“We're new to Gary, so we are constantly trying new places. We chose SteelCity based off of the pictures. Then looking at their menu, the options were endless and it was hard to decide.THE SERVICE: I ordered online and wasn't able to pick the time I needed to pickup our food. So I called. Let me tell you...the lady that answered the phone was great. She was patient with me and answered my questions. When I told her it was our first time trying the restaurant, she gave me some of the back story. When I was at the restaurant everybody was great. Not too often I see EVERYONE at an establishment enjoying what they do.THE FOOD: We decided we'd try burgers and 2 different styles of fries. The SteelCity Steak Fries were hands down an amazing experience and plentiful. The burgers were smash burger style and if you're like me, you love the crispy edges.LOCATION: The only issue I had was finding the restaurant. I pass it twice day and had NO IDEA it was there. The Marathon station it shares the space with definitely hides it. BUT...now that we know it's there, we will definitely be going back.Thank you for the great meal and awesome experience.“
“I ordered the rib tips hot link combo with fries. I love the fries, especially with the sauce. The hot links were huge, flavorful and spicy. And the piece of toasted bread they gave was fire. I wish I had two pieces. However, the rib tips lacked a smokey flavor. There was no char so I think they were oven cooked. They didnt give the flavor I’m used to. The portion size was fair. I’ll go back, but not for rib tips.“
“Just had my first ever cheesesteak sandwich! It was so delicious and gave me instant heartburn. No regrets. Next time I'll have my Tums on hand. ?Speedy and friendly counter service (no table service) and very busy during peak meal hours.“
“I really want to love Penn Station but they make it hard. Refer to the otherwise delicious club sandwich with a single, lonely strip of bacon. A quick google search indicates most internet recipes for club sandwiches call for 2-3 strips of bacon, per sandwich.Other than that the sandwich was good, but not great because it was hard to get a proper bite of sandwich goodness with such a meager portion of delicious bacon. At Jersey Mikes they give you two slices but they are usually burnt. Why is it so difficult to find a tasty sandwich properly portioned? By the way what you see here (no drink) cost $14. Next time I want a club sandwich I will make it at home. $14 will buy enough ingredients for 4 sandwiches, as they say on the East Coast PILED HIGH.“
“I'm in love and apparently so is my toddler. Lol We could not get ENOUGH of the Nephew's Special Sandwich ?????Order this NOW!!! It's Chopped Chicken, cheese,onion,mayo,tomato, lettuce and honey mustard ? Got wings too ? and they were good as well ?“