14 Best Sandwich Shops near New Whiteland

1
Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
321 N U.S. 31, New Whiteland

Customers` Favorites

Coca-Cola Classic
Sweet Onion
Cookies
Oven

“This location is usually pretty good. They haven't ever gave me a bad sandwich or toasted it so much you can't eat it. Some subways I've questioned if the meat was even any good or not but never had problems here. They do cost a little more than the subway not too far from here on st Rd 135 but service is always fast.“

4.1 Good20 Reviews
The Knuckle Sandwich Sandwich Shop • $
5116 IN-135 suite a, Bargersville - 3.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Breaded Pork Tenderloin Hubcap
Grilled Cheese Add Pickles
57 Chevy Burger and Fries
The Knuckle Sandwich
Double Cheeseburger
Pepper Cheese Bites
Betty Boop Burger
Reuben Sandwich
Big Bopper blt
Sausage Gravy

“Decided to try their breakfast this morning. Hubby got the blueberry pancakes, and I got regular. His were loaded up with blueberries! I have to deduct half a point because they don't have peanut butter which I like to have on my pancakes, but they made up for it by the bacon portion. Most places you get just 2 slices of bacon. They give you 4! The waitress was friendly and efficient, the restaurant was very clean and the decor and music are very entertaining.“

4.1 Good92 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
1675 W Smith Valley Rd Suite A-3, Greenwood - 4.61 miles

Customers` Favorites

Roast Beef and Provolone
Chipotle Cheese Steak
Turkey and Provolone
The Original Italian
Steak and Cheese Sub

“The food was really good. I wish they would repeat back the order and give a little more direction to how the line worked. We had never been there before. After letting them know we still weren't told the process. We ordered and I tried asking questions and just got nods. We weren't sure if this was part of the service, to not communicate with the patrons, or just the people workings preference. The tables were really tight. The food was really good though and would definitely go again.Parking: This place is in a strip mall and was hard to find a spot.Wheelchair accessibility: Wasn't really accessible,“

4 Good64 Reviews
Capriotti's Sandwich Shop Sandwich Shop • $
1901 E Stop 13 Rd, Indianapolis - 5.78 miles

Customers` Favorites

American Wagyu Slaw Be Jo
Chicken Chipotle Crunch
Chicken Cheese Steak
Philly Cheesesteak
Wagyu Cheese Steak
Classic Italian
Grilled Italian
Meatball Hoagie
Tomato Bisque
Clam Chowder

“I used to go to this location a lot! The reason why I don't go anymore is because you only serve sugary soda or sugary lemonade. You took ice tea away (which is a cheap beverage to offer your guests who keep your doors open), and I do not want to be limited to water. I've asked several times to bring back ice tea but it doesn't seem to phase you or even speak volumes to how much business is being left on the table by being one of the only places to not offer the cheap and popular beverage of ice tea. Please bring it back or change out one of the sugar bombs in your fountain for Powerade or something not carbonated and full of sugar. Again, used to be a die hard loyal customer, but I don't want to pay to be limited to Indianapolis tap water. Once again, literally every other restaurant makes ice tea so they can maximize their business...but you don't?“

4 Good61 Reviews
The Tailgate Sandwich Shop • $
8028 S Emerson Ave Suite V, Indianapolis - 6.35 miles

Customers` Favorites

Stuffed Burger
Fries

“Best Stuffed burger in Indianapolis by FAR!!! Char-grilled EVERY TIME! All food made to order; and the meat is not dry, and it's great quality. You owe it to yourself to try the food here. I order mine to go all the time. Id show you pictures but I eat it way too fast! lol“

4.3 Superb32 Reviews
McAlister's Deli Sandwich Shop • $
7711 Shelby St Suite C, Greenwood - 7.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Tortilla Soup
The McAlister's Club
Roast Beef Supreme
Broccoli Cheddar
Grilled Chicken
Chicken Salad
The McAlister
Baked Potato
Potato Salad
Cup of Soup

“In and out for carry out. When we ate about 10 minutes later I wasn't really happy with our order. Sandwiches just wasn't good at all. Service was good and the atmosphere was good, but food not so much. Ordered a Reuben and a club with soup and potato salad.“

4.1 Good42 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
6815 S Emerson Ave Suite F, Indianapolis - 7.64 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Philly Cheese Steak
Jersey Mike's Famous Philly
Number 56 the Big Kahuna
Roast Beef and Provolone
Chipotle Cheese Steak
Italian Mike
Cheesesteak

“Subs done, right.Tried Jersey Mike's for the first time today. I was told to get the big Kahana, and I wasn't disappointed. It was full full of meat and veg. It also had American cheddar. It was delicious and very filling. I got it on rosemary parmesan bread, which was also great. The service was personable and very friendly. We will definitely be back to try the many other subs“

