50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sleepy Hollow

“we always order from rosatis we order 2 pizzas one double dough and one thin crust when you say light sauce on the double dough they due i never have to say real light because of my stomic i cant have much sauce they always due great for me the other pizza always taste good . thank you for great service“

“We came tonight for the first time for my husband’s birthday. Food was so good. Service was excellent! The cook even came out to ask us how our food was. We will be back!“

“First time there. It’s a 30 minute drive, but we plan to go back. Best ingredients done to perfection. We have loved Lou Malnati’s , but this is equal to if not better. Our family agreed. They drove 1 1/2 hours and said they would come back“

“Great pizza. The management came out of the back to show me the pizza cause he was concerned it was to over done. So he was so kind and deliver another pizza. Great management and most of all Great pizza. 5 stars. Great experince. Thank you.“

“Best pizza able to pick up orders in 20 minutes .“

“We went to Woodfire for my birthday. The food and service is excellent. Vicki was our server and she was very friendly and attentive. The food is so fresh and homemade. The pizza crust is crisp on the outside and chewy on the inside. There is an assortment of types of pizza, but the cheese pizza is the best I’ve ever had. The pasta is rich and delicious. It’s cooked perfectly and the vodka sauce is amazing. The appetizers, home brewed beer, and desserts are phenomenal too. Step aside Coopers Hawk, I have a new favorite restaurant!“

“That Birra Pizza maybe one of the best creations I have ever tasted. Owner is super nice and he created something special. In case you dont know what that is, It is a pizza with beef cilantro and cheese that you dip in an au jus sauce. He crossed mexican food and pizza with an Italian beef 🤯“

“So many styles to choose from. Always hot and tasty! Highly recommend!“

“oven o mo b t n as v mel yo“

“I went to Dominick's for lunch special! I ordered pepperoni! The whole slice was covered! Not a spot missed! I will have to see if I can wait till next week to get another! 🍕“

“Great food & great service! Especially on a busy night with music in the square going on. They made sure I was taken care of after they saw me waiting to place an order. The traditional Margherita Pizza was delicious!“

“Best pizza in town 100%!!!!“

“Great Chicago deep dish pizza which I miss a lot!!“

“One of my favorite places in Cary. Great owner, super nice and a great business man. I have tried a few different dishes from here and am obsessed with their caprese salad, chopped salad, buffalo chicken wrap, and their cauliflower crust pizza. They have delivery and also pickup. Their fruit when in season is super fresh and I honestly cant even find that fresh at a grocery store. Sometimes I drive 20 minutes to pick up their super fresh caprese salad and fruit side. Definitely recommend giving this place a shot if you haven't already!!! By far one of my favorite go to in Cary!“

“We ordered the thin crust pizza for lunch! The best we had in along time. Fresh ingredients and the crust thin and crispy like we like it. We also had the sandwiches and pizza another time at a relatives. Sandwiches were delicious as well as the pizza. I recommend Chicago Pizza Authority!“

“Village is always a must for us. We love the atmosphere and the vibes everytime we come, Dan is the best“

“Excellent pan pizza and I love their mozzarella sticks!“

“Food was very good! Service started slowly but improved as it appeared that our waiter was initially slammed with a lot of tables. My opinion is to make your reservation in the main/original dining room as the outdoor/indoor area seemed to be loud.sssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss“

“We had rented the back room to films few scenes for our film and also had pizza for the cast and crew. Tanya who was our waitress and coordinator for the setup in the back room was absolutely amazing. She was super friendly and helpful with everything. You can tell she loves her job since she was always smiling. You have a great worker with Tanya. Also, the cast and crew loved the pizza and salads.“

“Our first time there. Sat at the bar and got lucky to chat with the owner Justin who was bartending. He was very friendly and we really enjoyed the food. Definitely a must do.“

“Goodness last night I ordered a pizza puff and a couple pizzas and I’m still thinking about that pizza puff. Literally clapped my hands after eating it. So good. Pizza was great to but that pizza puff gave me life.“

“the foid was good the bartenders friendly, on the spot and gave service with a smile! band was great! dance floor tight tho.“

