22 Best Pizza Restaurants near Johnston City

1 T-Moe's Pizza

4.5 Superb 227 Reviews

1011 Prosperity Avenue, Johnston City

• Delivery

“All around one of the best places with tasty pizzas and much more with big selections if your hungry for something other than pizzas I strongly suggest T-Moe’s pizza with other options to eat delicious pizzas burgers fries and nachos and fried mushrooms and fried ravioli and fried pickles and salad and much more to try including pasta and much more and the service is amazing and great staff and amazing prices”

2 Newby’s Pizza

4.6 Superb 109 Reviews

406 South Pershing Street, Energy · 6.41 miles

• Delivery

“The $5 slice and drink deal is amazing. It's big and so far each time I get it, it's been delicious. It's hard to find places to get lunch that includes a drink for this price.”

3 Pirate Pete's

4.6 Superb 78 Reviews

3000 W Deyoung St Ste 800C, Marion · 5.61 miles

“We had our 4 year olds birthday party here and had around 60 people and we had the best time! From the games to the playsmart and then laser tag, the kids are still talking about how much fun it was! We will definitely be back!”

4 MadMad’s Pizza

4.5 Superb 80 Reviews

200 East Main Street, West Frankfort · 5.34 miles

“Looking for a place to stop for brunch and it's not as easy as you would think. MadMad's Pizza was just the place and service is fantastic.”

5 Tower Square Pizza

4.1 Good 180 Reviews

1207 Tower Square Plaza, Marion · 6.17 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Pizza buffet was well stocked and the pizza was hot. The salad bar gave you plenty of options.”

6 Fazoli's

4.3 Superb 255 Reviews

1135 North Carbon Street, Marion · 5.73 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“My husband and I both had the crispy chicken ranch salad. It was very good and the breadsticks were hot and fresh. Staff was very friendly 👍👍”

7 Godfather's Pizza Express

4.2 Good 45 Reviews

701 East Deyoung Street, Marion · 5.58 miles

• Delivery

“Godfather's Pizza located in Huck's stores in Southern Illinois. Pizza taste great and not bad prices. The cheese is what makes Godfather's pizzas so good. Carryout only. Most Godfather's locations close around 8 or 9 p.m.”

8 Joe’s Pizza & Pasta

4.3 Superb 216 Reviews

313 North Park Avenue, Herrin · 5.56 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Joe's Pizza is a local treasure. Always good food and service. Special mention for Emily, though I don't know her last name. She is always smiling, and makes me look forward to my next visit.”

9 Domino's Pizza

4.0 Good 126 Reviews

820 South Park Avenue, Herrin · 5.73 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This is the Best Domino's I've been to in a while. Tonight they were very busy but they were still very friendly and seemed to work really well together. The food was great and we love the new Domino Pizza.Thank you for fixing my order so quickly. I can't have a lot of garlic and I forgot they put garlic on the crust. Thank you all.”

10 Hunt Brothers Pizza

5.0 Superb 4 Reviews

16273 Pittsburg Road, Pittsburg · 5.22 miles

• Delivery

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings”

11 Walt's | Pizza & Restaurant

3.9 Good 303 Reviews

213 South Court Street, Marion · 6.35 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Definitely recommend Walt’s pizza 🍕 great service and great food and drinks definitely will come back for some great food”

12 Domino's Pizza

3.9 Good 136 Reviews

716 South Logan Street, West Frankfort · 4.91 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We decided to order pizza Tuesday night. Upon pick up it smelled so good we had to try a pice. It was delicious! We regretted not ordering the parmesan garlic bread bites. We pulled over and placed an order and went back for them. They were fresh, hot, and melted in your mouth like butter! Our best Domino’s experience ever was found in West Frankfort, Illinois on a Tuesday night!”

13 Casey's

3.9 Good 125 Reviews

2314 West Main Street, Marion · 6.42 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“My four stars are based on the fact that it's fast pizza. It's by no means Italian restaurant level pizza, but it's very good for fast food pizza.As for this location, the people were super friendly and the place was clean.I've never had Casey's pizza but I wanted to give it a try.Would I have it again, maybe, only because I much prefer local family owned restaurant pizza.”

