21 Best American Restaurants near Sheffield

“Pleasant outdoor dining! You bus your own table“

“If you've never been, enter a GEM. And be cool...It's been welcoming pilgrims for 150+ YEARS. History, come to Life. No phonies...Just real people ...doing a bang up job...with kindness, class, talent and care. Good vibes, great drinks and chow. Hi Style...So well done. Be thankful. Party on. Mum's the word.“

“So charming and full of character. We had a wonderful time with our children and extended family. Food was excellent and loved the location. Very relaxing and scenic. Tap water was incredible! Ice cold and tasty. Really neat to drink mountain spring water right in our room! I made sure I filled up our water bottles before we left.“

“Food and service were outstanding!“

“Really sweet charming place. Very warm and welcoming. We were surprised how elegant the restaurant felt when we walked in because we were expecting more of a pub. The bar area is also small, atmospheric, inviting you to linger. Having been there a few times now, I’d say the menu is carefully thought out, but occasionally, the quality (freshness) and portions are hit or miss, but mostly hit. It’s a nice little neighborhood treasure and always an enjoyable place to go.“

“Mini golf and hand cut fries!“

“Omg. Fried shrimp chili you need nothing more don’t misunderstand. I’ve had the other food. It’s amazing. Would highly recommend who knows might even see you there one day.“

“Have been here a handful of times and it never disappoints! Tonight we met the owner, Frank, what a great guy! This place is a hidden gem. Take a day trip and head over to this place, you’ll be glad you did. Every meal we’ve had has been delicious and served promptly. Cocktails on point. Love the hip vibe and the servers are very attentive and super friendly. Five stars 🌟 🌟 🌟 🌟 🌟“

“On our way home from drone daughter off at camp we stopped in. I got the brisket and rib combo. My wife got the burger. We got a pretzel and Mediterranean snack. It was all delicious. Friendly staff and nice atmosphere. I will go again.“

“Great food and coffee, great service!“

“What a perfect place to get to enjoy this morning. Thank you for the excellent caring service to the incredible scratch made authentic Mexican food 🙏🏼“

“Charming place with tasty food!“

“Chef David makes the most incredible meals…BBQ,duck, steak😋seafood, oysters and clams…. and much much more! Pretty bar keep Cindi can whip you up almost anything... The long time favorites are superb and she has beers and seltzers that won't quit LOL👍👍👍“

“A few great items done well. Bring your wallet. Get extra jam if you’re feeling saucy.“

“Great accommodations, comfortable and well located in the hamlet of Hillsdale. I would definitely stay there again. There were some stairs to our rooms though, so that might be a little tough if you have mobility problems, though they also seemed to have nice ground level cabins.“

“Beautiful space and.lovely garden out front. Quaint and comfortable inside. Small food menu, but there are lots of great choices. Had the ricotta w toast and mortadella. I'm not a pork fan, but the ricotta and toast were delicious. Had the Hake cake, which was smokey and delicious, and the brick chicken, which was substantial and perfectly prepared. Extensive wine list. Had a French rose that was delightful. Waitstaff was pleasant and made good recommendations. Would return again and again and again.“

“My son and daughter in law got married n June is 2025. Everything was absolutely fabulous! If you’re looking for a farm setting for your wedding I highly recommend Gedney Farm! The restaurant is also amazing. Great atmosphere and delicious food!“

“The paninis are delicious. The potato skins are good, too. The french fries were a bit over crispy for me but still good. Beers are cold, the service is alright, pool tables, keno, scratch tickets, and a full menu of other items are there too.“

“Truly loved it! Beautiful restaurant with a cute rustic cozy feel and great atmosphere. As someone who eats out a lot, I wasn't sure what to expect but the food was excellent. From the Signature, Caprese Salad, the delicious brick oven pizza, the Rack of Lamb for my husband all through to dessert, everything was extremely flavorful and delicious. The hot food came out hot, a pet peeve of mine is when it comes out luke warm from sitting to be served. Here everything was perfectly temperature. And can we talk about the cocktails? LOVED the Neo’s Negroni. 5 stars from me fully recommend this amazing restaurant won’t be disappointed!“

“Workers always friendly and attentive!! Great business!!“

“Enjoyed the food and atmosphere“