“Pizza crust is freshly baked and you can absolutely tell this was made in a bakery. Best in the area. Also...crispiest chicken wings I’ve ever had and don’t even get me started on that tres leches cake...SO. DECADENT! Ordered here for my birthday and wasn’t disappointed!! Friendliest owners, too. Can’t wait to go back! #supportlocal“

“It was a great visit for happy hour and our waitress Lani was the best ! She also made our drink in the bar and it was one of the best old fashioned I’ve ever had. We got 2 personal pizzas and meatballs for our appetizer. Great place to wind down after a busy day .“

“We have been going to this amazing spot since they opened. Last night just solidified how awesome this place is. We rented out the upstairs area for a party and it was an epic time up there! The staff and food were beyond unbelievable. I highly recommend there party rooms and highly recommend Sarah! I can’t thank this place enough on how amazing our party was due to them and their care of our guests!“

“I have been ordering from here for years. Great service, great food, prepared fast, and a clean store. But my favorite thing of all is Danielle, the manager! She is so friendly and always remembers me. Thanks for making me feel special, even when I'm just grabbing some pizza!“

“Had such a wonderful experience at MOD Pizza! The pizzas are always delicious, but what made my visit extra special was Dre. He was incredibly patient while I decided on my toppings and super creative with suggestions to make my pizza taste amazing. You can tell he truly cares about the customer experience. Thank you, Dre, for making my visit such a great one!“

“Zzas Italian beef is my absolute fave!! Fresh cut fries are amazing. We just tried meat lovers Square pizza...DELISH!“

“It was my first time ordering. I ordered when I walked in. It took about 15 minutes to cook. The pizza was made fresh. It was also cool to watch the owner making not only my pie but to others.
While the pizzas were in the oven, Cindy and I had an enjoyable conversation about food at other restaurants, which included chocolate cake and real strawberry milk shakes.
When I arrived home to enjoy my pie, I must say that it was one of the best that I have had in a while. It was worth the 30 minute drive.
Thank you Cindy! 😆 I will be back. 😀“

“We were a party of 6 and our first time at a Mod. Julie was our server and she did great. She helped me get signed up on the app and we ended up getting a free no name cake dessert. I rated the food highly because I'd never been in a pizza restaurant before where it was free unlimited toppings and everyone ate their own pizzas (mini mods). If I had any suggestion I'd like to see an expanded menu with some non red sauce related options but I had a Caesar salad and added chicken to it and that was really good.“

“This is our go-to place for gluten-free pizza. As opposed to another popular nearby pizza place, the crust is actually fully baked. The GF crust is decent. Not as good as real crust, but better than others in the area. As with any GF pizza, I’d recommend eating it all the first night, as it’s never as good reheated.“

“Got a deep dish Ultimate on our way through to WI. So glad we did. The pizza is amazing. Even the next day it heats up great and is still delicious. Crust on the bottom is crispy but not overdone and the top is fluffy with tons of toppings and cheese. They were very friendly as well. Definitely give it a try“

“Always great service and excellent food! The pizza is the best!“

“I don’t know what it is, but something about Dinos pizza makes me crave it over all other local pizza. Thanks to the chef who makes an amazing pizza!“

“Village is always a must for us. We love the atmosphere and the vibes everytime we come, Dan is the best“

“Miss this place it’s been years. And it didn’t disappoint. We got the western.“

“Best Service Best food All The Time. Free Delivery up until 3 That's Awesome 🤨“

“Great pizza, wish they had zeppole on the dessert menu, it’s the only Rosati’s location I can’t find them at which results me in ordering from the next restaurant. I attached what zeppole look from the other locations, they don’t even have the appetizer version with the marinara. Crazy because they’re big sellers at other locations and they run out.“

