39 Best Seafood Restaurants near Tisbury

“Excellent food and service. One of my favorites on Marthas Vineyard.“

“It was my first time there, and I will return eventually!“

“Let’s talk about the best warm lobster 🦞 roll in New England!!!!“

“Cape Codder born & raised...Sam's is the freshest , best seafood place locally by far! The staff is always great...the place squeaky clean. Prices have gone up because diesel is up...we don't mind paying for fabulous food!“

“Just had a delicious dinner, if you have never been or haven't visited in a while, you should definitely stop in!!!“

“Delicious bloody Mary’s and delicious food.“

“Friendly staff, excellent fresh food. Best kept secret in Falmouth.“

“This place is amazing! The food the atmosphere and of course all the amazing people! Outstanding food by the waterfront, what else can u ask for!“

“Food is so good. And the ambience is perfect. Love this resto.“

“No tables, no cash. Takeout only.But this seafood shack represents the best value in the island and it is very conveniently located in the heart of Edgartown.Lobster roll is pretty solid. New England clam chowder is tasty. Clam strips and other fried foods are beyond edible. Tastes like all ingredients are from the frozen section of Restaurant Depot, but there is absolutely nothing wrong with that as long as the line cook knows how to prepare those frozen foods. And they do more than an adequate job at it.I was getting a little bit tired of overpriced and under-portioned meals at the island. And I discovered this place and it was a treat.“

“Had a fabulous Brunch today at Romeos. The staff were friendly, attentive and professional. The Corn Muffins with maple butter and hot pepper jelly were delicious. Top notch make your own Bloody Mary's. Best Homfries I have ever tasted. Had the Romeo Sando and the eggs and bacon were cooked to perfection. We will be returning and can't wait to try the Dinner menu. I give them 5+ Stars!!!“

“Great place for a casual dinner. We were seated in the back and had great service. The fish and chips and blt were both delicious. My husband ordered the scallops and thought they were just ok. I would recommend sticking with the cheaper food options here.“

“Cool view of the water and boats! Food was fantastic and service was great! We had a delightful waiter with an awesome Jamaican accent. He was very accommodating to my many food allergies, one being shellfish, as was the chef. We flew all the From Kansas so my husband could experience fresh lobster. He was not disappointed! I had a wonderful piece of salmon with a miso soy sauce. Also, the clam chowder was fabulous!!! Oh and yummy Crème Brûlée!! Kudos to the chef!!“

“Water Street is one of the best places you can eat on the Cape! The food is beyond belief and the atmosphere is like having an upscale dinner at your best friends house. Absolutely perfect!“

“This restaurant is one of my favorites on Cape Cod. This food has to be some the most delicious food I’ve tasted anywhere! Whether you go for the sushi or traditional dishes, you cannot go wrong! If you’re in Falmouth; it’s a must try! My family and I have been several times and Ron, the owner, is amazing! Great service, and friendly, knowledgeable staff. Do yourself a huge favor and try this restaurant. I promise you, you will not be disappointed. You will be craving the food! :) 5 stars!!!!!!🤩“

“very good food and great service. highly recommended“

“The Haddock Chowder is Phenomenal and all fish is great Quality Staff is Very Friendly. Everytime I visit The Cape I stop at Falmouth Fish Market.“

“The fried clams here are absolutely elite - a delicate crispy batter and the freshest clams. The lobster roll is a league of its own - has celery and is slightly more mayo-y than others but I think it’s absolutely delicious, one of my absolute favorites and I’m very picky about my lobster rolls. The lobster roll and clams may be a little smaller than the gigantic options available elsewhere, but to me quality is more important than quantity. Top notch, I wouldn’t leave the Vineyard without these two of my favorites!“

“Get your pizza crispy and laced and you wont be disappointed“

“I had the Harpooned Swordfish. Best food I’ve ever had in 60 years on the planet!“

“Service friendly with an ungreedy seating plan. Relaxed environment and excellent sea food. Price is right and well worth the visit.“

“Great bar staff, food and service! More of a year-round Vineyarder’s destination.“

“We used the catering services for my husbands 60th birthday party, the food was exceptional! Brought it home to serve our quests and it was as hot as if we ate it at the restaurant! I highly recommend there catering services! Wonderful Owners! Wonderful restaurant!“

“What a great little gem! Stuck down the cape after a wake of a family member. The bridge traffic was backed up for miles. We decided to stop in for a bite and we were pleasantly surprised by this little place. The waitress was nice, attentive and fun. The food was very good and the atmosphere was a reminder of times gone by. Very relaxed and nice people. Thanks for getting us fueled up before heading back to Attleboro!! It was a great experience!!!“

“Great pizza and awsome service“

“Great selection of beers.“

“I love this place! We came everyday this week and ordered a variety of delicious meals. WOW!“

“Friendly Staff Great Food!“

“Great food, service, and atmosphere. Jodi has been our waitress many times and very pleasant.“

“Really great view if your waiting for your ferry ride back to the mainland! Super nice people“

“Great breakfast outside this morning! The blackberry/raspberry pancakes are to die for! Many great specials with lobster and crab. Service is friendly and host is too!“

“Dinner menu with their daily special’s is their best kept secret.“

“My husband I went there Mar 1,2025. The food was amazing and portions are very generous Enjoy 😉“

“Excellent dive bar, one of the last great ones on the Cape and in Massachusetts, or, really, anywhere. Atmosphere & ambience are excellent. Don’t let the exterior fool you, this place is cool, step inside & feel the vibe with all kinds of signage & plaques from old hotels, businesses and landmarks from all over the Cape and beyond. Bartenders are friendly and efficient. Excellent place to see a band.“

“My Empress Gin martini (Aka: The Dunes) was delightful. Thank you Billy & Shane for all the attention.“

“Always enjoy eating here! As a vegan, I get their classic marinara pasta and it’s delicious!!“

“Really great food year round!“

“This was mine and my hubby’s first time in Edgartown and we are so glad we went by the Atlantic! We loved sitting outside by the water and having a sip of wine. The service was great and so was the food! We’d highly recommend others eat at the Atlantic while in town!“