8 Best Italian Restaurants near Middletown

“LeAndra goes out of her way to make your visit very pleasant.“

“Papa is our new fav pizza place. You cannot beat the price for what you get. The garlic butter knots are the bomb!“

“Got in close to opening. All food fresh, staff was was over the top in accommodating! I thought I should be paying more!!“

“Awesome family owned joint with a great history“

“Wow. This place is amazing !! Their pizza, sandwiches , salads and apps are so yummy. I have never had anything to eat here that wasn't good. However, today they did something to make me a life long customer. I ordered a pizza to take home, On the way home I got an emergency call I had to go help with immediately. Sadly the pizza got left in my very hot car for 2 hours. I called Arts and asked a manager if they thought it was still safe to eat. They just were not sure, so they said bring it back and we will make you a new one, no charge. What!! This was not their fault. I left it in the car, I didn't ask for anything yet they stepped up to offer me a replacment . I live 45 min. away so I didn't go back, but their kindness was unbelieveable.. I am an Arts girl from now on !!“

“I love Olive Garden, the food is always good and the service cannot be beat. This place is awesome!!! Not only did we got way above and beyond service but the owner was there as well asking us how everything was. Dearest reader if you want good Italian food for a far price this is the place for you.“

“I'm not an I'm not an Indiana native, so I didn't grow up eating Pizza King. Now, is it the greatest pizza ever? No. But it is still so much fun to go: Using the phone to order your pizza; The cheese that comes with the breadsticks; The decor. Service here is good. The food is consistent. This is definitely a Muncie staple.“

“Good food had no complaints of any kind“