4.6
Superb
1,447 Reviews
2121 North Clark Street, Chicago
Customers’ favorites
- Frozen Pot Pie Pizza - The One Pounder Meat Sauce
- Half Pound Pizza Pot Pie and Greek Salad
- Frozen Pizza Pot Pie - The Half Pounder
- Mediterranean Bread Hand for Reference
“FIVE ⭐️ REVIEW — Chicago Pizza & Oven Grinder Co. After six years of trying, failing, hoping, and trying again… we finally completed our epic quest for the legendary pizza pot pie. Attempt #1 - 2019 — The Great Post-Marathon Pot Pie Shutdown. We arrived full of optimism… only to find the place overflowing with marathon runners. The line snaked down the street, they started turning people away, and our journey ended before it even began. Attempt #2 - December 2023 — The Mysterious Reservation Era. That winter, they may have been experimenting with reservations… and every spot was booked nearly a month out. We were driving through Chicago with brave hearts and empty stomachs, but once again: ❌ Quest denied. ❌ Pot pie unreachable. ❌ Spirits temporarily crushed. Attempt #3 This Weekend — The Victory Chapter. We arrived at 3pm thinking we’d outsmart the crowds. 😂 Adorable. Still a 2-hour wait. But we had no plans, so we grabbed bar seats, a Hugo Spritz (me) and a Dirty Martini (Dustin), and settled in for whatever fate had planned. Then destiny intervened: A woman who has been coming here for 20 years every Christmas season (and her husband for 40!) gave us sacred insider scrolls of wisdom: ✨ Don’t skip the salad. ✨ Order the Mediterranean flatbread. ✨ And—even though she isn’t vegetarian—the non-meat sauce pot pie is her favorite. We followed her guidance like travelers receiving a map from a seasoned guide. And she was right about everything. The house salad (no meat for me) with that creamy garlic + honey-lemon-poppyseed dressing combo? One of the best salads I’ve had in my life. The Mediterranean flatbread? Absolutely incredible. The pot pies? Divine. We ordered half-pound versions and still had leftovers. The staff boxed things up mid-meal like culinary ninjas to make room for each new dish. The hostess—facing never-ending crowds and multi-hour waits—was still genuine, warm, and unfazed. A wildly different experience from a reservation-taking restaurant we visited the night before (Italian Village) The vibe? Cozy, humble, like a Northwoods cabin tucked into the city, with a Cheers-style bar full of characters you secretly hope to run into again. My vegetarian pot pie? Perfection. Dustin (full-time meat eater) preferred the vegetarian sauce over the meat one, and already has his eyes on trying a grinder next time—along with that salad, no question. After years of attempts, long lines, and a journey worthy of its own folklore… 💛 We finally did it. And yes—absolutely worth every minute. #ChicagoPizzaAndOvenGrinder #PizzaPotPie #ChicagoEats #FoodAdventure #WorthTheWait #HiddenGemsChicago #ChicagoFoodie #FiveStars #EpicEats #DateNightWin”