26 Best Italian Restaurants in St. Augustine

Casa Benedetto's Italian • $$
197 Blackford Way, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Eggplant Parmesan and Pasta
Tortellini Carbonara
Chicken Parmigiana
Fettuccine Alfredo
Stuffed Mushrooms
Eggplant Rollatini
Chicken Francese
Veal Parmigiana
Bread Pudding
Pasta Fagioli

“Tend not to order Italian food in Florida, or anywhere other than NY or Italy, for that matter, having been raised in Brooklyn, so this was a leap of faith. That leap was very much rewarded. Amazing meal, fantastic service. Everything was perfect. When we're back in St. Augustine, this will be regular visit.“

4.8 Superb150 Reviews
Poppys Italiano Italian • $$
104 Ashourian Ave Ste 101, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

House Salad with House Dressing
Little Neck Clams over Linguini
Calamari Fritti Rings Only
Boursin Cheese Bruschetta
Spaghetti Carbonara
Eggplant Parmigiana
Fettucini Alfredo
Chicken Marsala
lg Caesar Salad
Lemoncello Cake

“This is fine dining.Absolutely delicious!We've never been disappointed and tonight was no different.We stated with chocolate martini s made by Phil.Then Caprese on delicious bread, the mozzarella was soft and fresh.I had Frutii Di Mare, OMG it was phenomenal. My husband had Poppy's Tortellini ,again delicious.The atmosphere is so relaxing with a staff of smiling faces.The portions are large and the quality is top shelf.Just had lunch with the left overs. Omg just as great as dinner was.Don't miss out on this wonderful authentic Italian restaurant.“

4.4 Superb153 Reviews
Bourbon & Boards American •
17 King St, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Ribeye Mac and Cheese
Tomato Soup
Charcuterie
Flatbread

“Unexpected night out landed us here. Arrived here about 830ish, unfortunately they were out of several items that we were interested in. A singer was here this evening, pleasant atmosphere. I joked that it has a Pottery Barn/Crate and Barrel feel to it.Service was great, waiter was very polite and social.Food was amazing. Steak was tender, sweet potato fry things were seasoned perfect. Great flavoring. Bread tray was different, the biscuit had an interesting scent to it, possibly an orange scent or flower. Can't place it.Would definitely come back.“

4.4 Superb122 Reviews
Nonnas Trattoria Italian • $$
2 Aviles St, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti and Meatballs
Chicken Alfredo Pasta
Penne Alla Bolognese
Spaghetti Puttanesca
Spaghetti Meatballs
Chicken Caesar Salad
Chicken Parmigiana
Spaghetti Marinara
Chicken Marsala
Calamari Fritti

“We came here two years ago and fell in love with the amazing food. I'm not suggesting we planned this current vacation around a single restaurant... But i wouldn't deny it either. The food is simply the best Italian I've ever had. 10/10, would eat here daily and happily get fat if i were local.“

4.5 Superb181 Reviews
D'Aleo Italian Deli Deli • $
US-1, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Prosciutto Ham & Provolone
The House Special
Fresh Mozzarella
Pepper Shooters
Italian Cookies
Potato Salad
Hot Pastrami
Meatball Sub
Sausage And
Roast Beef

“This is the definition of an old style Italian deli/shop. The sandwich and cannoli were amazing. It is a small place and can be cramped if it is crowded. They checked on us multiple times while we were eating and were very kind and personable. The deli meats and bread were so soft and fresh. This place is also a store. There were many people coming in for Italian imported foods as well as the sandwiches. Definitely stop by for good quality food and authentic experience.“

4.6 Superb92 Reviews
St. Augie's Pizza Pizza • $
113 1/2 King St, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Grandmas Pizza with Pepperoni Cheesy Garlic Bread on the Side
Pizza by the Slice of Cheese Pizza
Stromboli and Pepperoni Calzone
Sausage & Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Spinach Ricotta Slice
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Parmesan
Buffalo Chicken
Cheese Calzone

