11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Cicero

“I don't have pictures because of course we pigged out...this place is the gem they say it is...the food is awesome...they have an eating area. I had the penne bolognaise..my husband the timballo..for give me if I misspelled it..baked spaghetti....the gelato is great...they make their own bread..I bought their homemade sopressata to take home...I am sure I will not be disappointed..I highly recommend it..“

“If you like sweet sauce, traditional Chicago style with a lot of toppings then this spot is treat. The soft crust, hot pie and warm smiles will have you coming back for more“

“I visit twice in 2 weeks. I have been coming here for many years. Scatchell's your beef sandwich never disappoint me. What really puts them over the top is your homemade hot peppers. But I would like to suggest that your food handlers use plastic gloves. I observed one of your workers rub his nose and then made a sandwich (it wasn't mine) 😓“

“This pizza was absolutely delicious. So pleasantly surprised. Their sauce is everything. Had so much delicious cheese on it. I ordered this at midnight and it was still incredible. I ate the leftovers for breakfast lol Arrived fresh and piping hot. 🔥❤️🤌and it was still good the next day too.“

“The food was good and delivered in a timely manner even though I live a bit far from this particular location. Also, there was a gentleman named Brian that gave me the best possible customer service. I know it must be tough for workers to keep a positive attitude during this pandemic, but you have no idea how far being nice and respectful goes! Thanks Brian!“

“It was my first time going and I was fairly soprised it's pretty good pizza 🍕😋 and the prices aren't bad neither I myself got their large pizza got it within 15 minutes fresh out the oven as part of their special for $9.99 I wished there was a few more Pepperoni slices in it but for the price and quickness and taste it was well worth it, my only regret is I didn't ask for it to be well done but that's totally on me I prefer my pizza a little crispier to the bite, it's worth a stop if your in the area 👍🏼“

“Love them best tacos in town and pizza! Huge pizza slices for cheap , and they are QUICK.“

“It’s good food I never had they pizza yet but it was a lot of ppl going in and out“

“Great football size pizza. Very tasty as feeds a crowd. I went there and picked one up for my dad, had surgery in my hand so i couldn't open the door. The worker there was very nice and came over to open the door for me so I can walk out. That's customer service. Thank you Chely's. ?“

“I grew up in Cicero. I remember going to Falco's when I was a kid. Thar was 50 years ago. I was in the old neighborhood on 12/23/25. I had to go to Falco's. And glad that I did. Eating that pizza took me back in time. Keep doing what you are doing.“