17 Best Pizza Restaurants in Normal

1 Pizza Payaa

4.8 Superb 311 Reviews

107 East Beaufort Street Ste C, Normal

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We went here yesterday after the sports card convention at ISU with no idea what to expect, we just all agreed that we wanted a good, local pizza that we could not get back home. All of us on the trip agreed that this place was OFF THE CHARTS EXCELLENT FOOD. The atmosphere of the restaurant was kind, friendly, prompt, well-cleaned, and cosy. While I may get this wrong, the pizza to me was like a premium quality, perhaps modified blend of an artisinal with ultra fresh, ultra high-quality ingredients with everything someone would love about a Detroit style. I am a "pizza guy" and I am talking like top 5 lifetime pizza places for me. Definitely my favorite new pie that I have tried out over the last several years!😀 I will have to find a convenient excuse to get back to the area from 3 hours away soon just so I can visit again! Thanks for a great meal and outstanding service!”

2 Pizza Payaa Truck

4.7 Superb 177 Reviews

107 East Beaufort Street, Normal

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We went here yesterday after the sports card convention at ISU with no idea what to expect, we just all agreed that we wanted a good, local pizza that we could not get back home. All of us on the trip agreed that this place was OFF THE CHARTS EXCELLENT FOOD. The atmosphere of the restaurant was kind, friendly, prompt, well-cleaned, and cosy. While I may get this wrong, the pizza to me was like a premium quality, perhaps modified blend of an artisinal with ultra fresh, ultra high-quality ingredients with everything someone would love about a Detroit style. I am a "pizza guy" and I am talking like top 5 lifetime pizza places for me. Definitely my favorite new pie that I have tried out over the last several years!😀 I will have to find a convenient excuse to get back to the area from 3 hours away soon just so I can visit again! Thanks for a great meal and outstanding service!”

3 The Westside Blono

4.2 Good 319 Reviews

1304 Cross Creek Drive, Normal

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We love BloNo! My boys ask to go on a regular basis. It’s worth the hour drive up for us.”

4 Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza

4.7 Superb 125 Reviews

1531 East College Avenue, Normal

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“I feel like the whole team there does a great job. I'm always greeted with a smile and no matter how busy they are, they take time to get it right. You won't find a better $5 Friday around. All around good product, clean and great staff.”

5 Firehouse Pizza & Pub

4.1 Good 276 Reviews

129 East Beaufort Street, Normal

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The place is great. The pizza came out less than 3 minutes after we ordered it. The drinks were ludicrously tall and the pizza was the best I’ve had in years. We split the bill 3 ways and got a full meal and drink for 8$ per person. Exactly what every restaurant should strive to be.”

6 D.P. Dough

4.0 Good 287 Reviews

121 East Beaufort Street, Normal

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“OM Goodness, I love the Spinner Zone Calzone!!! This is so very amazing and made with the freshest ingredients!!!”

7 Cardinal Place Pizza

4.2 Good 68 Reviews

1608 Northbrook Drive Suite 105, Normal

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Best pizza ever! I used to eat there in the 60’s 70’s and 80’s in East Peoria. Now I have them shipped to me in Texas. Still good as ever!”

8 Casey's

4.3 Superb 52 Reviews

810 Beech Street, Normal

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Wish I got the gentleman's name. He was very helpful with me and my granddaughter. In the early morning The hot chocolate wasn't working. He came right around and refilled. Then made sure we got what we needed! I have had very bad experience there in the past when visiting. So glad they are getting good help! Thank you 😊”

9 Blaze Pizza

3.9 Good 252 Reviews

1601 East College Avenue, Normal

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Overall great first time experience. I walked in and was asked if it was my first time. I said “yes” and the kind lady explained to me how it works. Although it was relatively self explanatory I still appreciated it. My pizza came out fast and hot. This pizza only costed me $11.”

10 Monical's Pizza

3.9 Good 204 Reviews

1219 South Main Street, Normal

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“awesome service. pizza was very good. not serving alcohol right now so had to have a soda instead of beer with my pizza but that was okay. would go again if in the normal, IL area.”

11 The Landing

4.5 Superb 8 Reviews

200 North University Street, Normal

“This place is like half gas station and half MOD pizza. You can either order your own pizza fresh, or you can browse the many candies and soft drinks they have to offer on the shelves as well as a freezer with ice cream items and a bakery shelf with muffins and sandwiches. Interesting place! Pizza is about average, but keep in mind you can use student flex dollars here!”

12 Firehouse Pizza Ft Jesse

4.1 Good 21 Reviews

1525 Fort Jesse Road, Normal

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Driven by numerous times & never looked like this location was actually open so we never ordered prior to tonight. Garlic cheese bread was really good, especially with the garlic butter sauce. Pizzas overall (NY pepperoni & thin taco) were good - seemed a little on the small side compared to other places. Unfortunately the tortilla chips on the taco pizza were very stale but rest of pizza was good. Ready to go super fast. Will probably order again but may not make our usual Friday pizza rotation.”

13 Avanti's Italian Restaurant

4.0 Good 366 Reviews

407 South Main Street, Normal

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I went to ISU in the 1970's, and Avanti's was always a favorite part of our years on campus. Fifty+ years later, it's always a treat to visit this restaurant and consume their delicious food. Walking into Avanti's is like going back in time to my college days with my friends! Love this place!”

14 Joe's Station House Pizza Pub

3.6 Good 246 Reviews

305 Veterans Parkway, Normal

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“worst pizza I have ever eaten!! dry crust. no seasoning. sauce was aweful. stopped because joes station house in pontiac and streator are staples. what a huge mistake!! server was pleasant. however, strange to see a swap of delivery pizza boxes with another pizza joint. 0 out of 10 oh and the BBQ chicken pizza came odd shaped like it had been dropped 😳”

15 Pizza Hut

3.1 Average 142 Reviews

1700 Parkway Plaza Drive Unit Suite 1, Normal

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Perhaps you could put a bell at the counter so you are aware when customers enter the store. Overall you are well on your way to strongly agree. The cashiers were very courteous and the restaurant was clean. Thank you for your service. We appreciate you all.”

16 Domino's Pizza

3.1 Average 135 Reviews

305 West Beaufort Street, Normal

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The other store basically told me they wouldn't deliver to my area so near to close and this location gratefully obliged even though it's out of their delivery area. On another occasion I placed an order online with the Bloomington location (with cash payment thankfully) and the pizza never even came..”

17 Domino's Pizza

3.2 Average 97 Reviews

1910 East College Avenue, Normal

• Delivery

“Other than them having the minimal amount of staff to run shop and being slammed with orders, causing a slightly longer wait than necessary, this shop is a good stop too or from my job. Food is done fresh and right, shop is clean, staff is friendly even through the stress. Added bonus is this location has drive through!”