New American Restaurants in Provincetown, MA

“Top notch from beginning to end. The location in town and the building itself were quite charming, tables and floor plan was cozy but not too crowded. My wife and I started with the chilled green pea soup and egg truffle custard to start. They were delightful. The cocktails here were also amazing. My wife had “the last word” and I did a (nonalcoholic) lychee lemonade.The entrees we chose were both specials and were also to die for. We shared the monkish special and the wagyu ribeye and they were both cooked to perfection and executed exquisitely.
Above and beyond the wonderful food/atmosphere was our AMAZING server Bruno. He was a consummate professional through the evening but balanced his extensive menu knowledge with a beautiful charm and wit that had us enthralled and entertained the entire evening. His top notch service elevated an already great experience to an unmatched one. Highly reccomend giving Freemans a try! Thank you Bruno!“

“Food, atmosphere and drinks are awesome. Never had a bad meal here. I highly recommend the Tuna.“

“Jimmy’s is one of those places that never fails to satisfy, in a big way. This outing we had the grilled oysters, delicious, lobster carbonara, plenty of lobster in an amazing sauce, and the filet, which was one of the best steaks we have ever had!
The food is consistently great, service top notch, in an old school cozy atmosphere. If you haven’t eaten at Jimmys you are missing out on a truly great dining experience!!!“

“Great food and service …………………/“

“Our dining experience was top notch from the moment we walked through the door. We were warmly greeted by a friendly bar keep, seated by a welcoming, accommodating host and our server was knowledgeable, helpful and friendly as well. The food, THE FOOD... AMAZING! Best coconut shrimp EVER! Delicious grilled chicken sandwich with the best sweet potato fries I've ever had. My husband had the Alley Club sandwich with handcut fries and he raved about all of it! Don't walk by this wonderful spot... it's well worth your time and hard earned money.“

“Everything was excellent! ♥️ 🎂 Thank you!“

“Great food and great vibe!!“

“The Patio has always been a favorite spot in town, but what really makes it shine is the people—and no one embodies that more than Martini. They have a way of turning dinner into an experience: sharp, charming, and always making you feel at home. Whether it’s steering you toward the right dish or keeping the whole table laughing, Martini has that perfect mix of professionalism and personality that makes you want to come back again and again. Around here, we all know The Patio is special—but when Martini’s your server, it’s unforgettable.“

“Very cool spot food was very very good“

“Food was excellent, the waiter was excellent and the restaurant itself was great.“

“This place was surprisingly amazing. The steak frites was one of my favorites ever, steak was so tender and flavorful and the fries were perfect, along with the sauces. The oysters were so fresh and big and the arugula salad was unreal. Such a good experience! I just wish they had more wine by the glass options. The service was a bit slow but that’s fine.“

“This is one of my favorite go to stops. I love the craft cocktails, they are very classy with a lot of history behind them.

It is a unique atmosphere, it has charm, a tropical upscale feel, but very relaxed and casual at the same time. The bartenders work very hard and make a perfect cocktail every time.

The food is also very good and unique. One of my favorite dishes is the Shrimp with roasted garlic and polenta.

Every time I'm in town, I stop in for a visit.“

“Every trip we make to Provincetown has to include eating at least one meal at The Mayflower. The atmosphere is basic but the food and service is excellent! Great home style food with excellent fish and Portuguese choices, all at very reasonable prices. Over the last many years, the friendly staff and quick service has always been excellent. Highly recommend!“

“Our sever Andrea was fabulous, and the food is some of the best Provincetown has to offer. Our group ended up waiting outside for 35 minutes for our reserved table at 7:15, finally sitting at 7:50. We were comped a delicious dessert for having to wait. That was much appreciated. My only suggestion would be to let diners know that they have a set period of time at the table (such as 1 1/2-2 hours), or leave a longer window of time between reservations.“

“Fun and efficient staff couples with the million dollar view make this a great stop!“

“Best food in town, hands down!“

“It was beautiful! The house was absolutely gorgeous. Staff friendly, room very comfortable. We only had breakfast there but it was made to order & it was good. Many outdoor spaces to gather in evening with fire table and music. Hoping to return someday.“

“Absolutely the best fish tacos I’ve ever had and I’ve had a lot. Delicious lime aioli too!“

“Great food, great location, great staff. We had the cod in parchment and the lobster ravioli..(followed by the chocolate peanut butter pie and the vanilla cheesecake, recommended by our lovely waitress Darby) It was delicious. Well worth the drive after landing in Boston from the UK“