14 Godfather's Pizza Express

4.2 Good 4 Reviews

2700 West Main Street, Marion · 6.58 miles

• Delivery

“I love them pizzas!!! 😋🍕😋”

15 Godfather's Pizza Express

5.0 Superb 1 Review

3228 South Park Avenue, Herrin · 7.15 miles

• Delivery

16 Bennie's | Italian Foods

4.1 Good 274 Reviews

309 North Market Street, Marion · 6.08 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I took one star away on the food because the appetizers were good not great. I think serving a dipping sauce with the cauliflower and the mushrooms would make them better. Loved the decor, the personal pictures of the original owners and the current owners. Really enjoyed the staff's knowledge of the history of the restaurant, the building, and the original family that started Bennies. Staff was top notch! Definitely a place I would go back to.”

17 Joe's Pizza & Pasta

3.7 Good 76 Reviews

602 North Court Street, Marion · 5.95 miles

• Delivery

“Fantastic food & customer service!”

18 Little Caesars Pizza

3.6 Good 49 Reviews

2420 Ken Gray Boulevard, West Frankfort · 5.5 miles

“Just stopped in here tonite for some original pizzas on the go. They made us fresh pizzas fast and it was the BEST Little Caesars pizza we have ever had! We travel and have tried the pizza at many different locations all over the US. This is by far the best location we have visited. Thank you for the delicious pizza guys!”

19 Pizza Hut

3.6 Good 125 Reviews

700 North Carbon Street, Marion · 6.03 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I've never had a personal issue with this establishment. The $3 personal pans are such a great deal. The only problem I have is one of the girls wears fake nails and acrylic nails should not be in the restaurant industry, especially when you are messing with food without gloves.”

20 Domino's Pizza

3.6 Good 192 Reviews

205 West Deyoung Street, Marion · 5.52 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I don't just jump and throw five stars out. If you've followed me for any of the last 15 years, you would know that . With that knowledge, I am giving five stars to this location because of the evening shift manager, Suzy. I had a problem with the app. The app said the hotel was not able to be delivered to. It's 2 mi from the delivery place. Couldn't figure out the app, couldn't get much customer service from the stupid AI that Domino's uses.. But when I called the local shop, I couldn't get any help from the people on the phone, so I politely asked him to please give me a manager. When Suzy came on I gave her my spiel about being stranded at the hotel and I figured it'd be no problem. I'll just order pizza and a drink on the app and be okay till I'm picked up in the morning, and that was not how it ended up going down. I told her I don't like giving my credit card out over the phone. I was just wanting to get a small pizza for some food because I hadn't ate all day. Suzy took it upon herself, hearing the situation that I was in and the problem I was having, she graciously offered to make this meal on her. I reluctantly accepted as I wanted to take care of it with corporate but corporate doesn't do things in the evening and I was starving. Suzy saved my night, cured my hunger and made a new friend. Hey Domino's you ought to give some praise to this manager, Suzy. She did her customer service. She took care of the customer and she provided service. I plan to thank her in person tomorrow when she comes on her shift. (I did) But I think Domino's should let her know that they appreciated her keeping a customer happy. Because I really didn't want to call Pizza Hut or the other company. I don't like those pizzas. I only like my thin crust Domino's. Thank you Suzy for doing your job above and beyond. I know that what you did was special. And I let your driver know that you were special for doing that. Thank you thank you thank you. Crazy”

21 Papa Johns Pizza

3.5 Good 115 Reviews

1120 North Carbon Street, Marion · 5.73 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Thanks Richard for always reminding me to add the cookie to my order so I don't get in trouble when I get home.”

22 Little Caesars Pizza

3.5 Good 136 Reviews

1301 Enterprise Street Ste 10A, Marion · 5.66 miles

• Delivery

“though I work there as The Sign Shaker it's a pretty fun and look forward to place to be and everyday we press onward to give the Service that will costumers coming back!!! P.s Question to the community of Marion IL what could we do better to see that you want to continue driving into our store?”