6 Best Pizza Restaurants in Saint Johns

“Best place out here. From someone that was born and raised in NYC. This is as close as you will get to New York pizza. Something was forgotten on the ordered they delivered to us right away. Top notch service as usual. God Bless youse guys!!!“

“Bala's has changed my mind on pizza in Jax. I know - it's cliche to say the pizza here just isn't the same as NYC. A common complaint. However, Bala's comes pretty dang close! I ordered the meatball parmigiana pizza online and it said about 30 mins to be ready. I was there in 25 and they were ready for me! The pizza smelled delicious all the way home and it was still piping hot when I got it home and on my plate. First of all - the crust. Probably the closest you'll find to NY style crust here in Jax as far as I've tasted. The sauce - perfection. It tasted fresh and perfectly flavored. The meatballs - I'd like to know where they get them. I would buy just the meatballs alone to put in some sauce or just eat as an appetizer (or realistically a whole meal). The ricotta cheese was also fresh tasting and delish. The restaurant itself is in a cute little shopping center by my house. It is small with just a couple tables - typical pizza joint kind of place. The people are fantastic. Super nice. Might grab a couple slices and eat in for lunch in the near future. Definitely looking forward to trying their other pies - and interested in the Triple Threat. Seems like that would be a good party pizza.“

“Nestled off 210, Amore Mio Pizzeria offers an authentic Italian experience in a quaint and welcoming setting.The ambiance exudes warmth and charm, enveloping guests in a cozy Italian atmosphere that invites relaxation and enjoyment.Our delightful server, Sabine, provided impeccable service with a genuine smile and attentiveness that enhanced our dining experience.Starting with the fresh mozzarella sticks, we savored the perfect crispy texture, followed by a delightful caprese salad, though I wished for larger pieces of mozzarella. The cheese pizza, our litmus test for greatness, exceeded expectations. The freshly made dough and tangy sauce were a testament to the love and care put into each dish.The prices were reasonable, reflecting the quality and portion sizes, making it a great value for authentic Italian fare.Amore Mio Pizzeria surpassed our expectations, leaving us eager to return. From the warm welcome to the delicious food, it's clear this hidden gem will become a favorite haunt for us.For those seeking an authentic Italian dining experience with impeccable service and mouthwatering dishes, Amore Mio Pizzeria is a must-visit destination. We can't wait to become regular patrons of this delightful establishment.“

“This is a good spot for pizza and apps. Fridays, they have live music, which is nice and not overbearing. I usually get good service, but recently, due to being busy, servers seem a little frustrated. Still not bad though. I recommend trying the spinach dip and meatballs. If they tell you pizzas are taking 45 minutes to cook its more like 20. I think it's to try and give the kitchen a break or to catch up on busy nights.Kid-friendliness: The atmosphere is good for kids and booths are big enough to let them be kids.“

“Stumbled back into Jenk's Pizza after a decade and so glad I did! This little pizzeria in NW St John’s County is under new ownership and was really good. Well priced lunch specials, housemade marinara (the way I like it with chunks of tomatoes ?) , crispy salads and tasty pizza… all combine to make this a regular lunch spot for me! #jenkspizza #cr210w #eggplantparmigiana #lunchspecials“

“Favorite place to get pizza! Only issue is the inconsistency. I was just telling a coworker today how good it is and that I love being able to order a “lite bake” but then ordered for myself and the crust was definitely not lite baked even though it was requested. Just wish it was the same level of baking each time.“