36 Best Pizza Restaurants in St. Augustine

“I have eaten at Piesano's twice, and each time it was awesome! The food is absolutely wonderful - today, my party and I enjoyed a cheese calzone, shrimp scampi, and gorgonzola salad with shrimp. All were excellent. And the service and ambiance are exceptional. It is very quiet and comfortable, and the wait staff are patient and kind and don't mind if you take your time. Not many restaurants are quiet and relaxing these days. The prices are fair, as well, especially considering the high quality of the dishes. Highly recommended!“

“Our go-to for pizza and good beer!“

“The food is amazing and would highly recommend!!!!“

“I've been in Florida for almost a month and honestly this is the first place that got my order right the first time!!!!!!!! and it was sooo good 😊 better than Carmelo's Domino's st Augie's and Pizza Hut 💯 chicken is off the cain as well“

“Great pizza. I’m rarely out at the outlet mall but if im nearby, im picking up a pie.“

“We were visiting St Augustine for a couple of days and both of our dinners were from Carmelo’s pizza. The first night we had supreme special pizza. Yum! Last night was lasagna and salad with artichoke, peppers, feta cheese and more. Sorry didn’t remember the name of it. It also was delicious! If we come back to St Augustine, we will be eating here. Not only because the food is delicious but everyone is happy and really great at customer service. Jean - on the left both times on the phone with our orders but also in person makes you feel like you are the most important customer in the shop. I am a manager in customer service and the service she gave to me and the customer service that the team gives each other is outstanding. This is how a business is run: great food, customer service and team work! Thank you Jean and everyone for making our anniversary weekend special and delicious.“

“My family and I visited Tony's Pizza for dinner during a recent vacation. The food was made to order and was fresh and hot when it was served. The pizza and the garlic bread were delicious. The restaurant is small, but cozy and has a family feel to it. The value was great, too! There were five of us and the prices were very reasonable. We highly recommend Tony's.“

“Pizza was hot and tasty! Salad was fresh. Friendly staff, quick service, relaxed dining environment. I will definitely go back!“

“great food and great service“

“We ate here while on our 25th Wedding Anniversary trip! we had pizza and garlic knots! And it was so delicious! And the service was very friendly and helpful! We will definitely be back!“

“We ate at the Purple Olive for the first time this past Saturday night. It will certainly not be our last time. What an incredible dining experience. The restaurant is beautiful, the food is so delicious, and the service was excellent. Our server Jennifer was on point. Our water glasses were never empty, she gave us great tips about the menu, and struck the perfect balance between being responsive and giving us space. I had the macadamia crusted salmon, and I cannot honestly say it was the best salmon I’ve ever had. The flavor was delicious and it was cooked perfectly!“

“The best pizza in town! Delicious crust and everything. Worth the drive from Nocatee.“

“Delicious Every Time! One of our Favorite Places to eat!“

“​I was having a completely average Tuesday until Will and Gabe decided to rewrite history. Gabe stretched that dough with the precision of a surgeon, and Will applied the garlic oil with the passion of a poet. I ate the first slice standing up in my kitchen in complete silence. I don't know if they're pizza cooks or culinary prophets, but as long as Will and Gabe are at the helm, my diet doesn't stand a chance.“

“This location is by far the best one in the area. Always fresh and hot and pasta bowls are always on point with large portions.“

“We decided to have pizza delivered to the condo for our last night of vacation and omg so good! The island Baja pizza is amazing! Wish we lived closer so we could eat here more often! Best pizza I have ever had!“

“Always friendly service and delicious food at the Amelia Island location!“

“👍Luis took excellent care of us. First time we had been there. Chix Parm was excellent, very large portions. Would definitely return to try the pizza! 🙂“

“Love this Mellow and really enjoyed the live band Sarurday night, Chillakaya. I am always traveling around looking for trendy spots to take my friends and family. The California Club was very good. The bartenders took great care of us and we will be back for sure. 10 out of 10.“

