16 Best Pizza Restaurants in Natick

“I grew up in Detroit off of Buddy’s Pizza. This pizza IS BUDDYs pizza. Legit! Well done!“

“Even though we no longer live in Natick, we still get our pizza, subs, chicken tenders and fries from here every time we are in the area. We love it and so do our kids. Highly recommend!!!“

“The staff and service are always exceptional when I stop here. It is easy to see that the service plaza is falling apart and filthy but Papa Gino’s is always very clean and ready to help the very few people who come through that plaza. I commend the staff on their attention to detail and their efforts to help guests like myself“

“We had an issue with Grub Hub, and ended up having the restaurant cancel the order (ordered large but they only had the small dough at the time, which I didn’t think would feed the family, they were very obliging in canceling) we ordered from Papa Gino’s which was more money, and honestly not great, my son (ASD and ARFID) didn’t like it and refused to eat because it was cold. Rocco’s then delivered a large caramelized onion, and gave it to us for free (we owe you a double tip next time, my husband forgot in the confusion). My son immediately dove in eating the onions off the piece and the rest of the piece of pizza. You have made a customer out of us. Not only because of the excellent customer service but the food was very good and reasonably priced. Can’t wait to try some of the other dishes as well, due to the reviews.“

“they have been a staple in my family for over 40 years ...“

“they have been a staple in my family for over 40 years ...“

“I’ve never been disappointed ..“

“I ordered a large pizza for my son and his 2 friends who were having a sleepover, the pizza arrived at our house but when we opened the pizza box there was a questionable white all over the top layer, upon further inspection the white liquid appeared to be bodily liquids. We still ate the pizza, 10/10.“

“Theo's has been a Natick staple for many years. The food is fabulous, and the prices are fair. The new owners are working really hard to learn regular's orders and are doing a great job. They have my business and awesome broccoli and spinach pizza.“

“Freshest foods-friendly staff members. Be sure to try amazing italian sandwiches, delicious buffalo chicken pizza, scruptious mozzarella sticks and toasted ravioli, in addition to their veggie wraps and chicken salad......and don’t forget the GELATO for dessert!“

“Whipped Feta Dip was incredible. Nashville Chicken Sandwich with hot honey was great. My wife had a Fancy salad with grilled chicken that looked too healthy for me, but she raved about it. Service was great, everybody we interacted with was smart, friendly and upbeat. I'm eager to return.“

“I love getting to come here and choose between a wide variety of different options. I think the white pizza’s are the best but have never not enjoyed a meal here. The inside atmosphere is also very cute and the workers have been nice every time I’ve interacted with them so far.“

“i went to the bathroom and it was terribly maintained. there was actually poop all over the walls and the sink didnt work. i went and grabbed my pizza and when i took it home and opened it, THERE WAS A TURD ON MY PIZZA. I would not go again but i still ate the pizza, it was pretty good ngl. i wonder if he ate some pizza before adding the extra topping.“

“The coziest mom and pop store in Natick. We have been going there for years and the staff is so helpful and good. Great food. You can't go wrong if you order the barbecue chicken pizza. Definitely the best pizza is Natick. You can try half and half as well. Cold beers (Jack Abby) served as well.“

“Late lunch. One of three people there. The other guys there where friendly and great to talk to. They told me everything there is made fresh, and pizza dough is made daily. The bartender Amy was personable, fun, and great! Met one of the owners too. Nice guy. All around great experience and food was excellent.
Highly recommend 👌“