Bakeries near West Tisbury

“This is next to a great grocery market in the area (small "town") - bought a few years back (it's the old Fella's in West Tisbury) ; nestled in between the only grocery open year round close to up-island and next to the post office, also the only one in area that services this small town of mostly farm land. It was discovery of a coworker who was ranting about their bfast sandwiches- YEA - they are pretty spectacularly tasty!! I have had 4 items from this menu and today... I tried the pizza- I ATE THE CRUST - soft enough with a slight crunch - perfect dough, sauce was seasoned and is homemade- excellent. Best lil' spot to catch a quick bite. They are a slice app customer!!! Excellent!“

“The service was fantastic. I do not remember the lady's name that helped us but she was great! She was working the cashier and was very helpful and a kind human being. One of the girls on the team left their grilled cheese there and someone from pie in the sky brought the grilled cheese to the boat we were on and gave It to us. Thank you so much for helping us and the food was delicious!“

“We arrived for the ferry via the SSA shuttle bus, but our planned ferry was cancelled. With time to kill before the next ferry, and with breakfast on our minds, we wandered over to Coffee Obsession…actually a very short stroll from the ferry dock. Hot chai tea lattes partnered with breakfast sandwiches…bacon, egg, and cheese on everything bagels. These tasty sandwiches featured ample amounts of bacon, with the egg pretty much “over medium”. These were enjoyed on the covered porch. Service was friendly and attentive to detail, while prices were, in view of the quality, reasonable.“

“Charming, wonderful variety, cozy shop open every day to pay by cash or venmo. This is a woman-owned Wampanoag business using traditional and modern recipe inspirations. Pizza on Thursday and Friday April-November with byob and toppings, dough sauce cheese provided. The nicest owner who welcomed us with her friendly personality. A treasure!“

“I went in there last night with my daughter and grand daughter not expecting to order anything until I saw this amazing looking coffee and Oreo ice cream. It was a delicious as it looked. The owner, Elio, came in and we chatted about the shop and he handed me a loaf of olive bread by Madison Villatte, which was perfect. Excellent place with lovely owner.“

“Regardless of the long wait to have our sandwiches, we had zero disappointment in our food. Each bite literally melted in our mouths. I was ultimately impressed with their cookies. I kept mine for three days and yet it remained so soft and so good!“

“Last summer I planned a 20 person trip to the Vineyard. Back Door put together boxed welcome gifts for each of the guests. Everyone loved the donuts. They also made us a birthday cake, which received rave reviews. It was so delicious, I didn't think about taking a photo until after we ate it. Highly recommend.“

“I stumbled on this place because I needed a spot to finish up some homework while my boyfriend was busy. It's the perfect coffee shop. My coffee was delicious and the vibe was cozy and cute. Wifi worked really well. Would definitely come back.“

“Whew. Love LOVE this pie. Have stopped buying them one at a time because of the speed at which they disappear. The other baked goods are excellent. But you must try the pie. Probably top three crusts of my life and I am from the south. We also stop by before heading back to the ferry and take a few off island and they freeze well extending the joy for months to come. Treat yourself!“

“We just love that this new idea ... that brings together to Vineyard iconic experiences is happening ... just LOVE it ... the menu is at this early date at great combination .... we wish it well ... and have already used it twice . Just hope they can “nail” the classic items ... as they were ... and given the principles ... and their desire ... how could they not!“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐Scottish Bakehouse is an absolute gem on Martha's Vineyard! As a vegan, finding delicious and healthy options can sometimes be a challenge, but this place exceeded all expectations. Their selection of vegan baked goods is simply divine, from fresh breads to delectable pastries, each bite bursting with flavor and wholesome goodness.Not only is the food outstanding, but the prices are incredibly reasonable, making it accessible for everyone to enjoy. The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, perfect for grabbing a quick bite or settling in for a leisurely meal.Whether you're a local or just visiting the island, Scottish Bakehouse is a must-visit destination. You won't be disappointed!“

“I ordered a cake here for my mom’s 70th birthday. I requested vanilla cake with buttercream frosting and raspberry filling. Then I asked them to add gold shimmer.The staff was great getting everything together and making sure it was perfect for her big day.The cake ended up being one of the best ones we’ve ever tasted. And it was absolutely beautiful. I also thought the price was more than reasonable especially because things can cost a little extra being on an island. And I ordered one for 17-20 people but I think it could have fed double.So thank you!“

“Great breakfast sandwich, fast service (don't let the line fool you - it's a wait, but not as long as you think it will be), and they were able to accommodate a severe peanut allergy for a smoothie (the rest of the bakery goods were not safe, but we never expect that they are)! Thank you!“