15 Best Pizza Restaurants in Plainfield

“I have always like Amici's and feel it is among the best pizza's in Plainfield but the sauce tasted different this time. Much too bold and overpowering for my taste. I will try again soon but I hope this is a one off because, if not, I don't think I will go there again.“

“One of the best place for pizzas traditional pizza or twisted pizza. Best taste“

“Our first time trying Greeks pizzeria was the beginning of this month. We loved it so much that my family ordered some yesterday. Unfortunately, we never received our order it was delivered to the wrong address. When I called, the restaurant it was closed. I called back this afternoon, and they delivered my money to my home. Plus, we received a free extra large pizza. We were pleased“

“This was the best pizza we’ve ever had. Thanks so much! We will be back next year!“

“Had a blast eating here. The food was not only some of the best pizza I've ever had, but the staff and service were out of this world. We ordered two of their specialty pizzas which were the ballsagna and the party fowl. Both were incredibly good pizzas. We came in to pick up our order and decided to get their special edition cups and the employee only charged us for 1 of the 2 of them. When we got back to the hotel, we noticed they also threw in an entire extra order of bread sticks on the house. The restaurant itself was cozy and felt like a small hometown pizza joint, not some large pizza chain. It's such a great place and I couldn't recommend them enough.“

“Whoever was working on NYE’s eve the night before January 1st, 2026. It was a young man and a woman. Give them everything, they deserve it all. My tongue has never been graced by quite a delicacy. And that is just for the pizza, don’t get me started on the mozz slices. The flavor packed in each slice, for both items. The soft yet firm doughey texture of the pizza. When you think of pizza, you think of yummy stretchy cheese - this was just that. Not only will I be back, and I’ll be back often, but I’m telling everyone I know.“

“HANDS DOWNTHE BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD ON THE WEST SIDE & I AM A CONNOISSEUR OF PIZZA!!!¡!!!!!IT'S LIKE OLD JACK'S PIZZA, BUT BETTER,! THERE USED TO BE A JACKS OFF PENDLETON PIKE, IN INDY ! HARD TO DUPLICATE EVEN HARDER TO MASTER AND DO BETTER THEN.“

“Tonight, I had one of the best experiences possible with this Domino’s location. It was a thin crust, pepperoni and mushroom pizza and was absolutely perfect. The crust was flaky and crispy and toppings were edge to edge. Thanks Dani for a great pizza.“

“Food and staff are excellent!!!“

“Absolutely amazing restaurant! The food was perfect and the waiter we had was just such a great person. We truly felt we were in a 5 star high end restaurant in NYC but with good portions and very reasonable prices. We plan on going back many times to this restaurant and also getting the word out about how great this place is.“

“Papa Murphys is our go-to place for pizza . There is nothing better than getting a good pizza hot from your own oven. My favorite pizza was the chicken bacon artichoke, but it hasn't been right for a long time. The bottom of the crust always looks like it's been boiled in oil. But there other pizzas are still very“

“This Little Ceasars location has always been pretty good to us, so I feel I should express that here. I saw all of the negative reviews were like 2018-2020, so I suppose could have been some mismanagement going on at that time. But having been to Little Cesar's dozens of times between ~ 2021-2024 they have always been very friendly and have almost never messed up our order. They also always give my little girl a free bag of cookies when we come through, so she is always excited when we go to eat here.“

“When we come into Indy for the Indy mini half marathon, we always stay at the same hotel over by Nonna‘s so Italian so we could get our carbs in the night before. Well, this last weekend we were there for a family wedding and we ordered a pizza ahead so we could have it when we got to the hotel. It was all perfect till I got to the hotel and they called me to tell me we received the wrong pizza two people with the same last name ordered at the same time. They were so gracious and let us keep the pizza we had even though it was probably more expensive than what we had ordered, but we didn’t have much time to wait or return it. So gracious of them to make it so easy on us and let me tell you that pizza was delicious.“

“I went for the pizza that had BBQ sauce, bacon , onion and onion strings. They don't have it anymore. Got a pizza with half pepperoni/ half bacon, onion. It was okay. Ordered cheesey bread sticks and got plain ones.
Service was all that great.“

“Very casual atmosphere and the food was awesome! Sals pizza was our choice today. Will definitely be going back.“