33 Best Italian Restaurants near Elkton

“Haven’t been to Olive Garden in years and decided to go. The food was extremely good. My server Theo was extremely nice and attentive. The manager came out to ask if everything was ok and the hostess was also very polite. Great atmosphere I did go around lunch time.“

“Nice place, nice food, great costumer Service! It was our first time at that store and it was a great experience! The female manager was very nice and helpful she recommended us to try their best dishes and we really liked all of them! Totally recommend it“

“Very reminiscent of the Big Elk Liquor store sub (if you’re old enough to remember lol) I was very surprised at how amazing my Italian sub was! Meat in abundance sliced thin, and the bread and greens were amazing! Best sub I’ve had in years!!!! I don’t know why I waited so long to try. 10 stars from me and my husband!! Thank you Sonny!“

“We ordered catering to be delivered to the Bands of America competition and were very pleased with both the service and food! Serving 95 hungry students and over 20 parent volunteers can be challenging, and even more so when done out of state. Nick & Joe's made it super easy for us and we appreciate that!“

“We usually get the Brooklyn pie which we love!! We decided to try something different tonight. We got the chicken parm panini n the stuffed rigatoni with vodka sauce. Both were delicious!!“

“Very very DISAPPOINTING ☹️ They are good for basic Italian specialties and usually never had a problem. I am a regular customer and spend a good amount of money with them. Today was different. ordered the supposedly homemade baked penne pasta. it came sloshed in an oversized round container with only half the cheese on top and it was very runny. A monkey could have done better 😒🐒 Plenty of other places to get basic Italian 😒😒😒 I called to let them know about this and they didn't even offer to make it right 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️“

“I enjoyed eating here again, was awhile since I last dined in, glad it’s open now. I live about 25 minutes away from my closest Seasons, nice to eat the food fresh again, was delicious 😋“

“My husband had surgery yesterday and on the way home from the hospital he said he wanted chicken piccata. We ordered chicken piccata and chicken Marsala for takeout. Both were served over gnocchi. NEVER had such amazing gnocchi! Flavor of the piccata and Marsala—OUTSTANDING!!!!“

“Pier One is literally the first restaurant one sees on entering the historic downtown of North East. It's artwork including murals and stained glass, attract attention. There are three dining areas, including a moderate one at the entrance, a larger one in the back with a side entrance, and tables on the porch at the entrance. Staff are welcoming and efficient. I started with a delicious Bloody Mary in a mason jar with Old Bay on the rim. For an appetizer. A cup of Pasta Fagioli soup was a hearty starter for today's cooler weather. I large house salad was served with my main course which was a phenomenal Veal Roberto. The dish consisted of three thin slices of veal and two large shrimp sautéed with butter, and served with plentiful mushrooms in a madeira cream sauce, served over spaghetti. When I first looked at the serving sizes, I assumed I'd be taking some home, but I couldn't stop eating until the plate was empty and me happily full.“

“Great food and atmosphere!!“

“I have to say this was by far some of the best food I have ever had, customer service was great food was awesome! I’m happy I came here!“

“Excellent food, service, & dessert! Reese was our server on his first day!! He was excellent, very attentive! The pumpkin ravioli was delicious!!“

“Excellent service and delicious food at reasonable price for the quality.“

“Gnocchi were delicious. Next time there I'm getting something with meatballs. Friend gave me a bite of her's and it was perfect.“

“We love the tap room best food around 🦀🦀🦀🦀“

“Best cheese steak I've had in a long time. Roll was soft plenty of meat and the extras I ask for was their. Please don’t change what you did tonight 8/13. Love being able to get order through drive-thru. Thank you“

“Came here yesterday on the way home from work and it was the best decision I made all week. I saw this place had pupusas and had to try them and they did not disappoint. They are huge (I barely finished 1 lol) and they were so good. I will definitely be back, they are gonna be sick of me lmao.“