“I have been ordering from here for dinner where I work. We all aty work enjoy the pizza & appetizer. I ordered a Chicken Ceasar salad, a small BLT pizza & an Italian Beef with giardiniera with a side of adjustable. Well my coworker told me she only received 1 small Ceasar dressing for the salad (2 or 3 for the salad would have it nicely covered), Italian Beef was a fully disappointment. I would NEVER recommend that at all. The menu for the Italian Beef is NOT true at all. The menu says "NOW WITH MORE MEAT", well I received more giardiniera then meat. When I called she told me that it was 6ozs. of meat that all beefs get. I can tell you as a former line cook that packaged Italian Beef that what I received was NOT 6ozs since I packaged 7ozs of Italian Beef. I DO NOT recommend the Italian Beef at all. I was excited to get the be since all I heard was good things but when I received it and looked at the sandwich it was giardiniera with very little Italian Beef and I received 2 large containers of auju. I was really DISAPPOINTED on the sandwich and the answer that they gave me. If your menu says "NOW WITH MORE MEAT" 6ozs is not enough. It was a GIARDINIERA sandwich with Italian beef... Other pizza I will not order anything else. VERY DISAPPOINTED.... Pictures will be posted...“

“Great food (especially their deep dish pizzas) and quick, friendly service! Would definitely recommend 👍“

“We recently had a luncheon at Moretti's in Elgin after the funeral of my mother, and I cannot say enough good things about our experience. From the beginning, the professionalism of manager, Felicia, her kindness, and willingness to make this as easy as possible for us during such a difficult time is deeply appreciated. Everything was top-notch: the accommodations, the food, and the service. We can and will definitely recommend for anyone needing a venue in the future. Thank you so very much!“

“I've ordered here a few times in the past but never had to order for a party. So yesterday I ordered pizza from these guys I was a bit impatient at the time. I was trying to find out what kind of special they had and it was hard to understand because they were talking so fast I unfortunately snapped a little bit as I asked him to slow down so I can understand what kind of specials they had he did it without any complaints and I ordered a few pizzas. When I showed up to pick up my pizza they were super busy. Our pizzas were made perfectly for what I asked for. I like ours a little crispier than most but not burnt. I got to give it to those guys they handled it very well specially when I was a little Snappy on the phone and now I understand why they were talking so fast because they were crazy busy when showed up. Even though they were that busy my pizza still came out great and cooked to the way I liked. So I felt like I needed to write a post about how good these guys were and thank them for their great pizza and patience.“

“Disappointing. Have given this place a few tries, but last night was the last. Ordered a sausage pizza and there literally was 1 piece of sausage per slice on majority of the slices of pizza. Some slices actually had no sausage. Plus it was dry. Lifted up the cheese and there was barely any sauce. And, end pieces had no cheese. Took a pick when it was mostly gone....we were hungry so ate in anyways. We were very disappointed. A bad night maybe ? They weren't busy at all, no one inside. Really wanted to love this place, but....“

“I wish they had dine in but this is my go to for pizza since we found it. I love the ground beef topping on my pizza and this place does it very well. Great ratio of sauce to cheese. Not too much cheese. The crust is very good. We love it here.“

“I’ve been to plenty of pizza places, but Papa Saverio’s really stands out. The pizza is always hot, fresh, and loaded with toppings. The crust has the perfect balance of crisp and chew, and the sauce actually tastes homemade—not bland like a lot of other chains. Beyond the pizza, their pasta, sandwiches, and wings are just as good. The portions are generous and you always get your money’s worth.

The staff here is friendly, fast, and they actually care about getting the order right. Whether I call in, order online, or stop by for pickup, everything runs smoothly. It’s rare to find a place that feels this consistent.

If you’re looking for a place that serves quality food with great service, Papa Saverio’s is the spot. Easily my go-to in town!“

“I am always very impressed with how clean, organized and maintained this location is!!! Thank you for giving us a very nice place to allow our children to have fun and be safe! Management should definitely applaud their employees for keeping this place top notch!“

“I usually don't write reviews, but I was so impressed with this place that I had to. I was craving a sandwich coming south on Randall and found this place through Google Maps. I called and ordered the Italian Cold Cut panini. This was one of the best sandwiches I've had around here. I'm from the east coast, where sandwiches are thick. White Cottage did not disappoint.“

“DELISH!!!! The Chicago Classic is a MUST HAVE! And the service is great :-)“

“The staff was very generous in correcting a mistake on our order, THANK YOU Riverview!“

“I’ve lived in Carpentersville for a few years now and tried Masi’s on a whim really last night and it was excellent! We tried the pizza, fried pickles and moz sticks. Everything was fantastic. I think even the ranch was homemade. I would highly recommend trying this place if you haven’t! I will be ordering again.“