8 Best Pizza Restaurants in Saint Johns

“Serafina's Pizzeria in Jacksonville offers the best NY-style pizza in Northeast Florida, according to reviewers. The restaurant provides a warm and welcoming atmosphere, with huge and delicious garlic knots that are a must-try. Customers appreciate the crispy crust and generous toppings on their pies, with one reviewer even stating it tastes like a true NY slice. The owners, originally from Brooklyn, are friendly and make diners feel appreciated. Additionally, Serafina's offers an excellent gluten-free pizza option that left a lasting impression on a family, who claimed it was the best they've had in Florida. With authentic flavors reminiscent of Italy, this pizzeria has quickly become a favorite spot for those seeking high-quality pizza and exceptional service.“

“Amore Mio Pizzeria is a family-owned gem where doughs and sauces are made fresh daily. The pizza and pasta dishes are praised for their exceptional taste, with the crust being a standout. The cozy restaurant offers generous portions, a BYO liquor license, and a comfortable atmosphere, making it a great spot for a meal.“

“Bala's Pizza is a family-owned restaurant known for its high-quality NY-style pizza. The crust is praised for being perfect, and the toppings are described as delicious and creative. Specialty pies and slices are available, along with options like calzones and garlic knots. The service is exceptional, and the staff and owners are commended for their responsiveness and openness to feedback. Bala's Pizza has gained a reputation as one of the best pizza places in Jacksonville, with locations in Bartram and Silver Leaf.“

“Mellow Mushroom Durbin Park offers a delightful dining experience. While some customers have experienced minor mishaps, such as forgotten dressing in a Greek salad, the restaurant shines in other areas. Savor great pizza and apps, and enjoy the atmosphere, which is suitable for families with kids. Live music on Fridays adds to the ambiance. Service is usually good, but may be temporarily affected by high volumes. Recommended dishes include the spinach dip and meatballs.“

“Five Star Pizza offers delicious pizza with Wisconsin cheese, often ready as customers walk in. The staff, particularly those working late nights, are known for their helpful and friendly attitude. However, there have been issues with the restaurant's website, as some customers have experienced declined credit cards when ordering online. The restaurant is also recognized for serving excellent brownies.“

“Pizza Hut has a fantastic crew that provides timely delivery and maintains a smooth and professional work environment. However, there have been issues with the presentation of their pizzas. The "Philly" pizza is missing parmesan and oregano, and the steak is not distributed to the edge of the cheese. The "Super" pizza has poor black olive distribution, with too many on some slices, and the dough appears to be old or not oiled. The "Pep/Cheese" pizza lacks enough pepperoni and does not have cheese covering the sauce all the way to the edge. The "BYBBQ" pizza has underportioned chicken and uneven cuts.“

“Jenk's Pizza, a well-known pizzeria in St Johns since 2002, offers delicious pizzas and a variety of Italian dishes. The restaurant, now under new ownership, is praised for its tasty lunch specials, housemade marinara sauce, and crispy salads. While the blackened chicken may not always be as expected, it still receives positive reviews for its flavor. Overall, Jenk's Pizza promises a satisfying dining experience.“

“Your Pie Pizza serves hot and good pizzas, with friendly staff and a clean atmosphere. On busy days, it may take a while to order, but the accommodating staff offers suggestions on sauces and toppings, including plant-based options. The restaurant offers generous portions, different beers, and gluten-free dough that's actually good. Highly recommended!“