11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Chesterton

“Aliyah was an amazing waitress. It was incredibly busy for a Tuesday night but she kept her head held high! She kept our drinks full and served our food hot. We would love to have her as our server every time!!“

“Best thin crust ever!! Been eating their pizza for over 30yrs....Nothing compares“

“We met friends here for dinner and hubs and I split a small pizza with tomatoes and onions and a small house salad. It was the perfect size for us! He ate four pieces of pizza and I ate two (one piece was a little bigger than the others), The sauce was a nice sweet sauce and there was lots of cheese with tiny diced tomatoes. We got to choose between white and red onions. We chose red, and they weren't too hot, so we were pleased. They had several crust types to choose from.

The salad was quite big; head lettuce, tomatoes, mushrooms, onions, cucumbers, green peppers, cheese, and croutons, and the ranch dressing was quite tasty.

Our friends split an XL sausage and cheese pizza and it was plenty big for the three of them. It probably could have easily fed four, five, six, depending on how hungry you are.

I believe that pizza isn't as good unless you drink root beer with it. The root beer was soooo good (of course, I haven't had a root beer in ages). This was definitely an excellent recommendation. Next time we're in town, we'll return.

The only issue we had was the volume level was quite loud. The ceilings are high and not finished, so the voices bounce all over the place, only getting louder and louder, and then you have to speak louder in order to be heard by the person sitting next to you, and it's a vicious circle. If they just lowered the ceilings or put in sound dampening panels, it would be much more enjoyable.“

“Gal over the phone talked me into some moz sticks along with our pizza, (homemade) OMG, they were delicious, and so was the pizza! Glad they came closer. New Buffalo is to far for a great pizza!

Kid-friendliness: Yes kids are more than welcome, beautiful little bar in the back.. Chesterton’s new best kept secret“

“Tasted the moonshine at the European market and the ladies running the booth were very nice! They told us about the pizza of the month which had spinach artichoke and chicken on it!! This should DEFINITELY be a constant menu item it was phenomenal!! Also got the spinach artichoke dip which tasted so good! However it would’ve been helpful to have a spoon along with it for scooping:) Great drinks and great food!! Highly recommend! Wouldn’t hurt to have a few more menu options but overall excellent experience!“

“You won’t be disappointed when you visit this restaurant! A Great atmosphere,both friendly and family oriented,also features authentic recipes and amazing food quality. They feature a pizza of the month with a flakey pastry crust and ingredients for a flavor that doesn’t disappoint. For a good time,great service and great food visit the Chesterton Gelsasamos“

“Italian cheese bread is a main staple at this house! Once a week at the least, with crazy bread and cheddar cheese to dip! Only bad thing is their garlic dipping sauce, way to buttery to dip inShould be more like salad dressing, less like butter. I would love if their garlic dip was like Pizza Hut!“

“Excellent thin crust pizza!!!“

“Had a really bad order delivered, missing items and incorrect proportions along with bad tastes. Not the norm for this location. Since the cell phone on order was an old number I had to call to request a refund. Was so disappointed with the order that was never going to order here again but was informed it was completed by another stores manager. So I decided I'd give them one more try and they did NOT disappoint. Not only did they remake my entire order (a $60+ order at that) but they also threw in a free desert. Both the manager and store owner/gm were extremely professional and helped to make the mistake of another stores employee right! Truly thankful for their time and effort and getting to enjoy our favorite pizza again 😋“