13 Best Italian Restaurants in Elkhart

Antonio's Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
1105 Goshen Ave, Elkhart

Customers` Favorites

Hand Battered Mozzarella Sticks
Seafood Ravioli in Alfredo Sauce
Alfredo Shrimp Penne Pasta
Italian Stallion Pizza 14
Eggplant Arugula Salad
Chocolate Mousse Cake
Award Winning Pizza
Lasagna Bolognese
Chicken Parmesan
Fried Calamari

“This place is by far the best Italian restaurant in Elkhart. When we pulled in after work the parking lot was full of cars. It was a 20 minute wait but we were informed that there were two seats at the bar out back if we wanted them. We decided to go for it. Great decision. We started off with a couple of cocktails which were served up quick. The bartender was phenomenal. Given that the restaurant was packed wall to wall, she was extremely attentive. Funny, too. I had the chicken tortellini soup. I could have eaten that by itself. It was a giant bowl. Seasoned perfectly. Huge pulled chicken pieces and tortellini. I also had the pasta ala carte. Soccotini with marinara sauce and mushrooms. It was superb. Perfectly seasoned. The soccotini was stuffed with Italian sausage. Large portions. I took it home for lunch the next day. The food, service and ambiance of Antonio's was like eating at home with my family and friends. Everyone knew each other. My buddy had lasagna which he raved about. He also took home leftovers for lunch the next day. We decided then and there that we would back to try the award winning pizza. I can't say enough good things about Antonio's. When you travel for work it is nice to find a jewel out there wandering around. Peace and love!“

4.5 Superb105 Reviews
Milano's Pizza Pizza • $
2808 S Main St, Elkhart

Customers` Favorites

Medium Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza
Sausage Pizza Milano's Special
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Homemade Chicken Noodle
Fried Chicken Dinner
2 Toppings Pizza 16
With Broccoli Sauce
X-Small Combo Pizza
Eggplant Parmigiana
2 Toppings Pizza 20

“milanois has been a go to for my family for over 35yrs.. Always the best pizza,toppings incredible. Usually get it to go, but have had alot of my parents, siblimgs,kids bdays to eat in.Always fresh,delicious toppings!!! Have had alot of other dishes besides pizza all good..When my family goes its for tje pizza!!!!“

4.6 Superb52 Reviews
Michael's Italian Restaurant Italian • $
528 Harrison St, Elkhart

Customers` Favorites

Veal Parmigiana with Side of Spaghetti Dinner
Garlic Bread with Cheese & Marinara Sauce
Chicken Parmesan Sandwich
Spaghetti with Meatballs
Italian Club Sandwich
Cheese and Crackers
Chicken Parmigiana
Godfather Sandwich
Meat Lovers Pizza
Eggplant Parmesan

“If you're looking for an authentic neighborhood Italian restaurant with great food and great service in a quaint setting, head to Michael's. It is a hidden gem. The pizza is phenomenal, I can't wait to go back and try some of their entrees especially the eggplant parmigiana.“

4.4 Superb90 Reviews
Simeri's Beardsley St Tavern Bar • $
1737 W Beardsley Ave, Elkhart

Customers` Favorites

8 pcs Chicken Wings with 1 Dipping Sauce with Bleu Cheese or Ranch
Fried Pork Tenderloin Sandwich
Jumbo Hand Dipped Onion Rings
Monday Special Burger
Bacon Cheeseburger
Chicken Wrap
Fried Pickles
Frog Legs
Steak

“I just happen to be in the area, trying to pass time. I decided to Google a restaurant close by. I came across several in the area but their ratings were not so good.However, Simeri's rating was acceptable so I decided to give it a shot.The environment was very warm, comfortable, and clean.The staff was very friendly and courteous. The other patrons were friendly as well. They were eager to greet my friend and I without hesitation...(Jess and her Dad) That made us feel a little more at ease.I was supposed to return Thursday for the live band but unfortunately, I was unable to. However, I do plan on returning, soon!The food was great: fried whole chicken wings, smelt dinner, and mozzarella sticks!The pricing was reasonable too!If you looking for a friendly place to relax, listen to some music, good food, and a good vibe...visit this place!“

4.5 Superb41 Reviews
Volcano Pizza / Easy Shopping Place Pizza Takeaway • $
126 Easy Shopping Pl, Elkhart

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Sausage and Banana Pepper Pizza
Sausage Pepperoni Onions Black Olives
Italian Sandwiches
The Works Sandwich
Italian Spaghetti
Garden Salads
Breadsticks

“Even though we order delivery it is always fresh our delivery driver goes above and beyond this place is amazing if you haven't tried it you must not live in Elkhart because this is one of the best pizza places around I can remember coming here as a kid and I have grandkids of my own now seems like a family tradition when we order our takeout“

4.3 Superb56 Reviews
Per Bacco Ristorante Italiano Italian • $$
28046 Co Rd 16, Elkhart

Customers` Favorites

Complementary Oil & Bread
Spaghetti with Meatballs
Meatballs in Vodka
Homemade Tiramisu
Homemade Lasagna
Lemon Curd Cake
Cheese Pizza
Carrot Cake
Vodka Sauce
Bruschetta

“Oh, we had such a delightful dinner at Perbacco - Jorden Wizard waiter and she was wonderful. Everyone enjoyed the food delicious the portions are huge. I will go back just for the vodka and sauce and meatballs. The tiramisu and the carrot cake were enough to feed a family, I love the tiramisu wasn't so cracked up about the carrot cake but others in my family loved it about the only thing I can add is that please inquire as to reservations and the status of people we were there with our elderly parents and they wanted to sit at a high top table just by looking at us when we walked in you could tell that probably would not be the best option. And the Pam martini was delicious. Great recommendations all around.“