“stoll as good as it was 20 years ago when I was eating it for study fuel!“

“Going to Tony's is always a wonderful experience. The owners and staff are amazingly warm and friendly. And of course, the food is mouth watering delicious; the very best around.“

“Tony's is a local Italian restaurant in Newark along Chestnut Hill Road (DE 4) in a shopping plaza anchored by the local Shoprite. The dining area is basic, mostly what you'd expect from a local restaurant. However, the decor could use a little bit of an update and then it'd be just right.
The menu features what you'd expect from an Italian restaurant in the orbit of Philadelphia - pizzas, pastas, strombolis, etc. and have a great variety of different pizzas. For my meal, I went with a vegetarian pizza (spinach, tomato and ricotta cheese) and an order of garlic bread. The pizza itself was pretty tasty and the ricotta made a good contrast to the mozzarella on the pie itself and the vegetables were generally nice and fresh. The crust was also pretty decent as it could hold the slice and had just enough crisp for a good thin-crust pizza. The miss for me was the garlic bread. I don't know if it was the preparation for my particular order, but my bread had some minced garlic topping the butter on the bread rather than well-dispersed in the butter. I love garlic but trying to eat those pieces of minced garlic wasn't for me as it was bitter. I would like to see them better incorporate the garlic into the bread as that might help the read out. The garlic aside, the bread was nicely baked and had the butter and garlic been better spread I would have really enjoyed it.
The service was decent as well. I didn't have to wait too long for a refill and the server made sure I was take care of at my table.
Overall, it's a nice neighborhood Italian restaurant for those local to Newark and you'll at least get an enjoyable meal if you visit here.“

“best pizza around“

“My daughter is an UD student so we've tried most of the restaurants on Main St. and this was definitely the best we have had so far! It was family weekend so they were packed but the service was great and food delicious. I had the salmon, which was cooked perfectly. My daughter had the tortellini, which was delicious!“

“Took grandkids to 896 Pie today after a swim in the pool. Great service and amazing pizza. Brent is the owner and he was so friendly and engaged with his customers. All the grandkids and two adults enjoyed the perfectly cooked pizza. Thanks for a great visit“

“They are always so fast....one time they were behind, (not their fault) but gave us a free 2 liter before we could even think about complaining lol. Food is fresh and is good! never has a complaint. Drivers are always cool...always tip them!“

“The sauce is very watery. The meatball not homemade. I was disappointed“

“It was really good thanks!“

“Originated from Bklyn, NY; have lactose intolerance and tried this new tab. Wanted a Sicilian slice so bad for the last 2 decades, tried Amalfi. Definitely a good square, but can't say it's like NY, being honest. Probably NYC water in the end. Will definitely go back, thanks for the square, it was worth it!“

“I give them a five star ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ rating. I always knew this little shop was tucked in this shopping plaza but I never ever tried. Well let me just say I was missing out. I’ve now tried several different items and different pizzas and all of them have been delicious. You gotta try the BBQ beef cheesesteak (add extra meat and extra cheese) and BBQ chicken pizza. Wow 👍👍. I can tell they get slammed with takeout and delivery orders. Great staff. They’re my new go to.“

“amazing pizza would return to area just for this pizza“

“I ordered a build your own stromboli with 1 ingredient wrong and was mad at myself for forgetting the ingredient and settled for what I was getting. The manager said no I'll make you a new one I want you to be happy. I couldn't believe it it. When it arrived it was amazing so I highly recommend this seasons 5 stars“

“Second time ordering from here, food is fresh pizza is very good, and buffalo wings were good ,excellent service great customer service.“

“Great family owned restaurant here ! My family has had the pleasure of eating at a few of their locations. We can’t recommend them enough. They always have a happy go lucky staff. Fast and efficient. The food is always great. The fish and chips is my go to but the wife loves The chicken marsala. Always Satisfied“

“The bar can take over the restaurant making things loud and less than family friendly at times. Great food, friendly service. I almost always get the cheese pizza. In some ways, it is the taste of the beach for me. Takes me back to the days when they were only in Rehoboth.“