23 Best Pizza Restaurants near Garrett

“We stopped in on a rainy day for a quick breakfast before heading home out of town. Our server, Maddie, was friendly and helpful, as well as the guy who delivered our food. I have tons of dietary issues so was thrilled that all menu items breakfast through lunch are available all day, so I had a lot to choose from, and Maddie made sure my meal was exactly the way I needed it. My roasted turkey sandwich on marble rye, and side of fruit, were so fresh and delicious. My husband said the same of his South of the Border omelet. If we were locals, we'd return in a heartbeat.“

“The hot honey pizza absolutely SLAPS“

“I wanted to take the time to reach out to the Garrett, Indiana Pizza Hut and extend my sincerest gratitude for saving my husband and my wedding this last Saturday, September 18th. In the face of crisis and in incredible time, you and your team rolled out 35 pizzas for our wedding reception when our previous food vendor inexplicably decided not to serve us. You truly all saved the day and our wedding, and we can’t thank you enough. Thank you so much ❤️“

“This is a wonderful local pizza place. One of the workers helped bring out the pizza to my car so I didn’t have to juggle both my baby and my pizzas. I love small town hospitality so much and I am so thankful for this.“

“Delicious pizza and grinders! Fast delivery and great dining 5 out of 5!“

“Got the Veggie Lovers personal pan pizza. Yum! 😋 Nice atmosphere. Some old school Pizza Hut character, with some modern touches like a LED/gas fireplace with flat rock hearth, skylights and decorative vase glass pendants.

Vegetarian options: Salad bar and vegetable pizza. I think I saw some pasta dish too, but not positive as I didn't order the pasta.“

“This place has great pizza! I don't know about service. I went during the fair so they were outside selling pizza too. Rhat might be why it took forever to get service. Took quite a while foe pizza to get to the table too. They had games to alleviate the wait time. Overall giving them a pass on service due to how phenomenal the pizza was! They have a rocket game that seems cool but it isn't it just goes back and forth you can't control it just so you know.

Kid-friendliness: Them have games to play but they are old so watch out! One of them stole our money.“

“Everything has very good flavor. Subs, calzone's and the pizza. Chicken Bacon ranch is probably favorite yet preference for ham onion green olive. cheese, dough and SAUCE...all great.“

“Got the loaded crust pepperoni and it exceeded my expectations! And of course I got the Peanut butter and jelly dessert pizza, it is BOMB DOT COM! Y'all need to come just for that!!! Wish there was an East Of Chicago Pizza closer, but I don't mind driving 35 min for this!“

“We order online and pickup a delicious pizza every week. They also have delivery. Never been inside so don't know the atmosphere. The pickup service is very friendly and know my husband by name, he's been there so often. So glad they opened a place in Huntertown so we don't have to drive to Ft Wayne anymore.

Parking: Plenty of parking right in front.“

“I purchased pizza today 12/27/24 and there was only one worker there who was very nice. He took my order, and the pizza was done in only like 10-15 minutes. The pizza was very delicious, and I would recommend it to anyone who wants pizza and is new to or visiting Auburn.“

“There was a mistake in billing when I ordered on the internet. The manager personally reached out to me and apologized. Not only did he do that which I respected, he made it more than right! When I order from Pizza Hut in the future it will be at the Auburn Pizza Hut!!“

“I ordered my food and walked around town until it was done. They were extremely friendly when I picked up & quick. My daughter loved her pizza & breadsticks. My sandwich was delicious. We will be trying more things on the menu in the future!“

“Now this group of people know how to cook pizza and stuff. They should show the other little Ceasars how to cook em. Cooked to perfection every time I pick one up. The right amount of toppings, the right amount of baking equals perfection. Thank you all. Kendallville and angola could only wish they could cook as awesome as yall. And the friendly people are great as well they'd have to be, to cook this good.“

“Our friends moved from Indy to Maine and were craving Pizza King so bad that we ordered 3 cooked and then frozen pizzas and took them out there in coolers. ABSOLUTELY AMAZING! They were perfect and delicious! Pizza King Auburn went above and beyond for us and made a truly wonderful memory for us and our friends!“

