11 Best Mexican Restaurants in Michigan City

Check out these Michigan City Mexican dining hotspots.

Holly's Restaurant & Pub American • $$
3705 Franklin St, Michigan City

Customers` Favorites

Harbor Ruben and Chips
Sandwich & Onion Rings
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Holly Sampler Platter
Deep Fried Mushrooms
French Dip Sandwich
Chicken Quesadilla
Pulled Pork Nachos
Chicken Fingers
Nachos Grande

“Members of our choir come to Holly's weekly following our rehearsal, and are always treated like royalty! The service, the food, and the prices are phenomenal (not to mention the popcorn!!). We appreciate having a local business that treats their customers right.“

4.6 Superb101 Reviews
El Cajete Mexican • $
3301 Franklin St, Michigan City

Customers` Favorites

Create Your Own Combo Flauta Tostada Chile Relleno
Giant Wet Burrito
Carne Asada Plate
Fajita Quesadilla
Enchiladas Suizas
Chips and Salsa
Chicken Fajitas
Rice and Beans
Tamale Dinner
Chilaquiles

“One of the Mexican places that I've been to in NW Indiana. The menu is large and contains just about everything you could want, the prices are very fair for the very large portion sizes, the chips that you get are very warm and fresh and everything can be summed up in one word AUTHENTIC!“

4.6 Superb70 Reviews
Mucho Mas Mexican • $
727 Franklin St, Michigan City

Customers` Favorites

Mucho Burrito with Chorizo
Soy Chorizo Dynamite
Al a Cart Surf Taco
Chips and Salsa
Fajita Burrito
Black Bean Soup
Chips N Salsa
Chorizo Taco
Steak Tacos
Surf Burrito

“We stopped in for lunch on short roadtrip. Excellent place to get some great food!You order at the counter and they bring your food to the table. We had the steak taco plate, street corn bowl, chips and salsa. The tacos were AMAZING!. They use El Milagro tortillas (which is a big deal for us). The steak is cooked very well and not dry. The street corn was great and it was a pretty big portion.The atmosphere was awesome! They had a playlist of 80's music playing and some older cartoons on the TV!The staff is incredibly friendly and helpful!If your in the area, check them out!“

4.5 Superb77 Reviews
TACOS ON 20 Mexican • $$
429 US-20, Michigan City

Customers` Favorites

Chips and Guacamole
Lengua Beef Tongue
Street Corn Elote
Mexican Jarritos
Pork Al Pastor
Street Tacos
Birria Plate
Quesadilla
Steak

“If you like steak tacos the way I do my son likes the steak my daughter likes the chicken we've had the beef tacos we've had it all people are very polite, and you don't wait for your food too long plus they have other specials and it's a very good place to eat I highly recommend it to any Taco“

4.5 Superb48 Reviews
El Cantarito MC Mexican • $$
336 Dunes Plaza, Michigan City

Customers` Favorites

Steak Tacos with Pico De Gallo
Free Tortilla Chips with Salsa
Steak Burrito El Grande
Chipotle Shrimp Tacos
Lunch Chicken Fajitas
Lunch Shrimp Fajitas
Tacos De Birria
Chips and Salsa
Fajita Nortena
Burria Tacos

“Love this restaurant. This Mexican food almost taste as good as the authentic Mexican food from Juarez, Mexico. We went here for dinner on 22 February 2024 on our last leg home of vacation. I was amazed of how tasty the food was. I had the 3 carnita tacos with refried beans. Bought me back to my memories of visiting Mexico. The atmosphere was warm. Staff was awesome! Restaurant was clean prices were cheap.All in all this will be my go to Mexican restaurant on my way to Chicago or on my way back home. Thanks El Cantarito MC. This, Army veteran was very full and pleased with the quality and quantity of food. Your service was excellent. I will be back?? Just a suggestion: maybe add verde( green sauce as a choice besides red sauce).Parking: Good number of spots.“

4.2 Good66 Reviews
RIOS MEXICAN GRILL #2 Mexican • $
2715 Franklin St, Michigan City

Customers` Favorites

Steak Quesadilla with Cheese
Chicken Chipotle Burrito
Ground Beef Tomato
Steak Nacho Bowl
Chips and Salsa
Chicken Rice
Spicy Pork
Guacamole
Cilantro
Avocado

“It is 6:15 pm and I am currently attempting to get a hold of management regarding a taco which was not place in my bag at the time of purchase, YET I WAS CHARGED FOR IT...I tried calling NUMEROUS times and the call never went through.My receipt doesn't have ANY numbers or totals whatsoever.Cant turn this into the IRS for reimbursement.“

4.1 Good83 Reviews
Taco John’s Mexican • $
10157 N. Love’s Avenue, Michigan City

Customers` Favorites

Tater Tots

“It is a gas station, so….It’s new new so……They forgot cheese on my tacos. But even still- better than the bell.But these tots… omg these tots. I never would have thought tacos and tater tots were a match, and certainly never woulda suspected these tots to be this good!!! Pure artery clogging goodness“

4.1 Good14 Reviews
El Bracero of Michigan City Mexican • $$
4100 Franklin St, Michigan City

Customers` Favorites

Arroz Frijoles Pico de Gallo Lechuga Y Aguacate
Margaritas Carne Asada Tacos & Jalisco Special
Fajitas Con Arroz Frijoles Y Pico de Gallo
Complimentary Chips and Salsa
Birria Taco Plate w Consomme
Seafood Special Fried Rice
Giant Ranchero Burrito
Enchiladas Verdes
Burrito La Porte
Fried Ice Cream

“I grew up in Michigan city everytime I come back I to town I have to stop here and get the Jalisco special. They do not disappoint. Still the cutest little Mexican spot with the best meal. The portion sizes slim down a lot but it's understandable because their prices have not went up. Great service, great food I will of course be back.“

3.8 Good71 Reviews
Leña al Fuego Mexican • $
123 Lighthouse Pl, Michigan City

Customers` Favorites

Steak Tacos with Corn Tortillas
Tortilla Chips and Guacamole
Tacos de Carne Asada Plate
Tacos de Asada
Burritos

“This quaint little Mexican restaurant is nestled in the mall near Zumiez. They have a huge menu, but were happy to make me a vegetarian option. They proceeded to make the best burrito I have ever eaten, and I had a delicious meal with my partner. Lovely place and wonderful staff.Vegetarian options: Chef makes delicious vegetarian options upon request“

3.6 Good19 Reviews
Taco John’s Fast Food • $
10157 N. Love’s Avenue, Michigan City

Customers` Favorites

Tater Tots

“It is a gas station, so….It’s new new so……They forgot cheese on my tacos. But even still- better than the bell.But these tots… omg these tots. I never would have thought tacos and tater tots were a match, and certainly never woulda suspected these tots to be this good!!! Pure artery clogging goodness“

3.5 Good22 Reviews
Hacienda Mexican Restaurants Mexican • $
2148 N Karwick Rd, Michigan City

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Original Burrito
Original Hacienda Taco
Tableside Guacamole
Famous Wet Burrito
Margarita Flight
Chips and Salsa
Food Truck Tacos
Steak Quesadilla
Rice and Beans
Fajitas Mixtas

“What can be said that has not been already? Well the Michigan City location staff rocks. Food was over the top, we all loved everything. The salsa as always just money. Their new ghost pepper pico brings the heat and flavor, better trademark this stuff. Cannot wait to get their again!!!“

3.6 Good112 Reviews
Loading...

Taste More Cuisines In Michigan City

map Map