3.8
Good
191 Reviews
535 Boylston Street, Boston · 6.06 miles
Customers’ favorites
- Classic Smoked Salmon & Capers
- Finagle's Famous Egg Sandwich
- Bagel with Cream Cheese Combo
- Bagel with Egg and Ham
“Finagle A Bagel is a Boston breakfast institution that has been doing its thing for decades, and for a quick, no-fuss morning stop in Back Bay it fills that role reliably. The two-story space with outdoor seating gives it more breathing room than most spots in the area, and the upstairs seating is a good option when the weather is not cooperating and you want somewhere to sit and eat without rushing. The bagels are the foundation and they hold up well as a vehicle for everything built on top of them, with the everything bagel being the standout in the lineup. The egg and cheese sandwiches are the move for a proper breakfast, with a generous amount of meat and a combination that comes together cleanly on a toasted bagel. The bacon, egg, and cheddar on a plain toasted bagel is a reliable build that covers all the bases without overcomplicating things. Where expectations need calibrating is on the bagel itself. The texture leans softer than a specialty bagel shop, even when toasted, and the chew and crust that define a great bagel are not quite there. For a quick and affordable breakfast near Back Bay it works well, but it is a different experience than a dedicated bagel spot with freshly made dough. Service is fast and efficient and the value is strong for the neighborhood. As a convenient morning stop before heading into the day, Finagle A Bagel delivers exactly what it promises.”