment to exceptional service, Cataluna is a must-visit for anyone looking for a memorable dining experience.“

“Cafe Cairano is a cozy family-owned cafe, tucked away in a strip mall across from Costco. The friendly staff, including the daughter and mom, work together to provide attentive service and freshly cooked meals. The menu offers a range of options, including the delicious corned beef, sausage egg and cheese on a Kaiser, and the Saratoga sandwich. With a focus on home-cooked meals, the cafe serves up tasty breakfast and brunch options, including fluffy pancakes. With its warm atmosphere and friendly service, Cafe Cairano is a wonderful place to meet friends or enjoy a family meal.“

“D'Fontana is a hidden gem serving absolutely amazing food. Their pizza is a highlight, with the Sicilian and strombolis being particularly delicious. While the cheese sticks may not be homemade, the restaurant's other dishes, such as the meatball sub and spaghetti and meatballs, are cooked to perfection. Excellent service completes the experience, making it a must-visit for a tasty lunch or dinner.“

“Hungry Howie's Pizza & Subs offers a variety of tasty pizzas, including the popular Cajun crust option. While there have been some occasional issues with orders, the restaurant typically delivers quickly and the staff is friendly and helpful in resolving any problems. Customers with dietary restrictions have found the restaurant to be accommodating and accurate in their orders.“

“Vino’s Pizza and Italian Cuisine offers a wonderful dinner experience with delicious deluxe pizza, lasagna, garlic knots, greek salad, and zepolis. The owner, staff, and food are incredible, earning a perfect 10/10 recommendation from regulars. Known for its northern-style cooking with spicy sauce, Vino’s excels in pizza and well-priced dinners. While some find the cheese overwhelming, the fresh toppings and perfectly cooked crust make for pretty good pizza overall.“

“Renna's Pizza is a neighborhood favorite that serves up great pizzas with flavorful crusts. Their pizzas, such as the white pizza with crush garlic, are a hit among customers. While there may be a wait, the quiet and chill atmosphere makes it worth it. The service is great, and the staff is friendly. Although the sauce may not be to everyone's taste, Renna's is a reliable spot for a satisfying pizza experience.“

“Vino's Pizza & Grill offers a satisfying dining experience with friendly staff, good prices, and high-quality food. The pizzeria's cozy atmosphere and New York-style pies make it a popular choice for locals and visitors alike. Customers consistently praise the efficient service and delectable dishes.“

“Mama's Pizza & Grill serves authentic New York-style pizza, satisfying northerners' cravings. Their garlic parm wings are a highlight, cooked to perfection and crispy. Vegetarian options are also available, featuring fresh veggies in hearty portions. Customer service is friendly, and pickup/delivery options are reliable. This spot is a top recommendation for pizza lovers.“

“Marco's serves the best pizza in Jacksonville, with a crispy crust, gooey cheese, and piled-high toppings. This Baymeadows location is clean, with fresh food and a diverse, professional staff. With its Chicago-style pizza, Marco's is a must-visit for pizza lovers, perfect for a laid-back Florida night out.“

“Al's Pizza is a popular local restaurant known for its consistently good food, service, and pleasant dining experiences. With multiple locations, the restaurant has established a reputation for excellence. While the parking can be a bit of a walk when busy, the overall experience is enjoyable, especially for families who appreciate the quiet atmosphere to savor pizza and drinks. The menu offers a variety of options, including the meat lovers pizza and buffalo chicken flatbread, though some customers have noted the need for additional sauce.“

“Antonio's Pizza & Grill has received mixed reviews. Some customers have expressed disappointment with the pizza, stating that there have been few toppings and little extra cheese added despite requests. The quality of the food has also been reported to have decreased since a change in ownership, with the price still being high. However, the service has been praised, with mentions of a warm and upbeat hostess named Bri. The calzone and a XL philly steak pizza were mentioned as good quality items on the menu. Some customers were disappointed with the amount of pepperoni on a XL pepperoni pizza, finding it to be less than expected. Overall, there have been inconsistencies in the food and service at the restaurant.“

“Sbarro is a popular Italian restaurant located within a mall, offering a wide selection of pizza available by the slice or whole pie. They also serve various Italian dishes and garlic bread. The service is generally fast and friendly, though some customers have noted that the pizza appears to be held for longer than ideal. The overall dining experience is suitable for a mall setting, though some find the prices a bit high compared to the quality.“