“The workers here are beyond exceptional. My kid eats a specific type of pizza and they make sure it’s done according to his preference every time. If they happen to make a mistake, they are quick to correct it before I even pick it up. Fantastic service!“

“Came in with my two kids. My son is autistic and was having a little melt down. He didn't want to leave the store. Connie offered him a Little Caesars shirt which made his day. This is the best service I have ever experienced. Will got back and recommend to my friends. Keep up the good work!“

“I don't get to eat Papa John's Pizza very often but I have liked it ever since 2014 2015 somewhere in that area. But on all the food was excellent it was hot the cheese was melted right it wasn't overcooked it was all around a good pizza “

“We always like sitting on the bar side. I love their calzones ( can add 3 ingredients you like), my husband got the Hoagie Sandwich with house chips. We've had the Taco Pizza, which is very good. While waiting for our meal they bring out a fresh loaf of homemade bread to slice and dip in the oil w/seasonings. VERY good. Awesome waitress, too.“

“Sat at the bar, traveling on business. Autumn was tending bar and very pleasant, making great suggestions for eats. I had shrimp jambalaya pasta. Very good! Not a huge serving but enough to be satisfied. Beer choices Drunkun Punkun -- really good I thought def Pumpkin flavor, minimal on bourbon barrel taste...which is preferred by me. Auburn Lager which is their Amber was ok.“

“Food was hot and ready as promised. Pizza, wings, and stuffed cheesy bread was great“

“This hidden gem, located in Huntertown, boasts a surprisingly spacious interior and a generously sized outside patio area, despite its modest exterior appearance. However, parking can be limited & the establishment may be challenging to locate. Although smoking is permitted, the ventilation system is highly effective, minimizing the presence of cigarette smoke. I ordered 10 wings, requesting extra crispiness, which unfortunately wasn't achieved, likely due to the smoking process. Nonetheless, the wings were bursting with flavor and remained delicious. The only improvement would be crisper skin. Additionally, we ordered the sausage roll, which was exceptional - arguably among the top three I've ever had. It arrived hot, with a soft yet non-gummy exterior, and was filled with fresh ingredients & lot's of toppings. The $3 long neck beer special was an excellent value. Our waitress provided attentive and helpful service, and the environment was clean and well-appointed. I eagerly anticipate my next visit to try their funnel fries & other menu items!!!“

“First visit was June 13th 2024 during the Leo-Cedarville Farmers Market, and I ordered a single Marco's Sausage Pepperoni Pizzoli with peppers & onions (hadn't eaten all day). My order was done in 10 minutes, and was fresh and hot from the oven. The container had a packet of parmesan, and a cup of pizza sauce, as well as the Pizzoli. The outer crust was crisp and golden brown, and the inside was tender and perfectly baked. The filling was generous and gooey delicious from meats to veggies. All of the Pizzoli was sprinkled generously with parmesan and it was oh so good! The server also added plenty of napkins, which were needed because my meal was juicy and I'm a bit messy when very hungry.

My server was friendly and my experience was very positive all around. Great meal at 3 PM on a Thursday afternoon!

***
My second visit was the day after (Friday at 8:45 PM) and Marco's was much busier. I called in the same order doubled. The person who answered was kind and took my info, but noted they were no longer delivering for the evening. I was told my order would be ready in 20 minutes.

Since I had paid over the phone, I arrived at the appointed time (I only live 5 minutes away) and pulled out my walker and entered the building, struggling to open the entrance-way doors. The young woman had my Pizzoli boxes in hand, and I asked for them to be bagged. I struggled to get the door opened again, but managed to get back to my car.

Once home, I found the containers had no packets of parmesan, nor any cups of pizza sauce or any napkins. And while the Pizzoli were both well baked, the fulling was less generous, and did not fill the end of one side - each had one end that was all bread (about 1/4 of each Pizzoli was just bread).

Both myself and my fellow diner commented on this and chalked the discrepancies up to who made the Pizzoli.
And who served the meal at the counter.

While still a tasty meal, I've taken a star away for the second visit's issues.

For the most part, I would recommend this menu selection from Marco's, but will check my containers and bag to ensure all accompanied items are provided. And I may be inclined to order earlier in the evenings when the business is less busy.“