12 Best Pizza Restaurants near Kendallville

“This is a wonderful local pizza place. One of the workers helped bring out the pizza to my car so I didn’t have to juggle both my baby and my pizzas. I love small town hospitality so much and I am so thankful for this.“

“Order on the app and the pizza was ready as I walked thru the door. I walked in and Matt looked up and said perfect timing I was just putting your pizza away. BBQ meatlovers pizzas the best. Pizza looked great and was just what I needed after a long day! Thank you“

“The workers here are beyond exceptional. My kid eats a specific type of pizza and they make sure it’s done according to his preference every time. If they happen to make a mistake, they are quick to correct it before I even pick it up. Fantastic service!“

“Just ate there for the first time today, and I’m so impressed! The pizza is so good! My food was done about 6 minutes before the quoted time frame. UNDER $20 for and XL pepperoni that fed my family and I have leftovers! Will definitely be returning!!“

“You know the food and service is superb when we keep coming back and ordering the same thing over and over again sometimes even multiple days in a row. Right now our favorite is the Italian sub, which is absolutely amazing and tastes Incredible every single time. It’s flavorful and has the right balance of ingredients. It’s toasted and warmed just right and stays warm for an hour. It’s still fresh because delivery is fast. I do find the app clunky and prices could be lower. Overall 5/5.“

“Came in with my two kids. My son is autistic and was having a little melt down. He didn't want to leave the store. Connie offered him a Little Caesars shirt which made his day. This is the best service I have ever experienced. Will got back and recommend to my friends. Keep up the good work!“

“After reading many good comments about your pizza, we came in today to try it - delicious and excellent service. We'll definitely be back and we highly recommend you.“

“Best service, we came in a little over an hour before closing and service was top notch. tried several appetizers and 3 different pizzas. Not disappointed.“

“Amazing pizza with a small town atmosphere! I can’t recommend this place enough!“

“Stopped by Coody Browns on the last night in town for Memorial Day. I loved the lake location and patio, feeding the fish is always fun. I unfortunately can’t remember our waitress’ name but she was an amazing server and made the night! Food was delicious and affordable and came out quick. Overall a great pick if you’re in the area!“

“I wanted to take the time to reach out to the Garrett, Indiana Pizza Hut and extend my sincerest gratitude for saving my husband and my wedding this last Saturday, September 18th. In the face of crisis and in incredible time, you and your team rolled out 35 pizzas for our wedding reception when our previous food vendor inexplicably decided not to serve us. You truly all saved the day and our wedding, and we can’t thank you enough. Thank you so much ❤️“

“Elmo's has good pizza, especially for the price. I like sausage and banana peppers pizza on thin crust. Service is good.

It has been hard to reach them on the phone in the past. Perhaps this has gotten better. You can walk into the gas station and order easily, though. This is probably a better option as it walks you through the menu in a manner that makes it easy to customize your order.“