33 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Palestine

“For some reason, their pizza is better than the other Mozzi’s. I live in greenfield so it’s not feasible for me to eat here often but when I am getting Mozzi’s and can make it down to New Pal, I will always prefer this Mozzi’s. They make sure they are handing you what you ordered by showing you each item before you leave. I appreciate this considerate step. It’s also very clean in there.

Parking: Parking is on the south side of the building right off 52. There are only 3 spots in front but I believe there is more parking behind. I’ve never had to park anywhere else besides the front.“

“Would recommend this Pizza Hut to anyone! We had a huge last day of school party, where I had ordered 12 pizzas at Papa John’s. Three hours before the pizza is set to be delivered, Papa John’s calls saying their ovens were down. Called this Pizza Hut, and they were so helpful, said no problem, we will get your 12 pizzas done and we will give you a better price! I am so impressed, and y’all saved mine and the kiddos day! Pizzas tasted amazing, nothing went to waste!“

“Best pizza in Greenfield, In!!“

“Fun place and the pizza is really good👌🏻“

“We had the BEST pizza there today! We got a cheese and pepperoni & also a deluxe and both of them were sooo so good! Very good prices too. We were impressed!“

“The pizza was hot, freshly made and we were finally able to enjoy a meat lovers pizza! Typically the meat ingredients are made with pork which we do not eat, but to my surprise, this establishment offered beef options such as beef pepperoni , beef sausage and turkey ham. Looks like we have found our new pizza spot and look forward to trying more from the menu.“

“Best pizza in Indiana!!!!“

“My owner was very nice and friendly you personally made our Sundays and he took time to greet us as he was walking from the pizzeria to the ice cream shop very respectful man and I will be going back the sunday's that they made was completely on point they put everything on them things thank you for a great experience and all the families delicious treats“

“We ate at New Bethel Ordinary last Sunday after attending the IU/PU game. What a fabulous finish to a great day. The meat lovers pizza was over the top. Highly recommend....wish we could find a place like this in SWFL!!! Great place, TY!“

“Best pizza in Indy in my opinion. I live 25 miles away and it’s worth the drive“

“Best pizza in Indiana!!!!“

“shout out to marco's pizza on Pendleton pike for awesome customer service an all I really appreciate you all Pierre Pearson“

“We have been buying pizzas here almost every week for the past couple of years and have never been disappointed with the taste or service. They know my order when I call and recognize me and greet me by name. And the 2 for 1 deal can't be beat!“

“the pizza 🍕 is excellent and ALL Staff was very friendly and helpful“

“We ordered ahead for a work function that we needed 3 of the 30” pizzas for. Due to our schedule of events we needed to pick the pizzas up around 10:30. They don’t open until 11 but because of our situation they opened early. I got there at 10:30 to pick up the pizza and as promised, they were all ready. Got them to work and they were delicious. Fed 33 people on 3 pizzas and still had leftovers. It was my first time having Cuginos but because of the excellent service and pizza, won’t be my last.“

“We order here at least monthly! Always so good and exactly what we want!“

“Wings are some of the best in town. Could benefit from adding a few more sauce options. All of the pizzas I have tried are good. Service is a tad slow sometimes, but not terrible. The atmosphere is kitschy and retro cool. The arcade games in the back are a nostalgic touch. It's only unbearable when adults let their children run around screaming.

Parking: Around 10 parking spots. On a weekend night, it gets pretty full.

Kid-friendliness: Very kid-friendly. Arcade games and interesting decor.“

“Good sausage& pepperoni and XLNY 3Cheese pizza. However, I used to really enjoy the crustless pizza when it was first introduced, but it has declined in quality & quantity of toppings and increased significantly in price.

Vegetarian options: Although I am not vegetarian I have eaten the gourmet vegetarian pizza just for something different and it is delicious!“

“From the time we arrived the service was absolutely great. We were created as soon as we walked in and the waitress was very attentive. She kept and eye on us a d check on us just at the right times. The taco nachos were really and everything seemed rather fresh and meat cook well. Nachos also weren't soggy at all which was a big plus. I ended up getting a burger which can't remember exactly name something with "pork" in the name but the meat patties were cooked very well. They maintained enough juicyness and the BBQ pork and onions rings were very good as well. Very minor salad issue with few of the lettuce pieces being the "hard part" part of the lettuce but was till very good. First time coming and definitely won't be the last. Highly recommend to everyone. I love locally owned smaller restaurants!“

“Consistently great pizza!“

“Ordered delivery arrived in time given. Enjoyed the taste of our pepperoni,sausage, onion and mushroom pizza. Definitely a higher quality pizza“

“It was an awesome experience! The customer service from Tera was awesome! She’s an awesome person and she does a good job running the greenfield Dominoes! Also I’m glad you guys up’s your game on the Pizza! Thank you guys for an awesome supper!“

“The food was good the drinks were great! I enjoyed performing and like to go back to visit the live music every weekend!!“

“I love stopping at this particular godfathers pizza as well as this gas station. The employees are always so nice and I dare you to find a nicer and classier bunch of employees in the city as far as Shell stations go. And the pizza and chesters is fire. I even have Chinese food and it’s all clean the place is spotless.“

“We got a deep dish supreme pizza. This pizza was very good. The crust was perfectly crispy. Totally worth the $12 spent.“

“Excellent food and service“

“Late nite pizza at its best!
We had guests in town (from Poland actually) who wanted to try something local.

They LOVED the Pizza King flavor. Famous for their bread sticks and diced pizza toppings, PK did not disappoint. Hint, if you’ve not tried their pan pizza, you don’t know what you’re missing!

Also, our meal was a little later in the day, and yet, Ben was the consummate host and server! He’s one of the kindest and most helpful persons you’ll meet! He makes the Greenfield location shine!

Thanks for a great night of good food and a awesome experience for our traveling friends!“

“Best pizza in Indiana!!!!“

“My children love pizza so I tried to buy from places that I can get deals on Jack's is a little expensive when you have children who love to eat pizza on a regular basis but they are the best the jackpot is my favorite“

“I have been to this location a few times and LOVE the pizza here. I am originally from Nebraska where Godfather's originated. When I start to feel like I need a taste of home, I go here. Very comparable to the pizza from back home. We always call ahead to place our order and the pizza is always good and fresh. We always get a Taco Pizza and a pepperoni pizza.“

“My biscuits and gravy were served with spoiled gravy. It took me a couple minutes to realize the cheese aftertaste was spoiled milk. I've have had diarrhea all day....I will never come back. Clearly unsafe food handling and cooks who do not taste what they are serving.... in 45 years I have never had bad biscuits and gravy until today.“

“Godfathers pizza at 30th and Mitthoefer is ABSOLUTELY AWESOME as well as the price and the service. They are so kind and professional. One of the reasons we go there is definitely the courteous service we receive. I know people are cruel, I have heard them. And they will still serve us with a smile. ??THANK YOU GODFATHERS PIZZA, YOU ROCK!!!!! 30th and Mitthoefer“

“Great place to watch a game, or to have a craft beer“