9 Best Pizza Restaurants in Portage

“The new location behind the old location is awesome
The staff is awesome and that jalapeno popper pizza is like nothing else we have ever found
We drive an hour just to get it
The kids also love to come in and sit down to eat
Crazy how we can feed a family of 5 for less then $50 here and have so much food left over we really need you guys to open up a location around the crown point area“

“This was our first time ordering Take and Bake and the pizza was just as delicious as when we visited last month for our first time. our new family favorite pizza 😍“

“Perfect pizza as usual. Thank you. Drove 140 miles home and it was still perfect. Just warmed it back up in my air fryer. Thank you Jill“

“My family and I love JJ's! And if you haven't tried their version of stuffed crust pizza...it.is.a.MUST! We usually get a sausage and pepperoni stuffed crust and the whole pizza comes with a layer of crust on top! Not a thick layer, just enough to 'stuff' the pizza with delicious ingredients. They have pretty good mild/hot wings and they staff is always courteous. They messed up our order one time and we had driven to pick it up and didn't notice the mistake until we got home. We called them and they offered to deliver our order to us, no charge!“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“What a perfect delicious pizza [Original] What a perfect delicious pizza“

“I come here often enough. The gentleman that I think is the manager goes above and beyond. He is the hardest working man. He is always kind, and professional. He has excellent customer service. I tried dominoes in Chesterton and it could not compare. The pizza and bread stick bites are delicious. Portage dominoes is in a class by itself. I appreciate the hard work the staff here do. Dan is his name.
The young man working with him was a sweet heart.“

“This store went above and beyond to correct a stores issue that wasnt their problem to correct! They have a solid crew there at 9 pm on 12/19/25 I didn't catch the managers name but they will have all my future business I will no longer spend time or money at the Hobart crossing store they are incredibly unprofessional and unorganized I sat n watched workers go out for numerous cigarettes breaks (4) to be exact that was the bald man with tattoos while who I assumed was the manager touch his uniform pants multiple times pulling up his pants and continues to make pizza with out practicing good hand hygiene it was so unorganized people we stealing drinks .they had at least 30 pizza stacked up and was passing out cold food I asked them to cancel my order I placed my order at 7pm I then choose a different restaurant to get dinner from after 2 hour wait ! Again thank you Portage !“