“This was the best pizza joint we’ve experienced in a while! My family and I loved it! The pizza was great. We got it by the slice…they know exactly how to heat up that slice, too. We tried the garlic knots…YUM! And, at the recommendation of our airbnb host we tried the pizza pinwheels…AMAZING! Everyone who was working there was working hard, but they were so nice if you had questions. It was a great experience . Oh, and we got cannoli to go…once again, we were not disappointed.“

4.5 Superb101 Reviews

7
Violas

Violas Italian • $$
6149 A1A S, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Knots with Marinara Sauce
Chicken Parmesan with Spaghetti
Lobster Ravioli Alfredo
Eggplant Rollatini
Eggplant Parmesan
Meat Lovers Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Chicken Marsala
Mr V's Lasagna
The Stromboli

“The food was excellent. Brought take out home for the family after a long day of travel. The pizza and cheesy bread were excellent. We had the Supreme and some kid pizzas that smelt like pure garlic! Would highly recommend and would go back again if we are back in town.“

4.4 Superb188 Reviews
900º Pizza and Pasta Pizza • $
100 Ctr Crk Rd, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Double Bake Garlic Parmesan Rolls
The Queen Margherita Pizza
Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza
Fettuccine Carbonara
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chickpotle Pizza
Pasta Special
Supreme Pizza
Garlic Knots
Caesar Salad

“We stopped in for a late lunch based on reading reviews and were not disappointed. Fabulous pizza, reasonable prices and friendly service. We tasted some of their mac-n-cheese specialties [they're great by the way], but were too full to order any. Even though we are not from St. Augustine, we may need to find an excuse to drive back!“

4.4 Superb89 Reviews
Pizzalley's Chianti Room Italian • $
60 Charlotte St, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

BBQ Chicken Pizza
Calamari Appetizer
Garbage Can Pizza
Cheese Tortellini
Mozzarella Moons
Gluten Free Pizza
Lobster Ravioli
Minestrone Soup
Chicken Alfredo
Spaghetti Combo

“Highly recommend this place. Generous portions. Patio seating. You can build your own pasta!! I made a broccoli penne Alfredo with chicken and garlic and it was really really good. Breadsticks are good, but I do wish they had garlic bread. Drinks were good, nice sized.“

4.3 Superb215 Reviews
Gusto A Taste Of Rome Italian • $
4255 US-1 APT 8, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Gusto Meatball Parmigiana
Goat Cheese Bruschetta
Pappardelle Bolognese
Pappardelle Alfredo
Fettuccine Alfredo
Meatball Appetizer
Chicken Parmigiana
Eggplant Parmesan
Chicken Parmesan
Ensalada Caprese

“Excellent pasta bolognese and Osoo Busco. Ask for Antonio who comes from Roma and makes authentic freshly made Italian dishes. A gem and a perfect fine dining option. Portions are very reasonable and a good value for the money you pay. “

4.4 Superb78 Reviews
Carmelo's Pizzeria Pizza • $
146 W King St, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Cheese and Pepperoni Slices
Spinach Pepperoni Calzone
Carmelo's Supreme Pizza
20 Grande Cheese Pizza
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Fried Zucchini Sticks
Hawaiian Slice Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
Meat Supreme Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks

“The best. Don't let it being attached to a gas station turn you off. It's the best pizzeria I've been to in a very long time. Service perfect, place is great.Pizza soooo many to choose from. The place was so busy, didn't wait long. Very very fresh.Place just happens to be attached(but separate business)Great great great. 10 stars.“

4.3 Superb132 Reviews
Romano's On The Beach Pizza • $$
4255 A1A S, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Razor Thin Pizza not Recommended for Delivery
Pepperoni Bacon Sausage and Green Olives
Giant Pizza Slice
Chicken Parmigiana
Pepperoni Pizza
Antipasto Salad
Garlic Knots
Cheese Steak
Cheese Pizza
Greek Salad

“The friendliest and happiest wait staff ever! It appeared everyone that came through the door were locals as they knew the waitstaff. We had a large thin crust veggie pizza. The pizza was excellent only to be outdone by the tiramisu. We will definitely miss be back.“

4.3 Superb91 Reviews
Alta Marea Seafood • $$$
17 King St, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Wild Boar Pappardelle Bolognese
Grilled Caesar Salad
Seared Scallops
Octopus Salad
Oyster Trio
Burrata

