13 Best Italian Restaurants near Webster

“The ravioli and garlic bread are absolutely delicious 😋!“

“First time eating here, ordered a Buffalo Chicken pizza and it was amazing! Asked for pineapple as an added topping and they had no issue fulfilling my request. Friendly staff and a very nice meal, hope to eat here again sometime!

(Will add that their drinking water is absolutely repulsive, though — likely not the establishment's fault, but I recommend getting something else if you want a drink.)“

“My family did a timed pre order today placed (about 6 hours ahead of time online) for a large group coming from a local bowling alley for a birthday celebration. All 6 pizzas were ready when we got there at our exact time…fresh, hot and delicious! Plenty of paper goods, a nice bright, clean dining area with plenty of seating. Clean bathrooms and super friendly staff! All the guys at the front counter went above and beyond. Great visit!“

“My parents bought a house here in Webster been trying some spots got a sub here a couple days ago it was good my signature chicken finger sub lettuce, onion, jalapenos and bbq sauce toasted it hit the spot. Today I was like I gotta try the pizza got a pepperoni and jalapeno pizza small. This was solid pizza your basic Greek style style pizza which personally I really don't mind I really like Greek style pizza crust is on the thinner side which I love was crispy I will definitely come back here. Def a solid pizza place for when I come visit.“

“Last Friday is the first time I’ve tried their fish and chips, although I’ve eaten there before and never been disappointed. Take out Fish and chips- 2 large fillets of Fish, coleslaw and fries- EXCELLENT!“

“The veal picatta is absolutely divine. Cooked perfectly. I also tried the homemade fettuccine with a pesto cream sauce. Amazing. So good. I love the way food is prepared at Calabria. The only complaint I have is the Italian bread. It takes gummy and without flavor.“

“There are restaurants you visit—and then there are restaurants you experience. Mama Italia Ristorante is undeniably the latter.

At the heart of this extraordinary place is Marco Baldieri, a chef whose life story reads like a love letter to Italian cuisine. Marco is not only the chef, but the owner, the soul, and the heartbeat of Mama Italia. Well known throughout the United States for opening and leading highly successful restaurants, he has earned recognition in countless magazines and newspapers—yet here, in the charming town of Woodstock, Connecticut, he has chosen to create something intimate, authentic, and deeply personal.

Walking into Mama Italia feels like stepping off a cobblestone street in Rome. The ambiance is old-school Italian in the most beautiful way—warm, inviting, timeless. The aromas alone transport you straight to Italy, but it’s the feeling that stays with you: the sense of being welcomed into someone’s home rather than seated at a table.

Chef Marco is famously hands-on. You’ll often see him greeting guests, checking on plates, sharing stories, and making every diner feel like family. His presence is genuine, charismatic, and deeply rooted in Italian hospitality. This is a man who doesn’t just cook Italian food—he lives it.

Every dish reflects decades of mastery, passion, and respect for tradition. The flavors are bold yet elegant, comforting yet refined—each bite a reminder of why Italian cuisine is celebrated worldwide. It is not about trends or theatrics here; it is about soul, history, and perfection achieved through simplicity.

Mama Italia is truly a diamond—small, adorable, and priceless. It is the kind of place people talk about long after the meal ends, the kind of restaurant you feel honored to discover. Dining here is not just a pleasure; it is a privilege.

If you ever find yourself in Woodstock, Connecticut, securing a table at Mama Italia is an experience you will treasure. To eat here is to travel to Rome without leaving New England—and to be welcomed by one of the finest Italian chefs this country has ever known. 🇮🇹✨

Sabrina B“

“I haven't had a bad meal here. Service is always good. Plenty of seating. The lemon chicken parm is one of my favorite go to meals. Good portions.

***Food Mood Note: They have Coke products here! Their Diet Coke Crisp factor: Super crispy!“

“Great service! Was busy but that didn’t hinder the attention and care we received! Very clean! Always a great meal here!“

“Stopped on way home from RI very friendly staff and the pizza was awesome 😋“

“Amazing food, waiter was geat.“

“Such a great find! Cozy atmosphere warm and welcoming staff. Everyone is very friendly makes you feel at home! The food is incredible my son and I went for breakfast! Highly recommended if you haven't tried it yet!“

“First visit to oxfords casual dining this past weekend in Oxford and absolutely not our last. Everything was absolutely delicious, and our waitress was super busy but took good care of us. Also got to enjoy some great music from The Drunken Uncles.“