50 Best Pizza Restaurants near South Hamilton

“thank goodness for 5 Sons (& the lovely, beautiful-hearted Jen in particular) Entire staff is awesome & the food is just beyond. 😋“

“Some friendships have a way of picking up right where they left off, no matter how much time passes between visits. That was exactly the case when Cheryl and I met up with our longtime friends John and Mary Lou for dinner at Post in Hamilton.

Several years ago they moved from Georgetown to Beverly, so we do not get together nearly as often as we used to. Not only are they dear friends, but Mary Lou has also been Cheryl's hairstylist for years. Since they now live on the North Shore, they suggested we meet at Post, which is located in the space many locals will remember as the original Black Cow.

The restaurant was warm and welcoming from the moment we arrived. There is convenient off-street parking behind the building, we were seated immediately for our reservation, and before long our friends arrived and the catching up began.

We started with drinks, and on John's recommendation I ordered a Manhattan. I am glad I listened because it was one of the best Manhattans I have ever had. Cheryl ordered an Aperol Spritz and loved hers as well.

For appetizers, we decided to share a few dishes family style. The standout for me was the Honey Truffalo Cauliflower. The bleu cheese crumbles melted into the glaze and gave the dish an incredibly rich, creamy flavor that had everyone reaching for another bite. We also shared a crab cake that received rave reviews from everyone at the table and I enjoyed a small Cygnet Salad to start my meal.

One thing worth mentioning is that both Cheryl and Mary Lou eat gluten-free. For Cheryl it is a lifestyle choice, while for Mary Lou it is an allergy. The staff was knowledgeable, accommodating, and helped identify menu options that worked for both of them.

For dinner, Cheryl and Mary Lou split the chicken tacos, John ordered the chicken parmesan, and I chose the Blackened Street Corn Scallops. The scallops were perfectly seared, tender, and flavorful, served over a sweet and creamy corn risotto that was every bit as good as the scallops themselves. It was one of those dishes where you find yourself slowing down because you do not want the meal to end.

The prices were very reasonable, the service was attentive and friendly, and there were several other menu items that caught our attention for a future visit.

What made the evening special, though, was the opportunity to spend time with good friends. We spent hours catching up, talking about our growing families, sharing stories about our children, and comparing notes on the joys of becoming grandparents. The conversation was so enjoyable that after dinner we headed back to their home in Beverly for another drink and several more hours of conversation.

Great food, excellent drinks, friendly service, and most importantly a wonderful night spent with great friends. Cheryl and I will definitely be back.“

“Great NY style pizza with a gourmet twist. The manager, Stu, is a super nice guy. I highly recommend you give them a try! HUGE pizza slices!!!“

“I recently visited this pizzeria and had a great experience overall. The pizza was absolutely delicious—fresh ingredients, perfectly baked crust, and rich flavors in every bite. You can really tell they care about quality and authenticity. What made the visit even better was the staff. They were welcoming, friendly, and very attentive without being overwhelming. The service was quick, and they made sure everything was just right throughout the meal. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, making it a perfect place to relax and enjoy good food with friends or family. I would definitely recommend this pizzeria to anyone looking for tasty pizza and excellent customer service.“

“Great pizza, awesome staff!!“

“Amazing food, Meatball and eggplant are incredible, Large sandwich is enough for two meals, I’ve gone several times now and highly recommended!“

“I have tried salads, subs, multiple pizzas, wings & dinners all were fantastic. Reasonably priced, owner super friendly. Easily best pizza in Beverly as well as Best pizza ever. Meatballs are unbeatable size quality I could go on and on.“

“I actually loved this place! Their food was so good. If I could I would have eaten their everyday just so I could try everything. But sadly I only got to try their hamburgers and pizza and omg they were the best! Dont forget to try their cookies! Oh my the best!“

“Nickey's is tremendous!! Best Pizza and Subs, ever!! The folks that work there are family and they are super nice and attentive. I have tried a number of their offerings and everything is delicious. Been going there for years and I highly recommend their Pepperoni Pizza - I've never been disappointed!!“

“Stopped in for some pizza after a long day. Decided on the Big Mac pizza. Absolutely delicious!! Ingredients were fresh, crust was cooked to perfection and toppings were generous. Customer service was also top notch! Would highly recommend.“

“some of the more creative and better pizzas in the area. a wide variety of sandwiches, wraps and subs, plus salads and dinners (pasta or rice). what's not to like? love the melanzane and the shrimp scampi pizzas, but other combinations are good too (plus MYO, of course).“

“they have amazing food!!!“

“Delicious pizza and subs served by a friendly staff! Thank you for lunch! We will be back.“

