50 Best Italian Restaurants near Stoughton

“La Stalla hosted a 50th wedding anniversary dinner for my parents for 50 people in June 2025. Michaela the event coordinator was fantastic and accommodating. We went with the buffet and the meatballs, arancini, chicken parm, haddock, and steak tips were excellent. The deserts of gelato and tiramisu were also fantastic. Everyone commented on how good the food was. The servers were extra accommodating in allowing me to use the television for a slide show. We even stayed past the planned time and the staff let us enjoy each other's company. I couldn't be happier with how the event went and will be coming in for dinner soon! - Sam T“

“Came to Amelia’s for Easter dinner. This was my first time there and I was not disappointed! Everything was wonderful, from the cleanliness of the restaurant, to the decor, to the food to the cappuccino. But what brought it to perfection level, was our server, Kayla. She was on point, friendly, patient and an all around lovely young lady. Thank you so much for a wonderful experience!“

“So nice not to have to go to the North Shore for amazing roast beef!! Thank you!“

“This has been my go to OG since I was a kid. Our server Juan was absolutely wonderful. They confirmed our choice to get the new creamy garlic dishes, and boy oh boy was it the right move. 11/10 service. Will def be back again soon 🔥“

“I usually don’t like reviews but I just had to this evening I called in the order and used for about to close in a few minutes but you still took my otter and I thought that the food wouldn’t be as good as it generally is that it would be called something would be wrong But I’m telling you I still give you a five star and I wish I would’ve left more of a tip the food meaning I added stuffed haddock with mashed potatoes and broccoli and everything is still fresh and hot I love you guys thank you so much for a perfect meal ??“

“Great. Been there dozens of times.“

“Great food and atmosphere. Amanda, Jay and their staff are amazing! Highly recommend!“

“Dinner there tonight and it was excellent. Beautiful room with comfortable dining. Extensive wine and cocktail list. We loved several pasta dishes- bolognese, sausage broccoli Rob, arancini, mussels - all delicious. Great cannolis and tasty ice creams rounded out the night. Service was excellent and free garage parking behind the place is a bonus. Highly recommended“

“The best beef bolognese I have had in ages! Time to buy more!“

“I really like the food, also they cooked the way I like it. Thanks for serving MA“

“Always amazing food and service!!!“

“We stopped here before a concert at Xfinity. Really some of the best food I’ve ever had! We had the margherita pizza, crispy eggplant—so good we got another order—and the bruschetta. It was all so fresh and so good. I would love to try a full dinner from there! If I lived closer I would be there all the time! I will def go back next time I’m in the area. The staff were all so amazing too!“

“We had an excellent dining experience here. Calamari was some of the best I have ever had. Flatbread pizza was creative and oh so flavorful. Mushroom ravioli wasn’t a huge portion but was so well made and fresh I didn’t care. Creative and well made cocktails and the complimentary bread was delicious and a really nice touch. Our waitress Kathleen was very kind and attentive, and when our gift card was accidentally misplaced she worked with the manager to rectify right away. Fantastic atmosphere and outdoor dining experience! Would highly recommend this spot!“

“Great service. Greater food“

“Pleasant atmosphere, great food, upstairs deck for outside dining, social distancing and great services.“

“On October 2nd, we hosted a Rehearsal Dinner for 35 that opened up to a Welcome Party for 90. The transition in their beautiful event space was seamless, thanks to Joanna and her wonderful staff. Leading up to the events, Joanna answered any question I threw at her. It was especially comforting since I was organizing from Florida. The food at the rehearsal dinner was delicious, chicken parm, salmon, gnocchi. The service, both food and drink was exceptional. We did a prix fixe menu and Joanna created a specific menu for our event. It felt very special. For the welcome party with an open bar, we chose a charcuterie board, fruit platter, meatballs and arancini all served buffet style. High top tables were added to accommodate the additional guests. Again, Joanna and her staff paid attention to every detail. As the hostess, besides wanting great food and service for my guests, it was extremely important that I got to enjoy my son’s wedding festivities. I had the best time not having to worry about a thing. I can’t thank Joanna and her staff enough for making it all happen.“

“Great owners and clientele!“

“We tried 6 different things and they were all amazing . Great pizza , deserts are delicious. Fun atmosphere and the big wood stove fire is cool. Service was fast and polite. Our food came out pretty fast even tho it was busy on Friday. Everything was very well prepared and generous serving sizes. I can’t wait to go back. Get the Popeyes sweet pea pizza . One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had.“

“Can’t talk this place up enough amazing old school authentic Italian and a very warm environment whether your looking for a nice cup of coffee or a chicken parm sangy the workers over here always do it right. Killer Sicilian pizza as well!“

“Second time. Great food. Great flavors. Great atmosphere. Cooked beautifully. Our server, Liz, excellent! She was friendly, attentive to detail, knowledgeable . La Familia doesn't even come close across the board. poor quality food and poor service.“

“We dined at Campanale’s this evening - it couldn’t have been better. The atmosphere was very festive, with tasteful Christmas decorations, not overdone. The food was great, the waitstaff were friendly and attentive. 🍝🎄👏🏻“

“A little taste of Italy! Everything was on point 100% from the drinks to the dessert. Espresso martini was the best EVER, the bolognese was the BEST EVER! The chocolate lava cake and gelato was by far the best I’ve ever had! Service, staff atmosphere was all amazing! Can’t wait to go back!“

“I've been going here for 50 years now , this is th best italian rest in the south shore and it's better than the over glorified unhealthy comfort food places with high ratings by a long shot.“