“Visited this restaurant while on vacation. Great looking place and atmosphere was nice. Our seafood risotto lacked flavor. We usually order risotto if on menu when we eat out and have to say sadly it lacked flavor for both wife and I. Appetizers was good and drinks also good. Service was great.“

4.2 Good201 Reviews
Simone's Wood Fired Craft Kitchen Italian • $$
185 Murabella Pkwy #8, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

White Chocolate Bread Pudding
Marina's Old-World Meatballs
Pollo Campanelle Alla Pesto
Arancini with Pomodoro Sauce
HH Linguini Con Polpette
Neapolitan Style Crust
Linguini and Meatball
Chicken Parmigiana
Margarita Pizza
Chicken Marsala

“Great local spot. Sit outside and watch the sunset with a glass of wine, good food and friendly staff. Food would have 5 stars but I have been going there for years and still no coffee available when I ask. Highly recommend going here but come early ..it gets crowded real fast and never enough parking.“

4.2 Good143 Reviews
La Strada Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
4075 A1A S, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Veal Parmigiana with Tomato Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese
Fresh Baked Garlic Bread
Chocolate Mousse
Lobster Bisque
Veal Sorrento
Tiramisu

“Such an authentic Italian place with the red and white tablecloths and decor. Don't be in a hurry if you eat here but worth the wait! Veal is awesome! Decent prices! Lots of food! And save room for chocolate mousse! Best I ever had!!!“

4.2 Good120 Reviews
Marco's Pizza Pizza • $$
230 Plaza Blvd Suite 6, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Hawaiian Magnifico with Pepperoni
Pepperoni Pizza
Veggie Pizza
Calzone

“Hey, I’m not sure if this email will find anyone but I have a small concern.I’ve ordered 4 or 5 times and the pizza is really good…. But tonight I feel like the ball was dropped. I ordered half veggie and half meat and it looks like they just put the bare minimum of toppings on the meat side.The in house employees were all very busy and by the time I realized the pizza was “skimpy” I was already home.Please let me know what can be done to fix this.I’m not a fan of public reviews soI tried to find a management email address online but I had no luck“

4.1 Good51 Reviews
Cafe Cairano Italian • $$
425 W Town Pl UNIT 108, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Breakfast Platter
Veal Scallopini
Greek Salad
Sandwich
Burgers
Mac

“Wonderful dining experience, great service and delicious food! The negative we experienced was the horrific smell coming from the restroom just past our table. It was so bad that it made us hurry to finish and skip dessert so we could leave. We would have asked to move but the other tables were occupied and/or reserved. I will definitely dine again but will not sit at that table, will ask to be seated at a table in the front.“

4.1 Good75 Reviews
Five Star Pizza Pizza • $
987 S Ponce De Leon Blvd, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

XL Pizza with Pepperoni and Banana Peppers
Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza
Piezilla Deluxe Pizza
Cinnamon Rolls
1 Topping Pizza
Fudge Brownie
Garlic Bread
Garlic Rolls
Cheese Pizza
Wings

“As delivery pizza goes, you're not going to find anything better in St. Augustine. Their delivery area is the largest, covering most of the city, from just North of the airport, all the way down to SR 206, and from the beach to I95 and beyond. Everything is made fresh, the kitchen is clean, and the delivery is FAST! Open every day of the year until 3AM, including ALL holidays.I recommend the pepperoni rolls, which is pepperoni and provolone cheese rolled up in dough. After baking, they're brushed with garlic butter, and sprinkled with parmesan cheese. I also like the BBQ chicken pizza with bacon and onions added.Vegetarian options: Just don't order meat on your pizza. Boom!Dietary restrictions: Gluten free pizza available.“

4.1 Good97 Reviews
Cortesse’s Bistro Mediterranean • $$$
172 San Marco Ave, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Warm Mediterranean Bread and Oil with Mediterranean Spices and Local Organic Herbs
Mediterranean Bruschetta
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Mediterranean Olives
Eggplant Rollatini
Blackened Grouper
Mushroom Risotto
Chicken Parmesan
Macedonia Ajvar
Chicken Milanese

