13 Best Pizza Restaurants in Fernandina Beach

“We loved our pizzas! So good!“

“Customer service was great! Food was delicious. Would definitely recommend! And Nettie ( sorry if I spelled it wrong) was very helpful“

“Coastal pizza is always amazing!! This is the best pizza we’ve ever had for years now! Nothing compares. Even the house salad is just so good for no reason. Staff is super friendly and on top of it. Love it!“

“I just ordered a large cheese pizza from Pizza Street Kitchen for the first time. I have had pizza at a couple of other restaurants here on Amelia Island while volunteering at Fort Clinch and wanted to find a “better” pizza. I found it! The pizza has the exact taste sensation I love. Having grown up in NY, when I tried this pizza I knew this was my new favorite pizza place.
The cheese is generous and the crust is perfection. I am looking forward to trying other items at Pizza Street Kitchen. I will definitely be recommending Pizza Street Kitchen this others!“

“Found this restaurant a few months ago. The food is good. Went back today for lunch and I got the steak and cheese in a wrap and my husband got a calzone. Only compliant would be the cheese and wrap for my sandwich wasn't toasted or melted which could have made the steak and cheese with grilled onions slightly better. Otherwise the calzone my husband had was good and our pizza from our first visit was good as well.“

“We always love visiting the Sandbar when we are in town. They have a great happy hour with a view you can’t beat. We really enjoyed the coconut shrimp and chicken tacos. Anthony is the manager and he is so helpful and friendly along with the whole staff. We can’t wait to visit again!“

“Amazing food. Had the Hawaiian pizza and bruschetta - both prepared perfectly Friendly, attentive waitress - Lisa“

“Great food, beer, and fun atmosphere!“

“Hit up Natural Slice Pizza Shop over at the Omni Amelia Island Resort recently and it was a solid choice. The pizza is great, but the real standout here was the staff—everyone we talked to was super helpful and genuinely nice, which really makes or breaks a spot like this. The restaurant itself has a cool, laid-back atmosphere that's perfect for grabbing a bite. Plus, it's super convenient that it shares the space with the Mellow Yellow frozen yogurt shop if you want to grab something sweet right after your pizza. If you're looking for a good pie in the area with top-notch service, definitely check them out.“

“Wayne (pizza specialist) made the best pizza I've ever had from dominos last night!! yum!“

“Great food and service! Menu with good variety. Cute ambiance.“

“what in the floppy disk pizza is this? we put it in the oven when we got home and it was still Flopsy Mopsy Cottontail. severely undercooked and raw dough. Not great“

“Always friendly service and delicious food at the Amelia Island location!“