15 Best Italian Restaurants near Sellersburg

“Went to Mazerella's Pizza for 1st time less than one year ago, and their pizza is absolutely phenomenal! Their lunch buffet is certainly the best in town and food is fresh with a variety of pizza's everyday. Excellent food, and prompt service every time!“

“First time trying Lupo and would definitely go back! Pepperoni pizza, pasta with pork, and cabbage were all very tasty options. The pizza crust was perfect and pizza itself had the right amount of toppings. Ranch was great. Overall the flavors were spot on and it looks like they have a great variety of unique flavor combinations. Nice patio seating and decently quick service. The restaurant itself was clean and has a welcoming atmosphere. They have a parking lot right next to the building, but it was full so we parked in the overfill lot across the street (not far at all) Would recommend!“

“Let's start at the beginning. Gorgeous restaurant. Tables aren't set up with intimacy in mind though. My husband's drink was perfect. My maple bourbon drink tasted like bourbon only. No other flavors noted. We were offered free champagne for our celebration which was a nice touch. Calamari was pretty standard though I loved the lemon aoli with it. My special of the day Sea Bass was incredible. My husband's salmon was good, perfectly cooked. This will be unpopular opinion but I thought the lobster bisque was gross. It tasted like melted cheese with a few lobster pieces thrown in. Not bisque at all. I do tend to be a bit critical since I lived in Boston once. But I couldn't eat it. Overall though fantastic restaurant. Especially seafood in a location far from any sea. Well done.“

“The decor inside is amazing! You can look around all night and find something new to see! We went for a friend’s graduation party and the service was still great! The food was delicious as we’ve never ate here before. It would be great for a date night or anniversary!“

“The food overall is good. I had the Filetto Con Gnocchi. It was cooked beyond my preference. The Tortelloni Alla Matriciana was really good. For dessert, I had the bourbon bread pudding it was interestingly good.The Raspberry Lemonade cocktail was awesome. My favorite drink!*I am not a fan of the Fondi Di Carciofi Fritti appetizer.“

“We went on a slow day (things were in high gear for the derby). We kind of got there after lunch but before dinner. Our server Amanda was great. She was patient and described menu items for us. Chatted and made sure we had everything we needed and also kept drinks filled. The pork tenderloins while not huge were still good sized and not tasteless or dry. They had really good flavor and texture with a crunchy panko breading. The pasta nachos were AMAZING. First time we've ever had them and they did not disappoint. I'd have any of these dishes again.“

“What could anyone add that isn't already known about this fabulous staple in American cuisine culture we call The Olive Garden? Whts not to love... endless bread sticks, soup and salad coupled with your favorite Italian dish (mine is baked ziti.) And don't we love leaving feeling like a satisfied, stuffed piñata?…I felt compelled to write a review for this specific Olive Garden because my experience there was extraordinary! Sometimes it is service that makes the difference and this was no exception!After having a delicious meal I felt compelled to white because I couldn't have been more satisfied by the welcoming and congenial overtures paid by the entire staff. In particular Lizzy and Lauren. I can't wait to go again and visit Lizzie in the bar or maybe be lucky enough to have Lauren as my server!Thanks for being so positive and kind, i have not laughed so much in a long time! Even my uptight date had fun! Talk about mission impossible! Also great food and drink recommendations from Lizzie and very tempting dessert recommendations from Lauren!“

“The owner is awesome he will personally come out and see his customers and joke with them or wait on them if staff is running short , the food is amazing and not overpriced, memo cam out and even got a selfie with me and my wifeThis is my 3rd time there and it's been awesome each time! 5 stars all the “

“Steve was our server for a phenomenal dining experience. He was attentive, friendly, knowledgeable, and professional. The pasta and meatball dish had the most flavorful marinara I have ever eaten. The well crafted Italian margarita went perfectly with it. My boyfriend had the linguine dish with a glass of Merlot and loved it. For dessert we had the cheesecake and almond joy. Absolutely exquisite.“

“Really a great spot. We were there in between lunch and 5pm so it wasn't busy. The beer was cold and the appetizers were hot. Really good toasted ravioli. And the service was perfect. Worth going out of your way to eat and kick back for.“

“Place was empty, except one table who already had their food, I walked in on my lunch break, and was wondering if they were closed. For about 5 minutes. Pizza was good. But 30 minutes for 1 pizza is a long wait, could only imagine what it's like when it's full of people.“

“Alright, it's been a minute but it's pi day and wanted to see what deals were out there. BoomBozz offered order a large pizza or famous pizza to get a cookie for $3.14.Our server Maggie was absolutely amazing! It was our first time here and she suggested the Bavarian pretzels with house-made beer cheese. Get it. Order it. Order it immediately. It was delicious. That was a great suggestion. We tried the award-winning Fire Roasted Chicken pizza substituted with Brisket with the Garlic cream sauce. Just go ahead and put the cream sauce on the pizza. It's fantastic. Then our pi day cookie came out. We smashed it. So good. It wasn't hard, it wasn't thick, it wasn't too much.Between Maggie's outstanding service, her keeping our drinks full, and this delicious 3-course meal. We'll definitely be back.“

“A pretty good experience, both me and my mother got the Choose two deal, which is smaller portions, however it was fairly priced and tasted great. The staff was friendly and the restaurant was clean, I have always had good experiences with this location.My only gripe was that we had to find a table that wasn't wobbly but seating was plentiful so it wasn't an issue.Vegetarian options: It's pasta with your choice of sauce.Parking: Parking lot is smaller than most but has never been an issue finding a spot.Kid-friendliness: Fazoli's is a family friendly restaurant.Wheelchair accessibility: Ramp at front door“

“I Had the Carbonara, it was good and I would recommend it to anyone that likes pasta and Italian food. I Cleaned my plate. Service was great. If you don’t appreciate more authentic Italian food, don’t eat here. All the bad reviews are just people that would rather eat fake Italian Olive Garden with oversized meatballs and gargantuan piles of Parmesan cheese.“

“You kind of know what you’re getting into when you go to the Old Spaghetti Factory. Service and food is nothing special, but the prices are reasonable and I love how tacky it is inside! The ambiance is definitely interesting but charming at the same time. Besides, where else can you get fettucine alfredo with a SIDE of chicken parm?!“