39 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Palestine

“Best pizza in Greenfield, In!!“

“For some reason, their pizza is better than the other Mozzi’s. I live in greenfield so it’s not feasible for me to eat here often but when I am getting Mozzi’s and can make it down to New Pal, I will always prefer this Mozzi’s. They make sure they are handing you what you ordered by showing you each item before you leave. I appreciate this considerate step. It’s also very clean in there.

Parking: Parking is on the south side of the building right off 52. There are only 3 spots in front but I believe there is more parking behind. I’ve never had to park anywhere else besides the front.“

“Tia's is a first class coffee shop locally owned with good coffee, a breakfast menu with service by Tia and her friendly staff in a home town setting. What more could you ask for.“

“Would recommend this Pizza Hut to anyone! We had a huge last day of school party, where I had ordered 12 pizzas at Papa John’s. Three hours before the pizza is set to be delivered, Papa John’s calls saying their ovens were down. Called this Pizza Hut, and they were so helpful, said no problem, we will get your 12 pizzas done and we will give you a better price! I am so impressed, and y’all saved mine and the kiddos day! Pizzas tasted amazing, nothing went to waste!“

“Fun place and the pizza is really good👌🏻“

“Got the tenderloin and onion rings. Large portions and was fresh. Fast and friendly service. Would definitely come back“

“Absolutely love this place.The pizza is delicious.Perfectly baked crust, generous toppings, and just the right amount of cheese and sauce. You can tell they use fresh ingredients, and everything tastes homemade in the best way. The staff is friendly and quick. Definitely my go-to pizza spot — highly recommend“

“Stopped for lunch in town for a sports competition. Quick service. Delicious food.“

“Best pizza in Indiana!!!!“

“shout out to marco's pizza on Pendleton pike for awesome customer service an all I really appreciate you all Pierre Pearson“

“Excellent food, excellent value, nice delivery people, one of the few great places like this left these days. 10/10 recommend. The Fettuccine Alfredo w Mushrooms, Beef Nachos, even the pickle pizza is delicious! Tip your driver good, they don't charge like door dash!! 🫶“

“We ate at New Bethel Ordinary last Sunday after attending the IU/PU game. What a fabulous finish to a great day. The meat lovers pizza was over the top. Highly recommend....wish we could find a place like this in SWFL!!! Great place, TY!“

“We order here at least monthly! Always so good and exactly what we want!“

“Best pizza in Indy in my opinion. I live 25 miles away and it’s worth the drive“

“the pizza 🍕 is excellent and ALL Staff was very friendly and helpful“

“Last night I brought in a group of 35 at Hometown Classic Pizza, and everything was absolutely fantastic! (yes, I did make a reservation with staff about a week before)

The staff handled our large party with ease—friendly and organized from start to finish. The food was delicious, served hot, and everyone in our group was very happy.

Thank you to the entire team for making our experience so smooth and enjoyable. We’ll definitely be back!“

“Always clean, fresh, and friendly. Pizzas are great deals and taste amazing. I never get box or take out. 2 large thin crust for 5.00 or one XL my for 9.99 you can't beat it and can trust it's hygienic becuase you bake it yourself as well as watch them make it with gloves.“

“Got out of surgery yesterday and all I wanted was a piece of pizza. Got to try their pizza and breadsticks and it was amazing. The breadsticks are the best breadsticks I have tried in Indianapolis. Thank you for the great food.“

“First off they are now known as Willies Roadhouse. The restaurant was very clean, and our waitress couldn't have been nicer. We shared a peperoni pizza and a few beers. Everything was good, but the prices are a tad on the high side, would definitely return!“

“Consistently great pizza!“

“Best pizza in Indiana!!!!“

“Ordered delivery arrived in time given. Enjoyed the taste of our pepperoni,sausage, onion and mushroom pizza. Definitely a higher quality pizza“

“Excellent food and service“

“We got a deep dish supreme pizza. This pizza was very good. The crust was perfectly crispy. Totally worth the $12 spent.“

“Very nice place came down from Boston like what I saw people dancing and having fun. The food was good.“

“I love stopping at this particular godfathers pizza as well as this gas station. The employees are always so nice and I dare you to find a nicer and classier bunch of employees in the city as far as Shell stations go. And the pizza and chesters is fire. I even have Chinese food and it’s all clean the place is spotless.“

“Fast order and out the door hot and good will be back“

“This is by far one of the best Pizzas I’ve had in quite some time!!“

“My biscuits and gravy were served with spoiled gravy. It took me a couple minutes to realize the cheese aftertaste was spoiled milk. I've have had diarrhea all day....I will never come back. Clearly unsafe food handling and cooks who do not taste what they are serving.... in 45 years I have never had bad biscuits and gravy until today.“

“I just want to thank Jessie who helped me a few days back. I’m a Hoosier born and raised 35yrs, but I have moved to NC about 14 years ago. So there is a group of Hoosiers here in NC and when one of us visits Indiana, you have to bring back Pizza King!!!! Jessica was great and helping. I ordered an assortment of 12 pizzas, all 1/2 baked. Brought the pizzas back home distributed them and everyone said they were delicious and amazing. Jessie she was so sweet and kind. Thank you, Jessie. So Tuesday, everyone here in NC was eating Pizza King and we were all loving it and savor in it because we don’t know when we’ll get Pizza King again. Yes, I understand you can have them shipped, but not when the shipping and delivery is more than what you pay for the pizzas. I wish it was different because we’d order all the time.“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“Amazing Godfathers Pizza !! Perfect Classic Combo ! It reminded me of the old old Godfathers back in Sidney Ohio when I was about 10 years old !! AAA+ . Prince, is dreamy . He smells fantastic, he looks even better ,and he plays cool music!!“

“kori is the best server ever!!! please request her!!!! 💣. com“

“Wooden Bear not only has excellent craft beer, but it's a lively and welcoming bar. After 3 visits (over a week apart), the regulars and staff treated me like a regular! See for yourself!“

“I have been to this location a few times and LOVE the pizza here. I am originally from Nebraska where Godfather's originated. When I start to feel like I need a taste of home, I go here. Very comparable to the pizza from back home. We always call ahead to place our order and the pizza is always good and fresh. We always get a Taco Pizza and a pepperoni pizza.“

“Fun for the kids. Guy at the door was friendly. Several machines were down but still enough for kids to play. My main complaint is that games only paid out 1 or two tickets, and “jackpot” tickets were low counts. After 2 hours we walked out with a large candy and a book mark. . .“

“Honey I ordered the Papa John's Garden Veggie Bowl, 100% delicious, my delivery was perfect, I had to have chocolate cookie& diet pepsi, and I tried the jalapeños cream cheese rolls ?!! Appreciate your business, and thank you for perfect order!“

“My children love pizza so I tried to buy from places that I can get deals on Jack's is a little expensive when you have children who love to eat pizza on a regular basis but they are the best the jackpot is my favorite“

“My experience with Donatos was as expected. Ordered on app, was given time for pick up, arrived on time line at pickup window was long so I went in. I stood at the counter for a few minutes before anyone from the kitchen came out to help me. The food was good.“