“Highly recommend if you enjoy authentic Italian Food. Outside is quite romantic and they have an adjoining piano bar at Night if you want to have some real fun after a quiet date.Best cosmos in st augustine.Escargot and veal marsala delicious.“

4.1 Good167 Reviews
Romano's Restaurant & Pizzeria American • $$
4010 US-1, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Bread and Olive Oil with Balsamic Vinaigrette
Eggplant Parmigiana Dinner
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Romanos White Pizza
Chicken Marsala
Sicilian Pizza
Broccoli Rabe
Caprese Salad
House Salad
Baked Ziti

“Outstanding food and had all 15 of my pizzas ready for my daughter's sweet 16 birthday surprise party on schedule. Great price and great service. Lady at the cash register to the guy that helped me load up.Grandma's pizza was the favorite. It went quick.Thank you Romanos“

4 Good79 Reviews
Antonio's Pizza & Grill Pizza • $
9155 County Rd 13 N, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Wrapped Jalapeños Stuffed with Cream Cheese
Antipasto Salad Yuummmm
Philly Cheesesteak
Jalapeno Poppers
Chicken Wings
Supreme Pizza
Garlic Bread
Greek Salad
Garlic Knots
Bruschetta

“First, we were greeted by a warm and upbeat hostess.. I think the name was Bri at the counter. She took the time to explain the menu and helped in our selection. The food was good quality for takeout. I definitely would go back again and ask for Bri and the Calzone.“

3.8 Good45 Reviews
Carrabba's Italian Grill Italian • $$
155 State Rte 312, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Mama Mandola's Sicilian Chicken Soup
Caesar Salad with Chicken
Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Fettuccine Alfredo
Grilled Asparagus
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Marsala
Pollo Rosa Maria
Minestrone Soup
Chicken Bryan

“I enjoyed my time at Carrabba’s during their happy hour tonight. They had a lot to chose from so I was very thankful to my bartender, Amanda for the recommendation on what to order as well was my server Maci. The food was delicious and good amount of portions. My favorite was their bruschetta. Overall, this place was awesome and I can’t wait to come back again!“

3.9 Good93 Reviews
Villagio Grille Italian • $$
500 S Legacy Trail, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Villagio Salad

“Stayed at the hotel where this restaurant is located for a month. I ate there almost every night for dinner. Good food and great service. Big shout out to all the bar staff. Robin, Kelly, Amanda, and Thomas. Always friendly and great conversations.“

3.6 Good42 Reviews
Amici Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
1915 A1A S, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parm - No Sides
Fried Mozzarella Cheese
Kids Fettuccine Alfredo
Chicken Parmigiana
Antipasto Platter
Chicken Marsala
Marinara Sauce
Veal Parmesan
Veal Marsala
Meat Sauce

“My family and I had a great experience. Richard took excellent care of us and had some great recommendations. We started with the burrata caprese which was very tasty. We also enjoyed the Greek salad. Our entrees were outstanding. I can personally recommend the Veal Francese and my family enjoyed the chicken francese and chicken Marsala. Great food and great service! Will definitely be back“

3.8 Good213 Reviews
Cucina Giovanni Italian • $$
2730 FL-16 Ste 101, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Angel Hair Nicola
Eggplant Parmesan
Side of Meatballs
Chicken Giovanni
Fried Calamari
Garlic Knotes
Garlic Rolls
House Salad
White Pizza
Stromboli

“We stopped for the night in the area and extremely happy to find CG for dinner.Fast delivery to the campground, nice proportions, hot food, delicious salad, and reasonably priced.We will definitely order again when we come through the area.“

3.6 Good117 Reviews
Borrillo's Pizza and Beer & Wine Garden Pizza • $
88 San Marco Ave, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Individual Cheese Pizza Slice
Borrillo's Supreme Pizza
Build Your Own Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Chicken Parmigiana
Margherita Pizza
Brick Oven Pizza
Marinara Sauce
Garlic Knots
Garlic Bread

“Wonderful outdoor dining with live music. Quick walk from many hotels with a great staff that was friendly and quick. Don't expect a pie to make your "best ever" list, but it was still good enough to make the total experience a great 2 hours of evening well spent.“

3.6 Good164 Reviews
Loading...
map Map