Cone Cottage
CLOSED$ •
About Cone Cottage
Cone Cottage Reviews
Great Ice cream and service
Ice cream was delicious. I had a dreamlike cone - it is vanilla twisted with orange sherbert
I come here a few times during their open season. Today 10/02/25 I went and puechased a chocolate malt and a vanilla/chocolate ice cream cone. Upon tasting the malt I realized it tasted spoiled. I tried my son’s ice cream and it tasted spoiled as well. I went back to the register and let “Maddie” know. Her first words were “our ice cream isn’t spoiled.” I told her both that I purchased tasted spoiled so she gave me a refund. The same thing happened last year around...read full review
Cone Cottage offers a variety of ice cream treats, including classic flavors like vanilla and chocolate as well as unique mix-ins. The atmosphere has a nostalgic, small-town feel, and the staff is generally friendly. While the service can be inconsistent during busy times, the soft-serve ice cream itself is consistently good. The addition of slots has changed the vibe, making it feel less child-friendly. Despite some minor issues, Cone Cottage remains a popular spot, especially on warm days, with offerings like the "Elephant Poop Blaster" flurry and a doggie sundae that delights four-legged customers. Overall, it's a solid choice for a classic ice cream experience.