“Highly recommend the pizza; it features all very fresh ingredients. The staff is very friendly and the environment is very comfortable! Great to bring the kids!“

“food is always great here. don't sleep on the devil's toast!!“

“The food is absolutely delicious and friendly customer service. One of my favorite place in this area highly recommend. ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Just grabbed a 3 way from Nicks on Essex. This place is a 9.2. Beef was top notch. Online ordering was a breeze. It was ready when I arrived. Friendly staff. I’ll be back! 😋“

“Scott and his crew are a welcome staff to this place. Had an awesome toasted Italian today with some pizza and a few other items to boot. Great service, clean place, excellent food. Can’t wait to go back!! Good luck Scott, you’re going to kill it!!“

“Excellent pizza!“

“Absolutely love this place! Great food, great service, and fair prices. The pizza is always delicious, the ingredients taste fresh, and the staff is incredibly friendly. You can tell they care about quality and customer satisfaction. One of my go-to spots whenever I’m craving pizza or pasta.“

“Pizza loaded with toppings and still beautifully crisp on the bottom. The best onion rings I've ever had--- super thin, super crunchy coating and perfectly tender onion. I'd come back just for the onion rings. Warm and friendly staff.“

“Topsfield house of pizza has always been a super friendly establishment with decent food. A couple years ago I came here with my class as the Essex tech was doing work for the town of topsfield. When we came in and sat down we were gifted a free pizza from the staff. Now years later I return by myself and still get the same phenomenal hospitality I did years ago. Ordered two slices, received three. Wanted to leave a review so you guys know it’s appreciated. Thanks for going the extra step that so many other businesses fail to do! Will absolutely be returning in the future!“

“Junior roast beef was excellent. Much better than Kelly’s which used to be the best.“

“Great homemade food, Great customer service!“

“We visited from out of state and felt so welcomed by the staff here. The Gal was working alone but still talked with us the entire time while she flipped dough by hand and made pizzas, calzones and subs. The calzones were huge and so delicious! Our Air bnb wasn’t ready for a couple of hours so she was nice enough to let us keep our luggage behind the counter so we didn’t have to it around. We will definitely be going back!“

“Nick's has wicked good Food.
Prices match what you receive.
Everyone there is very friendly & always have smiles when I walk in. My usual is a Steak Bomb & wow it's packed. It's wicked yummy .. For a cold Sub I get an Italian n it's always fresh n packed like a Sub should be!!!. Def go to Nick's you will absolutely love it.“

“Great pizza, have always liked the pizza here. Last night we ordered 2 pizzas to go since we currently can’t eat out. Place was very slow with few customers but the pizza was good, hot and ready when I picked it up. Order out people and help them out. Glad we ordered here for dinner on Tuesday.“

“The food was great. I got a small special pizza 🍕 😋😋💥. The staff was very friendly as well.“

“The food is excellent and the people behind the counter are soo friendly. Highly recommend!“

“We had such a blast at your restaurant! The food was amazing and the drinks were out of this world! The staff were so nice and welcoming! We came in on Friday before closing and everyone was so nice! We so appreciated it! We can’t wait to come back when we visit! Best vegan pizza I ever had!“

“The pizza, Cesar salad with brisket and cocktails were amazing. The staff and music were a lot of fun too. This place is our new local go to! I can’t wait to go back next week.“

“nice steak bombs also lamb kabob sub ,salads crab meat,lobster plenty full fried clams and calamari are a treat at very fair prices and home style feeling“

“The name is true, the pizza really is amazing. Jacqui has great hospitality, a delicious sauce and cheese blend atop perfectly crunchy but never overcooked crust. The garlic bread sticks are also a favorite!“

“I love this pizza place! They have single slices for 4 dollars that are bigger than your head and so delicious. Their sauce is SO YUMMY!! Every time I come there, the staff is so friendly and so kind. They have outside seating too, which is great i love that, I definitely recommend coming here. You will not regret it!!“

“I have been a loyal customer for over 30 years to CAP but have to say just now to the new owners who bought from Jimmy and Kosta who have that whole time treated me as family..thankyou because you just right now while I was picking up, recognized me as a loyal patron and family as they did! More than well done! Food is the same the best and service is loving and as close to home as it gets! They knew me and had me as I walked in of my 3rd time. THAT is crazy respect and customer service 👏 5⭐“

“We needed to schedule delivery of a working lunch for several people. Village accommodated our scheduling needs, made sure we had everything we needed in terms of plates/cups/cutlery, and delivered on time. Everyone’s order was exactly as requested and the food was excellent. (I got the Shroom burger and added bacon, and it was the best burger I’ve had in a long time.) We will definitely order from them again when we’re working in the area.“

