12 Best Pizza Restaurants in Ponte Vedra Beach

“If you're looking for a top-notch dining experience with incredible drinks and service, you must visit V's Pizza + Julep in Palm Valley. The atmosphere is always welcoming, but the real stars of the show are the people who make it an unforgettable experience. The hand-crafted drinks were absolutely amazing, thanks to the epic bartender, Jon from Key West. His passion for bartending is evident in every cocktail he creates. It's clear he's a true master behind the bar. The excellent customer service from our server, Reese, also made our visit perfect. She was attentive, friendly, and went above and beyond to ensure we had everything we needed. Her recommendations were spot on, and she made us feel like valued guests. V's Pizza not only serves fantastic food and drinks, but the team's dedication to their craft and to their customers truly sets them apart. I highly recommend it for anyone looking for a truly great experience.“

“We happened to find Poppy’s on Trip Advisor and boy were we delighted. The atmosphere is authentic, food is exceptional and friendly staff. Would highly recommend.“

“I'm in heaven! I've never been so happy after eating food. I just tasted the most delicious spinach spiral, displayed in the case, at Tony's pizza. I love their Margarita pizza, but the spinach spiral with dough filled with mozzarella and maybe ricotta and lots of garlic and oil is over the top! This is the best kept secret in Ponte Vedra. Tony's has the real Italian flavor I remember from NY many years ago.“

“I enjoy going to the Bronx house very much but they have the worst beer selection…just sayin! At least serve Yuengling to have some variety.“

“I’ve been searching for a good sub place because I feel like there’s not many in Jacksonville and I came across this place on Google and I genuinely had such a hard time picking what sub I wanted because everything looked and sounded so good and the staff is so nice and welcoming. I got the A1A and it is the best thing I’ve ever had genuinely. I love the sub so much like I will be back and I will be bringing everybody with me. I love this place“

“The pizza is everything I wanted and more. Can't wait to come back, I will be returning again. I was here about a week a so and slide through for some bbq, instead I saw pizza, we grabbed a bite and was impressed,“

“Was staying by the beach with family for the weekend and needed a bunch of pizzas. Called the store and they were quick to help us out, honest about how long it would take (about 20 mins) and when I got there they had them all finished already. The manager Jim did a great job and the other guy working with him was very polite and friendly at the counter. Will definitely be back next time I am I the are. Great job domino's!“

“Al's is great for their Great Pizza!!!“

“Had pepperoni made fresh from the kitchen,and I gotta say is the best way to kick off a late afternoon here in Jacksonville! Crispy edges on the crust wonderful sauce with the best tasting cheese I ever had! Not only is the food worth the visit the ambiance is great too not only pizza pasta and other authentic Italian staples they have the game going serving up cold drinks to wash it all down These guys are definitely making pizza the right way! Truly one of the best New York cheese pepperoni pies I have ever had! Gotta stop by if you are ever in the area“

“Always friendly service and delicious food at the Amelia Island location!“

“We’ve dined at Lynda’s twice in the past 2 weeks (once inside & once outside due to rain). The atmosphere is upscale casual with panoramic views of the ocean. The staff was excellent only to be surpassed by the food! It’s not the biggest menu I’ve seen BUT there’s definitely variety and everything we ordered from appetizers through dessert was excellent!! We’re already planning some family & friend gatherings at Lynda’s! It’s the perfect spot! Well done Mario - and it was so nice to meet you!“

“I love finding hidden gems, and Jonis Pizza was exactly that.

Susan and I were heading to one of our favorite restaurants, Fionn MacCool's, when we noticed Jonis Pizza tucked away in the same shopping center. Somehow, despite being in the area many times, we had never stopped in. That changed this week, and I am glad it did.

The restaurant is cozy, family-owned, and immediately feels welcoming. The aroma of garlic and fresh Italian cooking hits you as soon as you walk through the door. We started with the Garlic Cheese Bread, which was perfectly toasted and loaded with flavor. We also enjoyed the Fresh Mozzarella Appetizer, featuring fresh mozzarella, ripe tomatoes, and pesto that allowed the ingredients to shine.

As someone who grew up in a large Italian family in New York, I take Italian food seriously. When I saw Stuffed Shells on the menu, I knew exactly what I was ordering.

What happened next surprised me.

The Stuffed Shells at Jonis Pizza earned our prestigious Best of the Best Award. The shells were filled with a rich blend of cheeses and topped with a perfectly balanced sauce. The waitress explained that her mother makes them from scratch, and it showed. The dish immediately brought back memories of a favorite Italian restaurant from my childhood in the Bronx. For decades, no stuffed shells had matched those memories. Jonis Pizza finally did.

Susan ordered the Chicken Francese, and it was equally impressive. Tender chicken, perfectly prepared angel hair pasta, and plenty of flavorful lemon sauce made this a standout entrée.

The service was warm, friendly, and personal. You can tell this is a restaurant that takes pride in both its food and its customers.

If you are looking for authentic Italian food, a family-owned restaurant, date-night dining, or simply some of the best homemade Italian comfort food in the area, put Jonis Pizza on your list.

Be sure to check out our photos, especially the award-winning Stuffed Shells.

★★★★☆ 4 Stars

🏆 Best of the Best Award: Stuffed Shells“