21 Best American Restaurants in Edgartown

Behind the Bookstore Coffee & Tea • $$
46 Main St, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Don't Let the Old Ladies Cut in Line
Mushroom Toast
Avocado Toast
Banana Bread
Egg Sandwich
Coffee Cake
Scotch Egg
Croissant
Burger
Salad

“Wonderful people in a beautiful place!“

3.8 Good115 Reviews
The Covington Restaurant American • $$$
52 Main St, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Potato Rolls with Herb Butter
Walnut Pesto Ricotta Gnocchi
Island Farmstand Salad
Cannellini Bean Hummus
Three Sisters Salad
Pickled Cucumbers
Halibut Aguachile
Spicy Cucumbers
Mushroom Ragu
Smoked Beets

“Beautiful restaurant with amazing food and great staff. The vegan options are superb and absolutely delicious. Everything is presented beautifully and is super tasty. Special shout out to the sweet & spicy cucumbers which were incredible, and the home made bread is divine! This was a great choice for dining whilst in Marthas Vineyard!“

4.5 Superb66 Reviews
Detente American • $$$
15 Winter St, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Blueberry Buttermilk Bread Pudding
Fried Cornbread Panzanella
Bread Pudding Dessert
Scallop Appetizer
Lobster Risotto
Halibut Main
Bay Scallops

“Amazing! If you are a foodie this is a must. From start to finish it is a great meal. I had the Panzanella salad, Rack of Lamb and the Blueberry Bread Pudding. It was all memorable. I am definitely telling anyone who visits to try this place“

4.4 Superb46 Reviews
Alchemy Bistro & Bar American • $$$
71 Main St, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Roasted Garlic Smashed Potatoes
Hand-Cut Yellowfin Tuna Tartare
Filet Mignon and Lobster Tail
Alchemy’S Wagyu Burger
Grilled Asparagus Salad
Mushroom Toast
Crispy Oysters
Peach Cobbler
Pistachio Cke
Roast Chicken

“We had a wonderful evening! Excellent food, great service (our waiter & Megan the sommelier we’re excellent) in MV!!!“

4.2 Good84 Reviews
Chesca's Restaurant American • $$$
38 N Water St, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Black Angus New York Sirloin
Stuffed Bacon Wrapped Dates
Beef Short Rib Dinner
House Made Gnocchi
Grilled Salmon
Chicken Marsala
Clam Chowder
Key Lime Pie

“We did a walk in and we were able to be accommodated for a family of 7 the food was excellent and the service was very accommodating both with my wife's allergies and the dietary needs for the two young kids we had as well. The Cod was cooked perfectly and the clam chowder highly recommend it“

3.8 Good39 Reviews
6

Atria

Atria New American
137 Main St, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Heirloom Tomato Carpaccio with Burrata Pesto
That Big 3lb Stuffed Lobster
mc-Ripoff Burger and Fries
The Atria Classic Burger
Strawberry Shortcake
Truffle Fries Extra
Braised Short Ribs
Tuna Steak Special
Duck a L’Orange
Lobster Salad

“Good!Food. Great service and atmosphere!“

4.2 Good73 Reviews
Brick Cellar Bar Bar • $$
137 Main St, Edgartown

“Good!Food. Great service and atmosphere!“

4.1 Good20 Reviews
The Newes From America Pubs • $$
Faraway Marth'a Vineyard, 23 Kelly Street, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Caesar Salad with Chicken
Lobster Mac and Cheese
French Onion Soup
Fried Chicken
Clam Chowder
Fish & Chips
Burger
Fries

“Love the Newes Great atmosphere great food but what’s up with the new menu? Everyone wants the old favorites back! Fish and Chips, calamari Even the burritos from way back when Please, please bring them back! You’ll be glad you did!“

3.8 Good56 Reviews
Rockfish American • $$
11 N Water St, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Guinness Stout Braised Short Rib
Pan Roasted Atlantic Salmon
Hand Cut French Fries
Short Rib gr Cheese
Fried Cauliflower
Scallop Risotto
Risotto Balls
Arugula Salad
Lobster Roll
Lobster Taco

“Beautiful spot, amazing food, and super-friendly service!“

4.7 Superb109 Reviews
Lucky Hank's American • $$
218 Upper Main St, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

LH Famous Crunchy French Toast
Chocolate Chip Pancakes
Classic Eggs Benedict
Buttermilk Pancakes
Vineyard Benedict
Steak Benedict
Cod Cakes
Sandwich

“wonderful meal! great service“

4.4 Superb59 Reviews
The Terrace | Charlotte Inn American
27 S Summer St, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Potato Gnocchi

