22 Best American Restaurants near Wellfleet

“Incredible setting, sophisticated food and friendly service. A special night out!“

“Been coming here for the last couple years. The pitmaster is a gentleman who knows what he's doing. very tasty food and some fun sides. very friendly and always good wait staff. shall keep coming!“

“The lobster nachos were excellent! Highly recommend ✅“

“UNCHARACTERISTRICALLY LONG WAIT. Usually good, fast, friendly. Today we were there THIRTY MINUTES waiting for four sandwiches. New staff still learning the ropes, which is understandable, but at least a dozen other sandwiches got made for people ordering •after• us before we got our four. Hope this process improves considerably in the next few weeks...“

“Just had dinner at The Wicked Oyster. Arguably one of the best fine dining experiences we have had at the Cape. All the boxes were checked. Great atmosphere, food, and staff. Our waiter, Daniel, was exceptional and certainly a big credit to our experience“

“Food was excellent, the waiter was excellent and the restaurant itself was great.“

“Just flew in from Toronto and my first stop on the Cape is always Mahoneys..
My go to dinner is always the clam chowder and a plate of the best tuna sashimi ever!!
The bartenders are wonderful and I can always look forward to a very good “pour!”“

“Always the best food and service. Fair prices for excellent food! Amazing desserts too!“

“Great service. Food was served hot and quickly. Prepared wonderfully. Excellent , attentive staff. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Excellent!!! From the staff to the amazing food.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Best Seafood!! Been here twice Sept 2021 & Sept 2023 consistent quality perfectly cooked fish tacos (A little spicy) and fish sandwich is delicious. Best onion rings I’ve ever had, they come out amazing and not dripping in grease. Loved it the first time to Cape Cod had to bring my mom and M.I.L the next trip 🥰🤩 highly recommend!!“

“Sunbird is one of my favorite breakfast spots on the cape. The food is unique and wholesome. My favorites are the breakfast tacos and chai latte. I love the picnic tables and patio in the back - such a relaxing spot to enjoy quiet or a catch up with friends!“

“Delicious seafood, casual setting HOWEVER self service cold water no longer offered along with condiment bar. You have to go to soda machine and pay $3.00 if you're thirsty.....not very hospitable..bad PR“

“first time there Linda was amazing the food spectacular“

“We ordered online tonight, and it was DELICIOUS!! They were slammed tonight and there was a bit of a wait but I didn't mind. the staff was working hard & doing a great job!!!“

“Always enjoy when we are in the area.“

“Love the breakfast, love the wonderful wheat bread. Looking for a bakery that will sell me some.“

“It took me a while to try this place after I saw they removed tempeh and vegan cheese from the menu. No need for those with all the other scrumptious vegan fillings- you can load up a bowl or burrito with any and all vegan fillings- tons of vegetables, black and refried beans, and brown rice. Updated from previous review on 2025-08-18“

“I go to this lovely spot quite often! This is the best place to pass a nice evening. I visit this spot many times. The meals are of high quality, the staff members are friendly and the payment is reasonable. I enjoy being in this spot over a good dinner.“

“Ordered takeout last night. Mushroom,Swiss burgers,medium. Absolutely the best.... Perfectly cooked burger,yummy mushrooms with a surprise of bacon,gooey Swiss cheese,the best. Fries and pickle perfect compliment. Nice job Yardam cooking staff. We'll be back!“

“I rarely go out for drinks and find an establishment that can serve a Richard Nixon, let alone an establishment that can make one that really takes my breath away! If you’re looking for the summer spot to grab a perfect Richard Nixon look no further!“

“I had a fish fry and it was delicious.“