3.9 Good51 Reviews
Penn Station East Coast Subs Sandwich Shop • $
6810 S Emerson Ave, Indianapolis - 7.65 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Classic Italian
Snack Size Cheesesteak
Chicken Teriyaki
Chicken Parmesan
Fresh-Cut Fries
Steak & Cheese

“Average to better sandwich shop. Portions aren't like they used to be, but shrinkflation is real. Almost always enjoy my food here, but there is a bad miss on rare occasion. Favorites are the grilled Italian and cheesesteak with onions and mushrooms. Recently had the chicken parm and it was good as well. Parking is average and finding a spot isn't an issue.“

4 Good39 Reviews
McAlister's Deli Sandwich Shop • $
8860 S Emerson Ave, Indianapolis - 5.54 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Tortilla Soup
Country Potato Soup
Club Sandwich
McAlister
Choose
Chips
Mac

“Had our sandwich messed up twice, as well watched my to go order get finished and sit for about 3-5 min before it was brought to me by a second employee rather than the one that received it through the kitchen window. Not bad employees at all more or less just a silly process. Even though the experience wasn’t perfect Rob the GM handled it well and the exact way I would’ve in his position. People aren’t perfect mistakes happen and they fixed it good job McAllister ??“

3.7 Good53 Reviews
Penn Station East Coast Subs Sandwich Shop • $
1143 N Morton St, Franklin - 4.81 miles

Customers` Favorites

The Philly Cheesesteak
Steak and Cheese
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Teriyaki
Chunk Cookies
Fries
Fresh
Sub

“Penn Station has my favorite fries, bar none. I used to go to one by an old job so often, they put my picture on the wall. My girl laughs at the sign every time we pass one, because she says it look like it says, "Peast Coast Subs" I also like the chicken parm“

3.8 Good35 Reviews
McAlister's Deli Sandwich Shop • $
1011 N State Rd 135, Greenwood - 6.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Chicken Tortilla Soup
The McAlister's Club
Country Potato Soup
Soup and Sandwich
Grilled Chicken
Club Sandwich
French Dip
Reuben
Chili

“It is Ok.Kind of overpriced.I had a sandwich and lasagna soup and lemonade. The lemonade tastes like those powder juice, so bad. The sandwich was simple and the soup was so canned tomaty.Service was ok, they were courteous. The place is nice.“

3.5 Good63 Reviews
McAlister's Deli Sandwich Shop • $
2378 N Morton St, Franklin - 3.81 miles

Customers` Favorites

Jalapeno Turkey Crunch
The Italian Sandwich
Country Potato Soup
McAlister's Club
Caesar Salad
Baked Potato
The Italian
Potato Salad
Chef Salad
French Dip

“The standard typical McA's, fairly new building (2019, I believe) with the usual dining room that may seat a tad fewer folks than their other locations. Service was their usual fast counter ordering and food delivery to your table. The only exception was order accuracy.I ordered the Classic Grilled Chicken on the croissant with Potato Salad. I received the Grilled Chicken Club with the potato salad. No big deal except I don't believe there are enough ingredients to justify three slices of bread. Otherwise the sandwich was good. The potato salad was even better and not a huge portion either because it's supposed to be a side and that reduces the calories the way I like it.The restroom was very clean but the automatic paper towel dispenser was inoperative. However a roll of towels were available.“

3.5 Good53 Reviews
Penn Station East Coast Subs Sandwich Shop • $
S State Rd 135, Greenwood - 4.98 miles

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheesesteak and Fries
The Philly Cheesesteak
Chicken Cordon Bleu
Chicken Teriyaki
Turkey Avocado
Pizza
Fresh
Sub

“Penn Station has been a long time classic for me. While I don't often waiver in my order, on the days I do, I know there will always be a good option coming to me. The fries are generally light, in not a bit oily, and quite nice. The seating has multiple varieties that comfort exists in all. The shop is relatively small, but certainly doesn't feel cramped. You can see all food being made feet from the counter so that you can trust the food.“

3.5 Good44 Reviews

14
Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
6025 Madison Ave Suite A, Indianapolis - 8.58 miles

“I ordered my sandwiches online before I came but when I got here the store was really busy and there were probably 6 to 8 people in front of me. The people working we're working very quickly and they worked well together they got through the line pretty fast. When I was my turn they told me that they didn't have my sandwiches ready which was completely understandable because it was just the two of them and it was so busy. I didn't wait long at all and when it was my turn, he made my sandwiches. The sandwiches tasted great, they worked well as a team, and I will definitely come here again.“

4 Good9 Reviews
Loading...
map Map