15 Best Ice Cream Shops near Centerville

“Great new owners!!! Thank you for the wonderful ice cream 🍦 & the Four Seas freezer bag!!! Without doubt, the best ice cream on Cape Cod! See you again this summer ☀️“

“The other night, we went on a peak time 8:30pm ice cream run and every single ice cream spot had huge lines! We just kept driving… LOL. Eventually, we found ourselves all the way in Mashpee at Polar Cave Ice Cream Parlour. They had a long line too, but at that point, if I kept driving, we would’ve run out of gas So we waited in line and let me tell you, it was SO worth it. They make the waffle cones to order, and the smell alone was enough to pull you in. Not only were the prices surprisingly reasonable, but what really stood out was the service. The gentleman taking our order had the kind of smile you don’t see often anymore—genuine, warm, and welcoming. The whole place had these nostalgic Coca-Cola throwback vibes, and it just felt like a full-on experience, not just a quick dessert stop. My daughter said, “I hope customers feel this way when I serve them.” 🩷 And my husband got a banana split that was absolutely to die for and only $11! 🐻‍❄️“

“Best choice out of the ice cream shops closely located here. 5 most pertinent items 1- Vegan / non- dairy options! (the competition close by does not have any of these options) ... 2- Ice cream and waffle cones all made in-house. 3- open year round EXCEPT February. 4- they have ready to go ice cream pies and cookie sandwiches. 5- REAL premium hot fudge. They put the nuts and fudge under the whipped cream on top of the ice cream - much better in this format.Charlotte, our server, was superb and quite knowledgeable about the ice creams, the process, and the vision of the store. It is more of a "kid friendly" atmosphere. train track on the ceiling. Decor geared toward children. A bit noisy, but they do have a couple of tables outside.I HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS PLACE if the quality of ice cream and non dairy options are important.“

“The service at Seaside Scoops is great!! Justine does a wonderful job making everyone feel welcome. Main street has been missing the fresh beef burgers and hand breaded chicken tenders for many years. It was a flashback to my childhood getting a great burger and milkshake on Main Street.“

“The best!!!! Friendly, fun and delicious!“

“Friendly service fresh delicious ice cream. I love the outdoor decor seating areas.“

“Nice refreshing stop from a day of shopping - build your own ice cream cup with flavor and toppings“

“Penguins is awesome! The ice cream is super yummy, with tons of fun flavors to choose from. The waffle cones are super crunchy and fresh, which makes everything even better. The new owner is doing a great job, the place has a fun vibe and feels very welcoming. The staff are all friendly and efficient, even when it’s busy! Definitely one of our favorite spots in the area. Can’t wait to come back!“

“The girls that served us were both very friendly and helpful. The ice cream with all the trimmings was excellent! Plus it's a nice place to just sit and enjoy your ice cream or chocolate! It's a must place to just stop and endulge yourself!!!!“

“Went for Blizzards with my son. The value and taste of them was great. They were filled with all the wonderful tastes we expected. We did take out and ate them on the spot because we know they melt quickly. My tip would be if you are going to travel with them ask your server to not fill them up so much so they won’t overflow.

Parking: Great lot right next to restaurant.

Wheelchair accessibility: Very accessible with a walker.“

“Amazing cupcakes! Moist, delicious, and great flavor choices!!“

“I bought a handful of sodas last week. Best sodas I’ve ever had in my life. Highly recommend visiting if you’re in Cape Cod. Please make these available in Chicago!“

“The best candy shop on the Cape!! Great people. Love it!“

“It has incredibly creamy and delicious ice cream. They offer tasty sundaes with a good variety of flavors. Refreshing drinks and shakes are available. Additionally, they offer an excellent option for ordering an acai bow. Very polite and amiable is the woman working the window. A place for breakfast, lunch, and dinner was also suggested by her. It's a big assistance! This location is without a doubt recommended.“

“Shake Shack never disappoints! The food is consistently fresh, flavorful, and made with care. The service is friendly and fast, and the atmosphere has that perfect casual-yet-modern vibe. I got the chance to meet Kendall one of the employees and he was so sweet and kind.“