“We were entertaining visitors from NYC and they were intrigued by the charm, the exceptional service, the quiet atmosphere and the fine dining. It is hard to impress our guests but impressed they were. My husband and I also made a decision that The Terrance is the only place we will dine from now on. Please note the word "dine" as opposed to "eat" because it is truly a dining experience.“

4.3 Superb71 Reviews
Square Rigger Restaurant Seafood • $$
225 Edgartown-Vineyard Haven Rd, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

New England Clam Chowder
Grilled Stuffed Lobster
Pan Seared Scallops
Baked Clam Casino
Grilled Swordfish
Hot Lobster Roll
Grilled Lobster
Lobster Bisque
Seafood Paella
Grilled Salmon

“Just had a delicious dinner, if you have never been or haven't visited in a while, you should definitely stop in!!!“

4.4 Superb129 Reviews
Edgartown Diner Diner • $
65 Main St, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Croissant Breakfast Sandwich with Sweet Potato Fries
Banana Bread French Toast
Croissant French Toast
Corned Beef Melt
Home Fries
Cornbread
Burger

“Excellent food, great choices super friendly service. Reasonably priced.The retro atmosphere and music was fantastic!“

4.4 Superb76 Reviews
Bettini Restaurant Seafood
Harbor View Hotel, 131 N Water St, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Pan Roasted Organic Half Chicken
Prime Beef Ribeye Carpaccio
Pan Roasted Vineyard Fluke
Whipped Mashed Potatoes
Yellowfin Tuna Tartare
Porterhouse Pork Chop
Mushroom Pappardelle
Belgian Endive Salad
Prime NY Strip 16oz
Casarecce Bolognese

“We had an elegant evening that started with a cocktail reception, next we went to dinner in a grand set to celebrate the pairing of fine wine with a (4)course one of kind chef creations. This was an amazing evening and we enjoyed the people we met, beautiful atmosphere, excellent service, delicious food, and fine wine.“

4.2 Good460 Reviews
Katama Kitchen American • $
12 Mattakesett Way, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Scallops with Sweet Potato
Bolognese with Pappardelle
Blueberry Chocolate Chip
Breakfast Sandwich
Eggs Benedict
Clam Chowder
Croissants

“We absolutely love Katama Kitchen! We are home now and my husband just said, “Katama Kitchen has the best restaurant pancakes I’ve ever tasted!” The staff is so accommodating and it is so relaxing at the airfield. It’s the first place we’ll hit next year! Thank you so much!“

3.3 Good60 Reviews
16

Trio

Trio Wine Bar • $$
18 N Summer St, Edgartown

“After a long day of sightseeing I just wanted to sit on the beach and have dinnner with my toes in the sand and my eyes on the sunset. Picked up some tuna salad, noodles, and a gigantic cookie - and the cutest dish towel souvenir - and had the perfect ending to a fabulous day. Thank you, Black Sheep Mercantile!!“

5 Superb1 Reviews
The Seafood Shanty Seafood • $$
31 Dock St, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Hot Buttered Lobster Roll with French Fries
Fish Tacos with Pineapple Mango Salsa
Island's Best & Biggest Lobster Roll
New England Clam Chowder
Mussels Shanty Style
Lobster Quesadilla
California Roll
Served w Fries
Fried Calamari
Fish Sandwich

“Great views and staff! This is a place you want to drink a beer with friends on the weekend!“

4.1 Good198 Reviews
Town Bar and Grill MV Bar & Grill • $$
227 Upper Main St, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Tuna Avocado Roll
Braised Short Rib
Chicken Sandwich
Fish & Chips
Steak Tips
Burger
Sushi
Salad

“It was great very clean and friendly“

3.9 Good61 Reviews
The Dunes New American • $$$
31 Dunes Rd, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Croissant

“My Empress Gin martini (Aka: The Dunes) was delightful. Thank you Billy & Shane for all the attention.“

3.8 Good123 Reviews
The Wharf Seafood • $$
3 Main St, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Friday Special Prime Rib and a Burger
New England Clam Chowder
Fried Shrimp & Chips
Fishermans Platter
Fried Shrimp
Chowder Fries
Fish & Chips
Lobster Roll
Salad
Steak

“Great bar staff, food and service! More of a year-round Vineyarder’s destination.“

3.6 Good93 Reviews
Edgartown Pizza Pizza • $
224 Edgartown Rd, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Gluten Free Cheese Pizza
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Brazilian Burger
Brazilian Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
French Fries
Meat Lovers
Veggie Pizza
Sandwich

“Great specials. Good food.“

3.5 Good74 Reviews

You May Also Like