5 Best Ice Cream Shops near Chatham

Buffy's Ice Cream Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $$$
456 Main Street, Chatham

“Amazing staff, amazing ice cream, amazing atmosphere. This place as the only homemade ice cream in Chatham, the ice cream bars are out of this world. And they are very accommodating with allergens, (I have celiac and eat here without a problem)“

4.7 Superb45 Reviews
Brick Block Ice Cream and Crepe shop Ice Cream Shop • $$
10 Chatham Bars Ave, Chatham

“Awesome & CLEAN place with a great selection. Very nice countertops with barstools attached to the floor at counters, plenty of tables too. I ordered a Crepe with Vanilla Ice Cream and whipped cream, WOWZAPALOOZIA, the crepe was stuffed with 2huge scoops, luckily I had help eating it, Yummylicious“

4.5 Superb30 Reviews
Sweet Izzy Ice Cream Shop • $$
296 MA-28, Harwich Port - 7.07 miles

“We stopped here one night during our Cape Cod trip because they had vegan options. We had really yummy sundaes and were super happy with the amount of vegan options. There's a few picnic tables to eat at and I found a portapotty by the edge of the parking lot (unsure if it was for this business or the one next door). It's also right next to an overpriced trampoline park that my daughter was really excited about.“

4.8 Superb106 Reviews
Pleasant Lake Pizza Shark Pizza • $
403 Pleasant Lake Ave, Harwich - 6.66 miles

Customers` Favorites

Gluten Free Pizza with Shark Sauce
Deep Blue Shark
Buffalo Chicken
Extra Cheese
Pulled Pork
Sandwiches

“I have ordered countless pizzas and now sandwiches from pizza shark. The pizza is always great and topping very fresh and above average quality.Tonight was again a pleasant experience, so pleasant I thought I’d leave a 5 star review. I ordered three sandwiches. When I arrived I had to wait make 5 minutes as they were busy with the dinner rush. Both the chef and counter person apologized profusely. It was not an issue at all. I just perused the store while I waited. When my order was ready the chef again politely thanked me for being patient and the counter person gave me a gift card for the inconvenience. I did not get either of these young mens names but please commend them. This is great customer service. The gift card was completely unnecessary but such a thoughtful touch. My takeout order was at 7:00pm on 2/27/24.The sandwiches were delicious as usual. Great customer service is a becoming more and more rare. Everyone at your location is always super friendly and helpful which must reflect the way ownership is treating them. Please keep up the great work from top to bottom. Thank you again.“

4.7 Superb74 Reviews
Scribano's Italian Market & Deli Italian • $
302 MA-28, Harwich Port - 7.05 miles

“Ordered a sandwich today December 2, 2023.I was actually probably somewhat of an annoying customer ordering a custom sandwich wanted it with extra mayonnaise then halfway through the guy making it. I asked him to take some of the mayonnaise off I was a real annoying customer I’m sure,Anyways, the guy who made my sandwich absolutely knocked it out of the park might be the best sandwich I’ve ever had on Cape Cod and the whole time. They were polite and accommodating to all my weird request. Probably won’t go anywhere else on Cape Cod for a sandwich after my experience today , wish I knew the guys name who made my sandwich“

4.7 Superb48 Reviews
Loading...
map Map