“I think Panini is one of the best Pizza Shops In Danvers. In the fall, when my women's group meets, we get a pizza every week and we devour it. Price wise, it is definitely fair. With the growing inflation of food, I'm glad that they haven't gouged the prices with a big hike. It is centrally located next to CVS. I love a good 'Pie' and this is definitely one. They also sell slices, which is a plus when you just need a quick bite. I wish them continued great success! 🍕🙏“

“I love love, love Tony’s Italian restaurant! Being fortunate enough to live across the street from the business, I have thoroughly enjoyed many years of going to Tony’s. Food is totally delicious, and pizza unbelievably delicious! Family owned business, and they are absolutely lovely. I always feel right at home when I visit. I could go on and on, but I just had to say wonderful things about the whole family, and about the wonderful food that I have enjoyed & continue to enjoy ,at Tony’s restaurant. I continue to be fortunate enough to celebrate this great business!??“

“Hands down the best roast beef I've ever had. I would eat it every day if I could; eat some there and order more for later! Definitely a place I have to go whenever I'm in the area. Crew was friendly, everyone is there for the roast beef, it was wholesome. I'm sure their other food is great, but the roast beef is where it's at.“

“If you're in Salem, MA, you have to check out Peter's Bella Pizza! Their pizza is absolutely delicious—crispy, flavorful, and always made with fresh ingredients. The staff is incredibly friendly and welcoming, making the whole experience even better. Whether you're a local or just visiting, Peter's Bella Pizza is a must-try!“

“Had a great wood fired pizza tonight. Will definitely go again 🍕“

“My niece and I went there on sun for lunch it's a Must go 😄great yummy pizza great crust pepperoni and mushrooms very good prices it's that mom and pops style that I miss I'll be back to enjoy a nother pizza 💜best lunch
Wish they come to Rehoboth Beach Delaware
Take cash they don't take cards 🙂“

“I haven’t been on top of my pizza game in some time. We have so many great places around. And this is my very first online review. But I hit up Renzos for a simple lg cheese. It was absolutely fantastic. One of the best I’ve had in years. Paper thin crust and the closest to the real Thatcher St. Regina I’ve had. And on top of that, the owner and son are tremendous guys. Talked Patriots football while I waited.“

“Just picked up some takeout ribs! They were some of the best, tender, ribs I’ve had anywhere in a long time!! Food seems to be always improving!! Well done guys!! Ribs are FANTASTIC!“

“Great Fast Food and Service. Delicious 😋 Thank you. Very Good Job. Will recommend to anyone. 6 Stars 🌟 Six“

“Great place for a quick slice of pizza“

“Honestly, just a great staff! Super local, I stop by every few weeks to pick up a pizza or two (usually after a long day or week at work just trying to grab some thing quick )and I regularly see the same smiling faces! The entire staff is always working hard, attentive and friendly! Thank you all! :)“

“We had a custom pizza last evening and it was absolutely delicious. We started with the 4-cheese and added red sauce and eggplant. I have found it hard to get a good Italian-style pizza in Ipswich, so I'm very happy that Otto is now in town!“

“Well i Harry Jones met Freddy as a member and 2 time president of New England Showmen Association at the club I would have been in Randolph Mass as the younger generation was coming into light the old timer didn’t want to let go of the torch starting 82 I might have met one of my closest friends in Frank Valenti who we all gave his resting place yesterday getting to know this family was a task by itself so huge and so big in multi talented Frank acted like a little kid in a candy store love wasn’t the word that you used to explain the feeling he had for his grandchildren I said to Frank want go here want to go there he would say to me I taken the grandchildren fishing or Barque he loved Kid Nice guy Frank I sold my trailer after 30 years and I had no place to store 500 worth of meat Frank Harry you are not going to throw this meat a way so he back the truck up and we did the old school relay he moved that freezer around like a toy and he put it down his cellar the time we had really grew when I retired from the business sanding and painting his Food Stands he loved the people and his heart was made of Gold God Bless Frankie until we meet again in the gateways of a line of people that are lined up for Garden Pizza where your grandchildren will be our servers“

“We ordered catering size orders for celebration of a family anniversary, the same day as the worst snow storm in years. The Eliopoulis family’s personal attention to the details of our order all the way through our pick-up was beyond comparison! The food was delicious! We give the highest of marks to the Eliopoulis family, their staff, and Pomodori’s Ipswich! The Eliopoulis family enables their customers to feel like family.“