4.3 Superb50 Reviews
Saylor's Pizza & More Pizza • $
2047 Oakland Ave, Elkhart

Customers` Favorites

Pizza with Two Toppings
Ham & Cheese Sandwich
Chicken Strips Dinner
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Bacon Ranch Pizza
Specialty Pizza
Baked Spaghetti
Catfish Dinner
Garlic Bread
Cheese Pizza

“Every time I come to this establishment, Saylor's Pizza, I am greeted with a smile. The service is super quick. Prices are reasonable for my whole family. I paid $26, for a XXL two topping pizza. My favorite ?? I LOVE how they DO NOT AUTOMATICALLY, cut their slices into large ones it's cut perfectly for every age in our family from 2-53 years of age.The main issue that I have with this establishment is, when you walk into the doors it's a very small ordering area.Saylor's deserves more funding to get bigger.Vegetarian options: This business is clean and I'm sure, that they will sterilize and use different gloves to make your cravings perfect.Dietary restrictions: You say no cheese, then no cheese.Parking: 15 to 20 parking spaces, but that depends on how everyone parks. Open parking.Kid-friendliness: Yes, indeed. The staff are very nice and they have kids too.“

4.2 Good53 Reviews
Rulli's Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
54595 County Rd 17, Elkhart

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Cheese Bread
Pizza Pizza Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Personal Pizza
House Salad
Lasagna
Papa

“Food was good but impressed with how accommodating they were. Our party of 4 met for lunch and ended up talking for over 4 hours. Instead of kicking us out, they simply moved us to another table and continued checking on us. Our server was super nice, and we really appreciated the time, so we tipped well when we left!“

4.1 Good40 Reviews
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Italian • $
3003 Brittany Ct, Elkhart

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp Alfredo Fettuccine Alfredo Tossed with Saut
Never Ending Dipping Sauces for Breadsticks
Strawberry Limoncello Margaita
Chicken & Shrimp Carbonara
Chocolate Brownie Lasagna
Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
Create Your Own Pasta
Salad and Breadsticks
Sicilian Cheesecake
Chicken Parmigiana

“Got phenomenal help when my family arrived! The entire crew I saw was very considerate, and they were all young!! I also liked how our waitress served all the correct stuff and was so pleasant to help get our stuff quickly! I am not able to walk. I was in a terrible hard car accident a few months ago. I greatly appreciative of any person or place that respectfully interacts with me. Olive Garden definitely did! Thank you to them for sure!!Kid-friendliness: They definitely have a good kid atmosphere and a play area outside!Wheelchair accessibility: Got to my table very carefully. Care for me being in a wheelchair was definitely there!“

4.1 Good110 Reviews
Fazoli's Italian • $
1248 N Nappanee St, Elkhart

Customers` Favorites

Pumpkin Cheesecake from the Cheesecake Factory Bakery
Cheesecake Factory Bakery Cinnamon Roll Cheesecake
Spaghetti with Meat Sauce and a Salad
Side Salads Made Fresh Every Day
Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken
Baked Spaghetti with Meatballs
Cheesy Double-Stack Lasagna
Cinnamon Swirl Breadsticks
Philly Cheesesteak Ravioli
Chicken Broccoli Alfredo

“We took our 5 kids here because it's something we did as kids ourselves and it didn't disappoint. The service was wonderful and the girl who was working was just the sweetest. I think people often forget how customer service is so important. Our kids gave it a 10/10 except one who said 9/10 because she didn't have enough ranch ?“

4 Good66 Reviews
Bruno's home of the 24” Pizza Simonton Italian • $
51513 IN-19, Elkhart

Customers` Favorites

Sausage and Cheese Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
Chicken Pizza
Plain Cheese

“I had ordered the chicken bacon and ranch pizza. First off there's a ton of exposed crust on their pizza. Not really a fan, I'd rather my pizza be as covered from end to end as possible. 2nd the pizza was DRY. You guys need to learn that when you use a sauce that has fat in it ( dairy) is going to soak into the bread. You have to use more ranch as your sauce. And 3rd I asked for half with bacon and onion, half without. The way it was cut you can't tell which was which at all =( gotta do better at that guys. I'll try you again in the future but I'll know to ask for these things specifically to be different, if not I'll just move along.“

3.8 Good24 Reviews
Bruno's Pizza Pizza • $$
28046 Co Rd 16, Elkhart

Customers` Favorites

Supreme Meat Lovers
House Salad
Cake

“Best pizza I have ever had in all the U.S. you definitely get your money's worth here. They don't skimp on the toppings and they always cook to perfection. The staff is always kind and friendly. We live in Tennessee and everytime we go to Indiana we have to get our Bruno's pizza!!“

3.9 Good44 Reviews
Jet's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
153 Co Rd 6, Elkhart

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch
4 Corner Pizza
Meat Pizza
Hawaiian
Jet 10

“Quick and easy online ordering. Track your pizza on the app. Pick-up normally in 20 minutes after order is placed. And a good product.My usual is a large jets 10, Detroit style, with the turbo flavorized crust. The Hawaiian is my second choice. Also very good.FYI : Don't forget to check mark the box at the end of an online order or your order won't go through and doesn't let you know that it didn't. I ended up at Jets just to find out they didn't have any record of my order, because of that.“

3.5 Good33 Reviews
Loading...

Enjoy More Tastes In Elkhart

map Map