39 Best Pizza Restaurants near Caseyville

“The pizza was just as we ordered, but our problem is with the mango habanero wings. I ordered 32 wings. which cost $32, and there was almost no sauce on them. When I filed a report. they offered my a free medium pizza worth about 1/3 what I paid for the wings. What would have made me happy? Some mango habanero sauce for our wings. That would make me very happy.“

“Great food!! Fast and friendly service!!“

“I went in expecting mediocre some pizza and left with the satisfaction of just enjoying a delicious pizza. thanks for the experience.“

“Phenomenal food and beer. My husband and I tried the potato wedges, garlic wings and the garlic chicken pizza and it was all great. 10/10.. we are mad at ourselves that we just now discovered this place. I wish we lived closer!“

“Bennie’s Pizza Pub in Belleville is an absolute gem! From the moment you walk in, you’re welcomed by a laid-back, friendly atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. Whether you're here for a casual night out or grabbing a quick slice, this place delivers in every way.

Let’s talk about the pizza—phenomenal! The crust has the perfect balance of crispy and chewy, with just the right amount of char from the wood-fired oven. The toppings are fresh and generously portioned, and the cheese has that perfect melt and stretch. We tried a few different options, but the standout was their signature Bennie’s Special—every bite was loaded with flavor. If you love a little heat, their spicy options won’t disappoint either.

Beyond the pizza, the beer selection is fantastic. I did not try any of them, but they had a good choice. They offer a great mix of local and craft beers that pair perfectly with their menu. The staff is incredibly friendly and attentive without being overbearing, and service was quick even when the place was busy.

Bennie’s strikes that perfect balance between a casual, fun vibe and seriously good food. It’s easy to see why locals love it. Whether you're dining in or grabbing takeout, you won’t be disappointed. This place is a must-visit! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Parking: Former St. Louis Bread/Panera location. You would not know if not told.“

“I get delivery for pizza & salad, when I go to my sisters in Godfrey. Its delicious, can't wait for them to be closer to me👏👏“

“I must say…Some of THE BEST Pizza!!! Thanks for making my Birthday memorable😉“

“Maybe I don't remember what I know really loves facial. Okay. This place has great pizza and a great price color half. Or less than other places they sell it made and you can take it home for easier or put it in the oven. It is excellent. The white sauce was a good too I would recommend it to anybody who likes pizza and likes fresh ingredients that are high quality. You can watch the prepreparation process. It was very welcome atmospwe're sure they're very friendly and helpful and remember the regular customers“

“Great St. Louis style and authentic Italian ingredients cooked right in front of you. At least at the Waterloo location, that one is my favorite. There few places to sit but good luck if there customers waiting for the best carry out pizza.“

“The pizza was delicious, the garlic cheese bread was really good. Loved the fresh garlic on the bread!“

“Excellent food and service!!!“

“Marco's Pizza Collinsville Customer service is awesome. The pies are great, and I'd recommend them to anyone“

“So much for freshness on a Monday night. The wings we purchased with the salad appeared and tasted like yesterday’s“

“❤We love Jets pizza. Each time my son comes home from the military to visit, this is what he wants!!“

“I always order online. I've been getting the Pretty Pizza for the entire 5/6 years I've lived here. maybe in the past year, I've intermittently ordered a 1/2 PP and 1/2 BBQ. Somehow my order didn't come out right today. Is the app glitchy? Staff said the second half wasn't even selected, so THEY chose cheese pizza for me. not really happy. My number was available. Couldn't someone have CALLED me before making this? I'm taking a break from your establishment.“

“My husband and I stopped in during the Pride event just looking for the first place we found with food, and not only was the music and atmosphere super cool, we got the chicken bacon ranch pizza, and I swear, it was THE BEST pizza 👏🏻 I’ve 👏🏻 ever 👏🏻 had. The service was great, the food was affordable. Can’t wait to go back!“

“Our pizzas turned out great. I really liked the provel cheese on my pizza and my wife really loves Imo's thin crispy crust. Our only issue was with the cinnImos. There was hardly any cinnamon or icing on them. It was like eating plain, small bread rolls.“

“Got the sweet heat pizza. First time ever having Imo's It was pretty good. Crust was a little harder than I was anticipating but overall it was yummy. Probably just used to regular hand tossed crusts that are fluffier and lighter but I will go back for sure.“

“I stopped in to get a whole chef salad (my fave thing here) and bread bites. The young lady at the counter was so super nice!! Extremely pleasant and helpful. Highly recommend the Imo's in Fairview Heights IL!!

