21 Best American Restaurants near New Windsor

1 Uncle Matty's Eatery

4.7 Superb 222 Reviews

142 Church Street, New Windsor

• Take-Out

“Had the Sweet Chili Tuna tonight, and it was easily the best meal I've had there yet, and I've never had a disappointing experience. Cooked to perfection, and the sauce had a spot-on level of sweetness and spice. The mashed potatoes, broccoli, and bed of spinach were a delicious accompaniment. We started with the cream of crab soup. Sitting in the dining area, watching the falling snow, and sipping a cup of coffee. What a great way to start the weekend.”

2 Maggie's Restaurant

4.4 Superb 907 Reviews

310 East Green Street, Westminster · 6.58 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“My 62nd birthday party event that I had at Maggie‘s restaurant was phenomenal. The food was excellent and everyone really enjoyed themselves. Our server Brian was a riot as always. My whole family and all my friends enjoyed as our server. He really made the special. Everyone really enjoyed themselves and said that the food was absolutely excellent.”

3 Baugher's Restaurant

4.4 Superb 218 Reviews

289 W Main St, Westminster · 5.95 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I’m always glad when I can support a locally owned restaurant, and Baugher’s never disappoints. The food is consistently good at a great price, and the staff is friendly, welcoming, and attentive to customers’ needs. It truly has that nice, hometown feeling that keeps you coming back.”

4 Flick's Pub and Restaurant

4.7 Superb 35 Reviews

100 Antrim Blvd, Taneytown · 7.74 miles

“I had one of the best crab cakes ever here at Flicks. The service and food was a 10. I highly recommend stopping in for a bite you will not be disappointed. My opinion best crab cake in carroll county.”

5 Plum Crazy Diner 2002

4.3 Superb 345 Reviews

15 Baltimore Boulevard, Westminster · 6.8 miles

• Take-Out

“Always enjoy having breakfast at Plum Crazy Diner. This is my favorite place to have breakfast! Tasty food, great service and still at a good price.”

6 Café Blue

4.4 Superb 59 Reviews

330 140 Village Rd, Westminster · 6.95 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I have only tried their ribeye cheesesteak and French fries, but I promise it is one of the best cheesesteaks I’ve ever had. Their other food looks delicious, but their cheesesteak is on my mind 24/7. The bread holds up the PILE of meat and cheese so well - soft, delicious, and dependable. It doesn’t fall apart or get soggy. The garlic aioli makes this sandwich even better. The garlic is not over powering and it makes the sandwich so creamy and tasty. They chop their tomatoes a bit so you don’t pull a whole full slice out when you take a bite (I greatly appreciate this attention to detail). The pickle slices are thick and delicious. The fries are thick, but not too thick & battered in a super crispy, delicious coating. I could eat this cheesesteak every day.”

7 The Smokehouse Restaurant at Antrim 1844

4.6 Superb 365 Reviews

30 Trevanion Road, Taneytown · 8.53 miles

“We've had dinner at the Smokehouse Restaurant several times for our anniversary over the years. The service has always been top notch and the food absolutely fabulous.”

8 Lost Lion

4.6 Superb 176 Reviews

27 East Main St Rear, Westminster · 6.42 miles

• Take-Out

“Lost lion has unique food and drinks and great service. It’s a gem in Westminster. Highly recommend.”

9 Sergio’s LLC

4.5 Superb 235 Reviews

330 140 Village Road, Westminster · 6.97 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Large Portions @ great prices!”

10 Baugher's Fruit Market & Bakery

4.5 Superb 183 Reviews

289 West Main Street, Westminster · 5.96 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Did the Apple picking, Market, and Family Restaurant. Fun and delicious.”

11 First Watch

4.4 Superb 188 Reviews

255 Baltimore Boulevard Suite 1, Westminster · 6.9 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I have nothing but good things to say about this place. Great food. Great service.”

12 Thunderhead Bowl & Grill

4.5 Superb 93 Reviews

4337 Old Taneytown Rd, Taneytown · 7.64 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We had an excellent team bonding experience at Thunderhead. The staff prepared delicious food and accommodated our large group with smiles and kindness. Thank you for a great time!”

13 Winfield Inn

4.5 Superb 72 Reviews

1616 West Old Liberty Road, Sykesville · 7.15 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“In spite of the disinformation on this website, they are *** OPEN 7 DAYS / Week ***”

14 The Grille at Challedon

4.3 Superb 40 Reviews

6166 Challedon Cir, Mt Airy · 9.14 miles

• Delivery

“Great layout, conditions and really great food.”

15 O'Lordan's Irish Pub

4.2 Good 162 Reviews

14 Liberty St, Westminster · 6.34 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Our first time here, a big family get-together to celebrate birthdays. The food and drinks were wonderful and our server Helena was amazing. Coming from a family with tons of customer service history, her skills were top. Thank you for the wonderful night out for our family, we'll definitely be back!”

16 The Stables at Westminster

3.8 Good 315 Reviews

452 East Main Street, Westminster · 6.91 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I was watching dean and the dunes river band , even bought a good amount of food and stuff. I follow everywhere since the kids were little.he was very close to my family and my mom.she had passed away not long ago and some of his songs hit hard especially her favorite.they kicked us out because I had an emotional break down and walked outside to much. but I want to thank Mandy Allen deans Merch lady for the much need comfort and support tonight”

17 Texas Roadhouse

4.1 Good 481 Reviews

21 South Cranberry Road, Westminster · 7.16 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I recommended indoor dining as we’ve never had an issue there. However, to-go orders seem to be a hit or miss.”

18 Bob Evans

4.0 Good 262 Reviews

206 Malcolm Drive, Westminster · 7.28 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Fast service and tastee food”

19 Applebee's Grill + Bar

4.0 Good 285 Reviews

634 Baltimore Boulevard, Westminster · 7.43 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The food was good. It was served hot and tasted as it was described on the menu. Our server was great. I was with a group of women and he got our orders correct and kept on top of drink refills. It's a chain restaurant: the atmosphere was nice. It was quiet enough to chat.”

20 Bullock's Restaurant

3.9 Good 177 Reviews

2020 Sykesville Road, Westminster · 6.77 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Outstanding Dining Experience. Best Fried Chicken I have had in years. Hot and Crispy Skin the Breast was moist and Juicy. The MD Crab had plenty of Crab . It seems to be homemade as Well. The Salad Bar was awesome. The Wait Staff took Dishes away . I would Highly recommend this Restaurant 5 out of 5 Stars”

21 IHOP

3.7 Good 287 Reviews

490 Meadow Creek Drive, Westminster · 5.96 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Very good service the are very nice people and kindly”