“We had such a great time tonight at dinner with Santa! Santa was amazing and really took the time to interact with the kids. The cookies they provided to be decorated were actually delicious according to my kids. Food was amazing as always. Service was great. Despite it being busy, it was very well managed and not over crowded or overwhelming to the staff. Super impressed and will definitely be looking forward to this next year!“

“Our high school sports team hosted an end of season banquet at Tutto Bene yesterday – and it was wonderful! The owner and his team could not have been more accommodating. The buffet options were delicious and they also handled two special diet requests. The private room is pretty and can hold up to 60. It was very comfortable for our group of 30 and 30 display area. Although we brought in our own floral arrangements, they had many life-like silk flower arrangements already available in the room.“

“Outstanding experience from start to finish. The food was excellent, the atmosphere was welcoming, and the service was truly exceptional. A special thank you to Thomas, the manager, who went above and beyond to accommodate food allergies and ensure our meal was both safe and enjoyable. His attention to detail, professionalism, and genuine care for guests made a great dining experience even better. It’s rare to find this level of customer service these days. Highly recommend, and we’ll definitely be back!“

“Great slice nice and crispy full pie is on the have to get list.“

“incredible experience from service till desert. now my new favorite restaurant. everything was amazing and highly recommend“

“Good food, friendly staff, affordable for lunch and catering“

“I got the rancho wrap and it was awesome!! Can you say addicted.. 😍“

“Vico Ristorante Italiano offers an authentic Italian experience on the South Shore, with "amazing food". The service was great, with a large wine selection. I recommend the Rigatoni Bolognese.“

“First time here and food was fantastic! I got the eggplant parm and it was delicious! Generous portion that I had plenty to take home. Bartender/manager Brian was outstanding and so friendly. Can’t wait to go back!“

“Adrian was the best service we have had in a long time. Great place ask for him if you want great service. Will be back.“

“So glad I trusted the Google reviews and tried Trattoria! Was traveling from Boston to Rhode Island on a work trip with my boss and we stopped here for dinner. WOW! Friendly staff, beautiful restaurant, and absolutely fresh and amazing food! I knew it was going to be good because it was packed on a Wednesday night! Dinner was perfect from the fresh made from scratch bread with oil to the giant meatball appetizer and the delicious pollo Parmesana and pollo Francese! The beautiful dessert selection was the final touch to a very satisfying meal. I can’t wait to come back the next time I’m anywhere near the northeast! Molte Grazie!“

“This restaurant has been closed since the pandemic. Don’t know how people are reviewing it this year. Particularly the ones with a photo?“

“First time visiting & very impressed. Food was delicious, good size portions. wait staff very friendly & attentive. A great place to dine that doesn't break your wallet!“

“I have a complaint to be made, the chef Orlin Garcia himself, who works at the establishment, said that Mr. Carlos, the owner of Mak's.the kitchen is very dirty, there are a lot of rats, if basic sanitation is improved there, people will run the risk of catching leptospirosis, the snacks are very tasty and very dirty. Max Orlim Garcia's cook brought me a snack, my son-in-law said don't eat it because Mr. Carlos, the owner of the pizzeria, uses leftover food from other people at the table or what's left over As I said, Americans drool with desire for this burger, even though it's leftovers from other tables. He's a dirty and disgusting person, and Orlim himself helps to remake the burgers.“

“5 STAR TREATMENT!!! We had my husbands surprise birthday party there last night for 40 guests and it went off without a hitch! Jim the manager went out of his way to check all the little details that make an event special from custom menus to an easel for a sign. The waitstaff was wonderful and accommodating! The food was wonderful and the room was comfortable! Nobody left the party early!!! Thank you Olivadi!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ high recommended The best pizza in town“

“Just got takeout. We've been coming there for many years. The food was always delicious and generous. Today we ordered a large Italian sub and a quart of minestrone soup. While everything was fresh and tasty, we were disappointed in the somewhat minimal contents of the sub. The soup recipe seems like it had changed from the original one but it was still good. Maybe it was just an off day. We liked the new decor.“

“From the Hostess to the Servers, staff was pleasant and professional. The food was exceptional!“

“Bertucci's makes the best pizza around, all of their dishes are good. prices are reasonable, service is good. We noticed it wasn't nearly as crowded as it used to be before the pandemic, that's too bad, it's a nice place.“

“I just had the most amazing grilled octopus ever!!!!! Tania makes the best espresso martini I've ever had!!! This is my new favorite place.“

“It is not just the good quality pizza / other cusine that Comellas makes that is appealing about this restaurant. Rather it has a versatile atmosphere fitting for any type of classy dinning experience. With service that is home-like and warm. I would recommend Comellas to anyone.“

“Just Ordered One Of The Best Italian Subs I’ve Had In A Long Time.. First Timer There But They’ll Get To Know Me, Waiting To Try Their Take-Out Dinners And Such..“

“Best pizza in Quincy, hands down. Plus their lunch special, 2 slices of cheese with a soda! Can’t beat that anywhere. Did I mention service with smile and they always remember my order.“

“I absolutely love Avon House of Pizza! The team is so friendly, welcoming, and always makes you feel like family. Everything on the menu tastes amazing, and their pizza is something special,the dough is so delicious and perfectly made! 🍕 I’ve tried the burgers, subs, wraps, and pizza, and honestly, everything is so fresh and tasty. I especially recommend trying the chicken wraps they are so yummy! 🌯❤️ I order from Avon House of Pizza every day, and honestly, I want to keep ordering every day because everything is just that delicious! 😍“

“Excellent food and service.“

“Great seafood takeout or dine in easy online ordering 5 star place“