11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Cicero

“Where do I even start... The establishment is unlike anything I've experienced so far, the place feels magical for both kids and grown-ups alike. When you step in for the first time, it feels akin to a fun, fantastical experience coming to life. This place is a great experience alone, but trust me, it's best when visiting with some company; you could even bring your sister to this location. As for the staff, they know what they do and take their job seriously: they don't treat their job as some sort of pizzeria simulator. The pizza they serve is catered to your specifications, allowing you to have the ultimate custom experience any night. Don't get me wrong, this place is still prone to human error, but the staff is capable of providing help when wanted. Aside from the inevitable human error (and unsubstantiated rumors involving disappearances) the only downside is the lack of a warning when accessing the free wifi, if you do want to use the free wifi, just remember to use a VPN to prevent a security breach on your device. Personally, I reccomend it over any of the other copycat locations; I don't know the secret of the success of mimic locations, but having already patronized here for 5 nights, I know that I will always come back.“

“If you like sweet sauce, traditional Chicago style with a lot of toppings then this spot is treat. The soft crust, hot pie and warm smiles will have you coming back for more“

“This pizza was absolutely delicious. So pleasantly surprised. Their sauce is everything. Had so much delicious cheese on it. I ordered this at midnight and it was still incredible. I ate the leftovers for breakfast lol Arrived fresh and piping hot. 🔥❤️🤌and it was still good the next day too.“

“The food was good and delivered in a timely manner even though I live a bit far from this particular location. Also, there was a gentleman named Brian that gave me the best possible customer service. I know it must be tough for workers to keep a positive attitude during this pandemic, but you have no idea how far being nice and respectful goes! Thanks Brian!“

“It was my first time going and I was fairly soprised it's pretty good pizza 🍕😋 and the prices aren't bad neither I myself got their large pizza got it within 15 minutes fresh out the oven as part of their special for $9.99 I wished there was a few more Pepperoni slices in it but for the price and quickness and taste it was well worth it, my only regret is I didn't ask for it to be well done but that's totally on me I prefer my pizza a little crispier to the bite, it's worth a stop if your in the area 👍🏼“

“I visit twice in 2 weeks. I have been coming here for many years. Scatchell's your beef sandwich never disappoint me. What really puts them over the top is your homemade hot peppers. But I would like to suggest that your food handlers use plastic gloves. I observed one of your workers rub his nose and then made a sandwich (it wasn't mine) 😓“

“It’s good food I never had they pizza yet but it was a lot of ppl going in and out“

“Great football size pizza. Very tasty as feeds a crowd. I went there and picked one up for my dad, had surgery in my hand so i couldn't open the door. The worker there was very nice and came over to open the door for me so I can walk out. That's customer service. Thank you Chely's. ?“

“I grew up in Cicero. I remember going to Falco's when I was a kid. Thar was 50 years ago. I was in the old neighborhood on 12/23/25. I had to go to Falco's. And glad that I did. Eating that pizza took me back in time. Keep doing what you are doing.“

“Love them best tacos in town and pizza! Huge pizza slices for cheap , and they are QUICK.“