Wheelchair accessibility: They have a ramp for wheelchair entry“

“The chicken parmesan was kinda of good. I don't understand Italian cuisine in the USA. Tomato sauce with no spices and always the same taste, so I will say, it tasted like any chaine restaurant in the USA. Has for the service, well the waitress was nice, but more clients started to arrive, so she was nervous. We weren't finish and she already gave us the bill. I told her that we were not finished and that we wanted dessert. So, she came back for our desserts, but she didn't take our empty plates on the table. We add to push them in a corner to eat our desserts.“

“Everything good , expect the restroom need more attention“

“A young woman named "Brook" assisted me with an order over the phone last evening, April 6th. She was the most delightful, empathetic, and helpful representative I've ever experienced from any fast food establishment. We have always enjoyed pizza hut cuisine. Last nite's verbal exchange on the phone, exceptional service and assistance, and delivery was an absolute pleasure.“

“Our order for delivery this evening arrived hot, fresh and picture perfect. Awesome job!“

“The folks who work here are always really nice. This store is about a mile and a half from our house. I can place an order through the app, drive over there, walk in and within about two minutes our order is ready. The pizza is still out of the oven hot when I get home. They are consistently reliable.“

“Our order for delivery this evening arrived hot, fresh and picture perfect. Awesome job!“

“Happened upon this friendly great restaurant in Troy, IL while traveling home from OK to OH. Oh my! What a gem. This was some of the best Italian food we have eaten. Brian got a half a pizza that was full of toppings and much too big to eat. I got the the spaghetti and meatballs. The red sauce was like the Italian mother's made and the meatball was the owner's grandmother's recipe. Holy Meatballs! It was delicious. We will definitely be back on pur way through when we travel. We talked to the owner for quite a while. So friendly, kind and appreciative of our patronage.“

“Excellent pizza- we live 4 hours away so we’ve never tried Imo’s before. The cheese is so different from any other pizza we’ve had- it was so good! The ravioli was awesome. Friendly staff too. Thank you- we will definitely be back next time we’re in the St Louis area“

“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again“

“Phenomenal food and beer. My husband and I tried the potato wedges, garlic wings and the garlic chicken pizza and it was all great. 10/10.. we are mad at ourselves that we just now discovered this place. I wish we lived closer!“

“Pizza GOOD . The so called wings in a bag sucked very dry and tuff“

“Best pizza!!! Thin crust pizza with provel cheese!“

“We order from here way more than we should and food is consistently delicious! Cheesy bread is a regular in our house, as well as the buffalo wings. Delivery times insane which is understandable if not enough help, so we tend to DoorDash when we are feaning for Marcos pizza. It literally never disappoints. I did pick up once and the wait was long, but the ladies behind the counter were awesome! The guys working prep and boxing were literally amazing because it was obvious they were slammed but they put extreme care into each order prepared so the wait didn’t bother me. Keep it Marcos at Central Plaza!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“My pizzas were not correct. I called and talked to a female worker abt this...assume she may have been a manager.
She went above and beyond to fix this issue. Remade the pizzas, and bread and cinnasticks. Had it delivered to my home (I had carryout), and refunded my money with a hand written note apologizing.
Best customer service I have ever received anywhere! Kuddos“

“Hosted a party and it was so fun. The food was amazing. Especially the chicken wings. Jeff and Christy are very accommodating. Tara is a great bartender. Highly recommend this venue“

“When I first moved to town 10 years ago, this place was a disaster. However, the past several years it’s become outstanding, one of the better locations I deal with anywhere. The manager, Mariah has really turned this place around and they don’t have a bunch of crap employees like they used to or the other bs.

It’s gone from “oh F no” to “absolutely” when considering ordering food from here. Glad it’s out here.“

“Best Imos around, I always ordered from Fairview heights location. Last time we did I got aImos extra special sandwich, the food was rotten. They wouldn't replace sandwich. So we tried the Imos in O'fallon and never a problem, if so they make it rite. We spend a lot of money, it's our favorite place to eat. So glad O'fallon Imos cares about our business.“

“Can I just say that Keith was the sweetest man ever taking my delivery order on the phone! I was delighted to speak with him and I just ordered my pizza. I hope he delivers it too! ❤️“

“Our pickup experience was great, very fast. However, I am unhappy with the amount of sauce that was used to cover the boneless wings. More sauce is definitely needed and take the time to toss more thoroughly. What I received versus what is advertised online was very disappointing“

“I just ordered through uber eats & good lord whoever was cooking that food around 9pm PLEASE keep them back there!! this is the best imos ive ever had in my life from the wings, pizza & salad! Its so rare to get good food on the go, please keep it upppp🫶🏽“