“Jay was working all by himself on a busy Saturday. We called in a large order during the lunch rush and he handled everything like a pro! Not enough credit and respect is given to the hardworking folks like him. Jay deserves an extra paid day off. Thank you from the entire staff at Volkswagen Of St Augustine!“

“The food is typical Buffalo wild wings a decent meal with a beer or two. This place stood out for the Great customer service experience, and the manager Mr. Zanzari who keeps a constant eye on the place and makes everything possible to make sure all excels... Thank you Sir.“

“I have tried Marco's pizza in the past and was not impressed. After trying the location at the World Gold Village it was awesome! The customer service down to the pizza were great! I would recommend this location to anyone! I defiantly will be back!!“

“Best food around and great service! Can’t wait to come back!“

“We had no prior knowledge of Blackfly. We chose it because it was close to our rental.  We smiled as soon as we walked in the side door leading to the bar area and everybody seemed to be enjoying themselves. The further we entered the very well decorated restaurant the more we knew we had made a good choice.  To us, the best reason to visit St. Augustine is dining at the Blackfly!  We went all out and had drinks,  appetizers, their version of Coquille St. Jacques and their Chilli lime shrimp. Both were delicious and cooked to perfection with exceptional sauces. Main course was a Chef's Special which was baked shrimps, scallops over a bed of thai noodles and a sauce to die for.  I had the bone in Pork chop cooked medium rare and it was delicious.  Blackfly has a vast selection of wines in their wine cellar and we enjoyed a nice Honig sauvignon blanc.   Kudos to Matt, our server, who throughout the evening gave us the right amount of attention and space to relax for our entire dining experience.  The food was so good and well prepared that I was compelled to go to the kitchen to thank the staff and gave a large tip for the kitchen staff . Our evening at Blackfly was the highlight of our trip.  Thank you Vaughn and staff, you have an outstanding establishment.“

“Deshaun deserves a raise! He goes above and beyond. I’ve had a million pizzas but he was so accommodating and personable. I’d hire him in a heartbeat and promote him to manager. ! The pizza was excellent. Will drive back here from Jax just to get some Pizza Hut!“

“Best pizza in town. Friendly service and always my go to if I'm craving pizza.“

“Best pizzas ever ! Such a nice crew, i love everyone at US1 S“

“I love their pizza and other food items. I go there often beautiful atmosphere and great music. A lot of fun!“

“Best Italian restaurant in St Augustine by far. Food was delicious, staff was fantastic and the owners are from my home state of NJ. What more can you ask for ?? My wife and I will definitely be coming back !!“

“I'm not sure why anyone complains. Me and my wife get pizza here frequently and it's always great. Everything is cooked well, sauces up, loads of toppings and done nice and quick. Staff are also friendly and never mess up my order. They can take a little long sometimes but that's it“

“Had the individual pan pizza, perfect for one and great price! It seemed Laura was by herself but she provided excellent, friendly customer service👍🐻“

“Just bought a Philly cheesesteak Papadia . It was huge and delicious. For only $6 it is the best bags in I’ve seen in a long time.“

“On a whim we decided to get Pizza for dinner. We easily placed our order, redeemed some points for extra items. Within minutes of placing the order, the store called to let us know they were out of mushrooms. They agreed to some substitutions without additional charges, in went the order. Within about 20 minutes we get a call from Holly, the delivery specialist, with Door Dash. Holly called to confirm the address (of the resort we're staying at) and as I went outside to meet them, they were almost at the door already! I gave Holly an extra tip for their efforts. Overall, loved the food and delivery service, we will most definitely order from this location again in the future!!“

“This is what Italian food should taste like!!! Phenomenal pizza, garlic knots and potato ball! Soooo goooddd! I highly recommend!“

“Courtney sent me a text saying she was entering my complex and would arrive shortly. I immediately Went outside and my food was already sitting on the ground outside my door. She was nowhere in site. No knock no ring nothing! My Pizzas were slightly over cooked and not even warm. More like room temperature. I have no idea how long they Actually had been sitting out there. Over $20 for pizza and this is the kind of service I got. I will never order from this domino's again. And I hope corporate reads these reviews.“